Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 9th January 2009 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Sir Sean Connery takes swipe at the state of Capital



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 August 2008
SIR Sean Connery has launched a series of outspoken attacks on the state of modern Edinburgh and the way the city is run in his eagerly-awaited memoirs.
The 77-year-old screen legend laments what he sees as various threats to the heritage of his home city and criticises the role of the council and other authorities.

In his book, Being a Scot – which is published today and will be formally launched by the James Bond star at the Book Festival on Monday – Sir Sean:

• Suggests Historic Scotland is "whoring" the country's heritage

• Expresses "outrage" at Network Rail adding the pre-fix Edinburgh to Waverley Station

• Hits out at the "dark tourism" on the Royal Mile

• Warns that the Capital "could soon" lose its prestigious world heritage status

• Blasts the council-run Mary King's Close as a "Disneyfied haunted-house experience"

• Expresses his disappointment at the lack of official backing for a controversial new Filmhouse in Festival Square.

But he saves his most stinging criticism for Historic Scotland, saying it was "dreadfully depressing" to see it promoting a witch trial re-enactment.

He accuses the government agency of "celebrating 16th century misogyny", adding: "In Spain I learnt that they call such corruption of heritage in the name of tourism la puteria, or the 'whoring', of the culture."

He also blasts the rail "bureauprats" who appear to have renamed the city's main station Edinburgh Waverley, describing how he was "outraged" to see the extended name that now adorns signs there. The station, he points, out was named after the Sir Walter Scott novel.

The screen legend, who was born and grew up in Fountainbridge, also expresses his fears for the future of the Capital's built heritage.

Highlighting the ongoing investigation by Unesco into the city's World Heritage Site status, following major development plans such as Caltongate, he warns that Edinburgh "could soon lose" the prestigious title.

The city's planners should take a leaf out of Copenhagen's book, he suggests, to learn how to preserve a historic landscape.

Although he praises the "imaginative" work of Edinburgh architects Allan Murray, Malcolm Fraser, Richard Murphy, Charlie Sutherland and Charlie Hussey, he deplores the general standard of new buildings springing up across the city.

"Each time I return to the city I am shocked at the mediocre quality of the new architecture," he says. "And now even the cobbles of the New Town are being asphalted over, street by street."

Sir Sean also bemoans the lack of support for the controversial proposal to build a new home for the Film Festival in Festival Square.

Praising architect Richard Murphy's "beautiful" designs for the proposed building, he says the film centre – which would carry Sir Sean's name – would cement the city's international reputation and stage exciting events throughout the year.

He also describes finding that few people at the city council appreciated that Edinburgh had an international reputation within the cinema industry.

Sir Sean also talks approvingly about the Scottish Parliament building and Olorosso restaurant.

More extracts from Sir Sean's autobiography, Being a Scot



The full article contains 524 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 21 August 2008 12:59 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Sean Connery
 
1

Grouchy,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 12:06:54
Given that he doesn't live here and contribute to the upkeep of the city I think he's got some nerve.
2

Paranoid John from Midlothian,

21/08/2008 12:08:28
Time to go back to making films me thinks...and eagerly awaited by who?
3

Libra Hibby,

21/08/2008 12:13:30
"It really didn't bother me that much at the time," he says. "I never grasped that it was arrant snobbery. For me it just meant more time off for soccer."

Obviously part of his state side sales pitch. Its called 'Fitbaw' sean. No one here calls it soccer.
4

Andrew Kent,

EDINBURGH 21/08/2008 12:15:08
He's right, the way Edinburgh is run these days is a disgrace.
5

Liz,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 12:15:21
#1
I could not agree with you more.

I find this strange:
" Expresses "outrage" at Network Rail adding the pre-fix Edinburgh to Waverley Station"

'Outrage' really?! surely there are more outragous things going on in the world than a train company including the name of the city in the name of its main railway station..... Who outside Edinburgh knows where 'Waverley' is?
6

Steve_HMFC,

21/08/2008 12:18:13
Will Salmond be able to convive him to come home next year then?

This is a guy that switched from supporting Celtic to Rangers even though he had no connection to either club in the first place.

And a guy who supports Scottish Nationalism so much, he doesnt think Scotland is good enough to live in.

And dint he say it was ok to slap your wife around every now and again?

Brilliant actor, but talks a load of p1sh
7

John Knox furr First Meenister,

High St, Embra 21/08/2008 12:19:04
Hits out at the "dark tourism" on the Royal Mile.
Hmmm... a slur on the ethicity of many who run tartan tat shops? Shoorly shome mistake!
8

Indy Rep Kid...,

21/08/2008 12:19:20
"Sir Sean also talks approvingly about the Scottish Parliament building and Olorosso restaurant."

Good to see the wife-beater has his priorities inthe right place.

I preferred Roger Moore.
9

Cheradenine,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 12:19:35
#6 I'm not so sure Liz, there was a collective tantrum on these boards a few weeks ago when it was revealed that (shock! horror!) councillors do not always return their cutlery to the office canteen!

10

Tofeeman,

north of Liverpool 21/08/2008 12:21:15
Stick to comments about waterfronts in Marbella not somewhere you don't pay tax.
11

Libra Hibby,

21/08/2008 12:24:04
Brilliant actor ?

Didn't he win an Oscar for portraying an Irish cop with a scottish accent. On a par with Dick Van Dyck's cockney accent in Mary Poppins.

And where did his 'shpeech impediment' appear from.
12

aurorablue,

21/08/2008 12:25:00
He is only an elderly actor and his words do not mean anything, he has no intellect and doesn't even live here. What a load of codswallop!!!
13

Edinburghs Finest,

21/08/2008 12:25:24
He is just an over-rated p*sh actor who admits to hitting woman so I honestly couldn't give a monkeys what he thinks from his tax exile haven.
14

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 12:28:10
The man does more for Scotland than all the whingers on here put together,whether living here or not. I'm looking forward to reading the book.
15

JT,

21/08/2008 12:28:43
#1 totally agree, whilst he will be regarded as the best bond, it really grates me that he is so vocal about the state of the capital, yet lives and works abroad for tax reasons. Having said that he does have some valid points, such as the state of the royal mile tat that is on sale.
16

,

21/08/2008 12:30:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

Sports for Edinburgh,

21/08/2008 12:30:49
#14 - how?
18

aurorablue,

21/08/2008 12:33:02
#14 - what has he done for scotland exactly? (Except for slagging off the capital?)
19

Paranoid John from Midlothian,

21/08/2008 12:33:40
#14...really? You'll be first in the queue then no matter when you go for it. Wonder what he doesn't like about the council...council tax? bins not getting emptied? ahh won't be that cause he duzzn't live here. Wish you could report a whole article as unsuitable.
20

I love to eat Sellotape,

21/08/2008 12:33:45
By way of reply, we are entitled to hear what modern Edinburgh thinks of the current state of Sean Connery.
21

Trams shams,

21/08/2008 12:34:04
Whilst Sean may be away from the place his critisms are spot on and it may be that we're so close the the mess that we can not see it. I believe Edinburgh is on a full unstoppable downward slippy slope and we're going to be passing that West coast City very shortly.
22

Libra Hibby,

21/08/2008 12:34:52
#14.

What does he do for Scotland ?
23

Sports for Edinburgh,

21/08/2008 12:39:55
Whilst I do think there are some very valid points here, I must say that if Edinburgh were to remain static and not progress our economy would be... well... non existent. Looking at economic figures from the likes of the Bank of England, and those published via the BBC, Edinburgh is one of the very few areas of the UK that looks set to be able to be self sufficient through any economic downturn (in terms of localised income and employment) – this is due to inward investment and tourism. If Historic Scotland is ‘whoring’ our heritage, it’s working in terms of visitor numbers and therefore the employment. I do see the point here, but a visit to a heritage attraction (anywhere) shows a dramaticised representation of the past.

In terms of Caltongate – I partly agree. However, the place as it is is depressing, and almost useless. I love ‘historic edinburgh’, but a ‘useful edinburgh’ is also appealing.
24

Keith 1,

Edinburgh, UK 21/08/2008 12:42:07
#14

Looks like your a lone voice here.

Sean certainly doesn't do very much for Edinburgh that I can see. He does market kilts once a year in the US. If he likes Scotland/Edinburgh so much why does he not have a home here?
25

Peedie Paws,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 12:42:21
#11 - he got his 'shpeech impediment' when he got false teeth. Clearly, he doesn't use polygrip!
26

Sports for Edinburgh,

21/08/2008 12:43:58
I also think (after re-reading many comments), to say “yes, he’s right” or “no, he’s not” is not possible. This is his opinion that has been sensationalised by the EEN. We all have our own opinions regarding Edinburgh (just look at the trams for instance). But to say one person is right or wrong is just not possible. Perhaps, that is what makes this article so ‘awkward’ – we all have our own views (and motivations), and I am sure they are all different.
27

Sports for Edinburgh,

21/08/2008 12:45:18
#21 - move then.
28

Wee Keef,

Not in Scotland, that's for sure 21/08/2008 12:57:04
What really gets me is that the EEN thinks this is front page news.

Also, The Times is heavily advertising their serialisation of his book. If you haven't heard the radio advert, it's great. It tells us that, after many years, Sean finally breaks his silence and speaks out.

What blummin silence was that? The man never shuts up.
29

Labradoodle,

21/08/2008 13:01:16
it is his SNP that are partly running the council...
30

Buttress,

21/08/2008 13:02:54
Hang on a cotton pickin' minute - it's Allan Murray that UNESCO is concerned about...

www.eh8.org.uk
31

YummyMummy,

21/08/2008 13:05:57
I agree with the tat on the Royal Mile and the 'ghost tours' being, well, tacky. But it is for the tourists and doesnt really effect me.
32

Niko Bellic,

Sing Sing 21/08/2008 13:08:46

Hearing Sean offer up his opinions is not unlike listening to the ramblings of Prince Charles. It's a self important voice booming out, with no influence.

Charlie Windsor - moans about architecture, and gives ill-advised somments about nanotechnology

Sean Connery - moans about architecture and gives ill-advised comments about ghost tours.

I do think people should calm down about the, err Connery spousal chastisement thing, though. It is one out of context quote from nearly thirty years ago. Irrelevant to this discussion.

As for the 'whoring' of Scotland's heritage - yeh, like 'Highlander' was social realism directed by Ken Loach, wasn't it?
33

Iain Bhern,

21/08/2008 13:10:00
Mr Connery is an ignorant bufoon. He should live here, pay rates and vote for councillors. Then and only then does he have the right to criticise!
34

Phil MaGlass,

Holland 21/08/2008 13:16:19
Seems that most of you have your heid up yir erses,the guy like masel can see the state the Capital is getting into,theres a lot more than what was mentioned on here that is wrong with Edinburgh, but as usual you attack him,yes he doesnt stay in Scotland,yes he doesnt pay taxes in Scotland,Im the same,doesnt mean we dont not love our city,and when things are wrong they should be righted,Edinburgh is in a right state, from the Royal Mile to Princes Street it is pretty abysmal.
No quality shops in sight or if they are they are crowded out by cheap,loud, bagpipe playing tacky shops(what about fininf these shops for noise pollution). I was just back this weekend,whit a state the city is in(not including the dug up roads all over the city and Leith).
Edinburgh may well lose its UNESCO status but it wont worry these councillors a jot they are only interested in their own agendas and not making the CAPITAL the capital it should be.
Its just a pity it takes someone(Connery) who doesnt live in the capital to actually come out and tell us what we already know,Edinburgh is turning into a 5hithole,if it isnt already.
I have noticed that when you have left the city for a while,after you come back you notice in a big way the changes(not for the better) and the inhabitants hardly notice through a slow creep of changes(bad)you take it as the norm,trust me alot of people wont be rushing back to the Capital.I also have to add that the Tattoo this year was very disappointing,very bland,boring and predictable,time for a revamp(and not only the seating).
35

Linmal,

Livingston 21/08/2008 13:28:00
#33 Sir Sean Connery is not ignorant and it is his choice where he lives. Given the recent weather, where would you rather be? (Actually I prefer Edinburgh and the Lothians to anywhere else in the world, but that is my choice).

However, no matter what we may think of Sir Sean, many of his comments are spot on. It is not just this Council, the rot started in Edinburgh many years ago with the way they allowed first the architecture in Princes Street to be demolished for "modern" buildings in what was once a beautiful street. Then it extended to the rest of this once beautiful city. It will take a lot to put Edinburgh right, but it could be done.

And that abomination at the foot of the Royal Mile (the Parliament, not the Palace) what on earth were they thinking when they build that piece of concrete nonsense!

Also its time the so-called posh people of Edinburgh were told, not asked, to have wheelie bins. They seem to think it is not in keeping with the New Town.

Well just walk through the New Town on bin day as I did this morning and you will see the number of burst bags and their contents littering the streets. Wheelie bins would solve the problem in an instant. If you go to West Lothian or any area where they have been used now for about twenty years you will not see one tenth of the litter that there is in Edinburgh.

Maybe I'm not entitled to my say either as I don't live in Edinburgh, but I was brought up in Edinburgh and still work there, just can't afford the extortionate property prices (unless I want to live in a studio flat or something). Bit if I win the lottery I'll be back! I love Scotland and Edinburgh in particular, so there!
36

macCol,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 13:29:51
Well Mr Connery

If you are so concerned about the state of Scotland, why don't you come and live here, pay taxes and then you can justifiably complain about it.

Until you do, then I and many many others have no interest in what you say.

You keep claiming you're such a proud Scot. If that is the case, then why not live here and do something about it.

I'm sick of your whining from a distance. It must be hell living in Switzerland (or wherever you do now) and seeing the disgraceful treatment of the Royal Mile, or the Waverly station or etc.

So PLEASE PLEASE shut up unless you are prepared to do something about it.
37

married to a teacher,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 13:31:10
Going along princes street in a bus the other night at 8.pm the only shops open were Starbucks, Prode of Scotland (????) and discount bookesellers. It reminded me of being in barcelona - not!
38

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

21/08/2008 13:33:53
Connery reckons: "In Spain I learnt that they call such corruption of heritage in the name of tourism la puteria, or the 'whoring', of the culture."

My partner had her bag snatched by a motorcyclist within 6 hours of our arrival in Spain. The police were too busy watching soccer to be interested. I paid a lot extra to get us out of there within another six hours and I won't be back. It's a bandit-ridden fleapit of a country.
39

The faithful=,

21/08/2008 13:34:57
Sir seans right,open your eyes and look around Edinburgh,it looks like a sunday car boot sale up the mile.
40

Scotish Exile,

21/08/2008 13:35:50
Sean,

Some of your comments may have some merit, but please don't comment until you back and live here and pay your taxes like the rest of us!
41

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

21/08/2008 13:38:15
All this from a guy whose claim to fame is that he took a role after Patrick McGoohan turned it down.

Here's a Clue Connery: if you pay taxes here, you get a say in how things are run.

If you don't: STFU.
42

Alan R,

edinburgh 21/08/2008 13:42:04
As a 'fading' film star perhaps this individual could put something back to improve things. As a nod to his former career perhaps he could dip into his pocket and help restore the Odeon on South Clerk Street - I am sure some of his cinematic exploits must have been shown there? It would be a start...
43

I love to eat Sellotape,

21/08/2008 13:46:13
I for one am very interested in what Sir Sean has to say. Among other things, I would like to know what he makes of public toilets in Morrison Street.
44

PaulB,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 13:47:48
What a cheek this man has. A multi-millionaire living in tax exile daring to lecture us on our own city. Perhaps he should come here to live permanently, pay tax then he might have more credibility. Stay in Spain you old pain and stop moaning about things that don't concern you!
45

tomias,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 13:50:07
What a waste of postings-again
46

The Judge,

21/08/2008 13:54:00
You people make me laugh, Sir Sean had given more to charity than all of you dole scrounging, scheme dwelling parasites will have paid in tax in the whole of your sad little life.

He is absolutely spot on with everything he says about Edinburgh. If I had his money I wouldn't live here either, its a backward thinking city plagued with neds, junkies, jakies and other assorted bampots. Worst still we allow ourself to be lorded over by third rate career politicos who would jump ship if they though their seat was in danger and who's only interest is screwing the tax payer for every penny they can get.
47

JamboG,

Florida 21/08/2008 13:55:08
Im proudly Scottish but dont live or pay tax in the country anymore either. Still love the city of Edinburgh though, agree with most of what Sean Connery says, and dont see why both he and I shouldnt be allowed to comment. At times it does feel like it is becoming a parody of itself...walking down the Royal Mile among all those discount tartan and shortbread shops is indeed "sinister".

48

NYC Hibee,

edinburgh 21/08/2008 13:55:17
what does he know about being a Scot? He turned his back on Edinburgh years ago. Who cares what he thinks about our city - it's obviously not good enough for him to live here!
49

Bling Crosby,

21/08/2008 13:55:18
wife beating Scottish golfer Sean Connery should shut his mouth about things that don't concern him.
50

YummyMummy,

21/08/2008 14:01:34
The fact he doesn't live here backs up his veiws dont you think?
51

yorkshirepudding,

Coming to Edinburgh soon 21/08/2008 14:02:10
Sean Connery keeps banging on about being a Scot but spends the most part away in the sunshine of Marbella. He's not doing himself any favours by slating Edinburgh. In fact he does not do himself any favours when he opens his mouth these days. I think his wife needs to give him a good slap and hopefully he will come to his senses.
52

Celtic Fan Steven,

21/08/2008 14:18:08
14 Please tell the group what exactly he does for Scotland!???

The guy is an arsh-ole
53

Digby Hepplethwaite,

21/08/2008 14:27:54
Yeah, Connery - if you hate Edinburgh so much, why don't you come and live here!

(At least I think that's what you're all saying.)
54

Prin the Dissolving Donkey,

21/08/2008 14:33:07
Yeah! YEAH!

We DARE you to live over here, you ... you ... you ... RICH ACTOR!
55

THE BPRENTICE,

21/08/2008 14:33:45
IMO ex-pats are entitled to their opinion, Scotland will be important to them AND they have the power of being removed form the situation ... so they see it more clearly.

To be fair Sean Connery has made some decent points (especially the Historic Scotland Puntana International point) - maybe we should be as concerned as someone who doesn't pay tax here?

Maybe its a wake-up call to a lot of us?

However, he didn't say anything about the amounts of money spent on installing Trams in Edinburgh plus the Parliament (...aaargh!) - surely we could be spending the money better in other areas eg. education and transport ALL OVER SCOTLAND ...not just Edinburgh?!
56

THE BPRENTICE,

21/08/2008 14:34:29
The comment about Edinburgh having an 'international reputation within the cinema industry' made me laugh ... yeah lets see the Cannes 'beautiful luvvies' marvel at the closed Odeon on South Clerk Street and then fastrack them over to Westerhailes to have their seats kicked by local ned population ... enjoy yer films guys!
57

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 14:36:27
From The Sunday TimesApril 8, 2007

I’ll return if Scotland goes independent, pledges Connery.
Sir Sean Connery, the Scottish actor, has said he intends to return to live in his homeland after 50 years if Scotland votes for independence.

The former Bond star, who now lives in the Bahamas, has also revealed plans to act as an international roving ambassador for the country.

Connery, 76, who moved to London in the late 1950s and then to the south of Spain in the early 1970s, has always rebutted suggestions that he is a tax exile. Last year, he claims to have paid £500,000 in tax to HM Revenue & Customs despite living abroad.

The long-time supporter and benefactor of the Scottish National party (SNP) is closely following the political developments in Scotland. With the SNP riding high in the polls and promising a referendum on independence in three years if it wins the Scottish parliament election, Connery believes his lifelong dream of a separate Scottish state is within reach.

This is the man who promotes Scotland all over the world, gives generously to charity and has paid £500.000 in taxes to HM Revenue and Taxes and still you come on here asking what he has done for Scotland and accuse him of avoiding taxes. Your not fit to lace his boots.
58

livislosin,

21/08/2008 14:38:30
...and he must know that Edinburgh could do with a good wash too.
59

Farmernot,

21/08/2008 14:43:34
Shpot on Shir Sean
60

eric,

Lothian 21/08/2008 14:46:54
Well shed shir shawn
61

PaulB,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 14:48:09
Judge and Clamper - GTF! Ignorant idiots.
62

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 14:48:20
"Sean Connery believes in helping others.
He has donated to and supported literally hundreds of charities. One little known fact about Sir Sean's philanthropy is that he donated his entire salary (well over $1 million) from his Bond film Diamonds Are Forever to the Scottish International Educational Trust which he co-founded. This generous grant — like his many other gifts — has benefited the lives of thousand of ordinary Scots. While not all of the many worthy charities he supports are mentioned on this site, Sir Sean would like you to consider helping others as he has."

Another example for all you doubters out there asking "what has he done for Scotland".
63

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 14:53:14
#61 Try doing some research before you come on here spouting rubbish.
64

PaulB,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 14:55:59
#63 I really don't care for your views, or sean's!
65

ian Moran,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 14:56:11
whywhwywhwy do people always have a go at Sean its pathetic.
66

tertee,

21/08/2008 14:56:47
Of Course and he kept his gifts secret in case people thought it was PR. DUH
67

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

21/08/2008 15:03:21
#57 A Clampit was spot on when he pointed out the situation:

Vote Unionist, or Sean Connery will return!
68

Vision Girl,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 15:10:37
I prefer Roger Moore personaly!!!

And if Sean Connery thinks Edinburgh is such a mess then I assume thats why he doesn't live here anymore?
69

Buttress,

21/08/2008 15:15:38
Highlighting the ongoing investigation by Unesco into the city's World Heritage Site status, following major development plans such as Caltongate, he warns that Edinburgh "could soon lose" the prestigious title.

The city's planners should take a leaf out of Copenhagen's book, he suggests, to learn how to preserve a historic landscape.

Although he praises the "imaginative" work of Edinburgh architects Allan Murray, Malcolm Fraser, Richard Murphy, Charlie Sutherland and Charlie Hussey, he deplores the general standard of new buildings springing up across the city.

"Each time I return to the city I am shocked at the mediocre quality of the new architecture," he says. "And now even the cobbles of the New Town are being asphalted over, street by street."

CALTONGATE

Architect: (and Masterplanner) Allan Murray

Architect: Malcolm Fraser.

HAYMARKET TOWER

Architect: Richard Murphy...


So many other schemes - Allan Murray.

www.eh8.org.uk
70

Hamish Scott,

21/08/2008 15:17:32
Sean Connery is from Edinburgh and has every right to comment on the city (presumably the posters who think he has to live here to be free to comment have never commented to anyone about events in Georgia, Iraq, or anywhere else where they don't live).
His comments are spot on. The way Edinburgh sells itself in terms of history/heritage, the planning decisions, the lack of support for a film centre, even renaming Waverley, he nails it.
71

Ron Ross,

21/08/2008 15:17:56
Why are some of the posters on here so defensive? Why attack the man because you don't like what he says?

Because he doesn't live in Scotland, you tell him to "Begger off" with his comments. If he DID live in Scotland and made the same remarks, he'd undoubtedly be told "If you don't like it here, begger off!"

Many of his comments are valid. Why are so few people on here interested in constructive suggestions, regardless of who makes them?
72

blackley,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 15:28:49
I think he's right. I'm surprised they didn't go really loopey and call the station Edinburgh's Waverley!
73

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 15:30:01
HA HA HA HA HA HA!

Soo once again Charles is right, when he took a swipe on the disgraceful state of Edinburgh, all the proof is here in the EEN and Scotsman News.
74

ecky,

newcastle 21/08/2008 15:36:57
he slags edinburgh off yet still happy to stay in his penthouse flat at top of caledonian hotel
75

Andy Pandy,

Loanhead 21/08/2008 15:46:00
Eagerly awaited memoirs? Don't think so - his views are almost as boring as his acting.

But then he's my favourite comment board for the EEN along with trams, Kenny Richey, JK Rowling and Charlie Miller advertorials. Passes the time of a dull afternoon.
76

bigladatthebackpost,

edinburgh 21/08/2008 15:56:11
What does Timothy Dalton think about all thish?
77

Mikey,

21/08/2008 15:57:12
It's really weird listening to all the anti Connery ranters! Just days ago, they were all telling us how bad the cooncil is and Now that Connery agrees with them, they all think the cooncil's great! What's the matter boys and girls, can London not make up your mind for you?
78

Andy Pandy,

Loanhead 21/08/2008 15:57:54
#76 - I think Timothy says Edinburgh looks just great to him and can't understand why that whingeing ex-Scot goes on and on about it from his luxury home in a tax free land?
79

Ghengis McCann,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 16:18:28
What's really weird is the way all the kneejerk Braveheart apologists come on here to defend the buffoonish, misogynist MSP for Marbella East - a man who loves Scotland so much he hasn't lived or paid taxes here for decades.

If Gary Glitter declared himself as a Gnat, you'd no doubt all be on here saying he was just misunderstood or something. You really are pathetic.

PS playing golf with King Smug and bankrolling the Gnats doesn't qualify as a charitable work.

80

likkitysplit,

Mishtified 21/08/2008 16:50:17
Ho!...I shinsherely hope that the EEN isnt mishrepresenting scotlands most famoush shon and making him shound like an old faart by shimply shelecting particular captions from the book and ignoring any poshitive asshertions he may or may not have had.

eh EEN?
81

jambobones,

21/08/2008 16:55:05
well done sir sean. he only echos what i believe of this city, RUN INTO THE GROUND BY INCOMPETENTS OVER A LONG PERIOD OF TIME. however the blame does not solely lie there its up to the muppet voters of this city who always return the same incompetents to power. SHEEP MENTALITY HAS LED TO THIS PROBLEM.
82

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

21/08/2008 16:57:31
#75: They're at least as eagerly awaited as Gary Glitter's comeback tour.

P.S: George Lazenby was the best Bond.
83

I C Weiner,

21/08/2008 17:04:45
I wish this condoner of wife beating would keep nose out of Edinburgh's business and clear off back to California. The last time he lived here he was delivering milk the 1920s or something.
He's only sticking his oar in becasue nobody'll put him in a film these days.
84

go on go on ,

livingston 21/08/2008 17:06:36
Know i kno why my old man used to batter this turn coat old firm lover.WTF would he kno about edinburgh let alone pass comment on it ,He should live here if he,s so interested in what goe on .old pr8ck
85

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 17:09:44
#79 Ghengis, repeating the same old myths about tax and charity over and over again isn't going to convince anyone. The fact is he does pay taxes and does benefit charities in Scotland. What's your problem, don't you believe the Scottish International Educational Trust exists or that HM Taxes and Revenues
have recieved £500,000 from the man ?
86

A. Puschkin,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 17:12:26

If we can only comment if we live here - we will become short sighted. We need comments from people who love Scotland - do not necessarily live here - and who can state opinions that we might otherwise not hear.

Carltongate is a disgrace
Princes Street could be Blackpool
We could lose our right to be a City of Heritage.

I agree with JamBog Florida below

JamboG,Florida 21/08/2008 13:55:08
Im proudly Scottish but dont live or pay tax in the country anymore either. Still love the city of Edinburgh though, agree with most of what Sean Connery says, and dont see why both he and I shouldnt be allowed to comment. At times it does feel like it is becoming a parody of itself...walking down the Royal Mile among all those discount tartan and shortbread shops is indeed "sinister".
87

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 17:36:37
In his new book 'Being an Iberno-Bahamian', Sir Sean tells how he gets a real feel for the city of his birth on his regular chauffeur-driven journies between the airport and the Balmoral......
88

ridgie,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 17:38:46
This man only uses Scotland to get himself in the papers. He chose to leave and avoid paying tax here but insists in voicing his opinion on a country he abandoned many years ago. Anyone foolish enough to buy his pathetic book is only encouraging his constant rambling about 'when i was a milkman'! Try a new record Sean and shut up!
89

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 17:46:31
#88 He does,repeat does, pay taxes.
90

archie12,

21/08/2008 17:47:19
I bet a good number of those condemning Connery's comments were neither born nor live in Edinburgh. At least its the city of his birth, I think that entitles him to have an opinion. And isn't he also a Freeman of Edinburgh?
91

SPG,

edinburgh 21/08/2008 17:58:54
I agree with Shir Shean. This shity's a hitehole.
92

NorT,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 18:08:11
It is called Edinburgh Waverley to distinguish it from the other stattion in Edinburgh, Edinburgh Haymarket. Anyway he does not live here.
93

bully wee alba,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 18:34:26
I rarely venture into the realms of the foaming at the mouth unionista cringers, however, I decided to make today an exception and have a look at the standard of their comments.

There appears to be a common thread running through their sadly predictable and jealously ridden responses to the Sean Connery article.

Apparently Connery is a “misogynic wife beater”, “avoids paying tax”, “has done nothing for Scotland”, “has no right to comment”, “has a speech impediment”, “doesn’t pay rates(sic)”, “is an ignorant buffoon”, etc, etc.

There you have it. The Unionist cringe exposed both tooth and claw.

Any suggestion that a Scotsman, (or Scotland), should be portrayed as being successful, vibrant and progressive, must be disparaged, met with abuse, and generally ridiculed.

What a sad mind-set these characters have!

I’m so glad we are chasing them.
94

tsongkhapa,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 18:36:00
Listen to him, he is a god amongst gods and brought the milk to many a door when he was a wee boy. Praise be to Sean may his name live forever in the annals of the capital's history. He is above us and has all the riches that he deserves and resides in a sunny place away from the rain and floods that are cast upon us.
95

Andrew,

21/08/2008 18:47:14
Scorn Shammery! Either stay in the UK or shut up!!!
96

Andrew,

21/08/2008 18:48:37
86) Princes Street won't quite emulate Blackpool until the trams return!!
97

charliecha cha,

21/08/2008 18:56:41
tax avoiding,wife beating,old firm supporter.connery is a disgrace to edinburgh
98

Andrew,

21/08/2008 19:01:14
There's "Edinburgh Waverley" and "Edinburgh Park" (SOMEWHAT CONFUSING) and HAYMARKET (which is STILL & always was simply "Haymarket" - the other Haymarket being on the Metro system in Newcastle)! What if all stations with the suffix Central were simply called
"Central". "A single to Central please"! WHICH ONE? (out of dozens?)!! Coatbridge, Dumbarton, Glasgow, Greenock, Hamilton, Helensburgh, (to name but just 6 examples in Scotland alone)!
99

Andrew Scalloway,

Edinburgh 21/08/2008 19:32:48
Jeez you guys should use your time more usefully. Why not take up w@nking? You'd all be good at it.
100

Hamish Scott,

21/08/2008 19:40:57
#92
"It is called Edinburgh Waverley to distinguish it from the other stattion in Edinburgh, Edinburgh Haymarket. Anyway he does not live here."

Eh? How confusing is 'Waverley' and 'Haymarket'? How does adding 'Edinburgh'to BOTH of them help?
101

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

21/08/2008 20:07:02
With Councillor Tom Buchanan being put in charge of anything, Sir Sean is right to be concerned about the way our Council is being run.
102

Andrew,

21/08/2008 21:30:11
99) Taking up winking is taking the mikey!!
103

Andrew,

21/08/2008 21:31:06
Or should that be taking the "mickey"?!!
104

sligohibee,

21/08/2008 22:07:57
97. not to mention all the Bond birds
105

Eye glass,

Derby 21/08/2008 23:23:02
I am very sorry to hear that Edinburgh is encouraging a cheap money making scheme based on the dreadful tragedies of so-called 'witch trials'. These really and truly happened not so long ago, in Edinburgh, among other towns . Shocking that no Edinburgh voices are raised in protest. Have Edinburgh people no spirit of protest these days?
106

Casey Beer,

21/08/2008 23:35:18
He's sounding more and more like a bitter and twisted old bloke. I'm sure things were better in his day. Ha!
107

yorkshirepudding,

yorkshire 22/08/2008 01:29:10
what i like about this is you lot actually have something to say. Nice going and interesting debate.
I love to eat sellotape - i only come along to see what you have to say along with Phil MaGlass - the name gives away the fact that you are intelligent and imaginative.
Look forward to reading you all soon.
108

particle,

Perth, Australia 22/08/2008 02:16:33
Oh dear, seems to be a lot of recycling going on with the comments. If you don't have something interesting, new or amusing to add to the argument, why bother?

I haven't lived in Scotland for 6 years, but I love coming back for visits. It truly is a beautiful and welcoming country. Yes, there are unsavoury parts of the country, however this is not solely applicable to Scotland.

What I have found on my visits though, is that I am able to be objective in my thinking and see what is happening in Edinburgh and other parts of the country. Whatever I may think of Sean Connery, I cannot deny that he is right and he is entitled to his opinion.

What if the EEN had published only pos