Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 9th January 2009 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Simon hooked on removing 60 bras a minute . . one-handed



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 September 2008
FOR many men it is one of the more daunting features of a woman's wardrobe.
But instead of shying away from the tricky business of unhooking bras, an Edinburgh property manager is going to tackle as many as he can in one minute to raise money for charity.

And as if that wasn't difficult enough, he'll have to do it all one-handed.

Simon Keane, 27, from Viewforth, will put his unusual talent to the test to get his name in the record books and raise funds for breast cancer research. He is confident of beating the world record for the task, which stands at 42.

Friend Robyn Keystone, 24, who lives on the Grassmarket, is organising the event in the Finnegan's Wake pub on Victoria Street on October 31.

Simon said: "It's something I've always known I could do. Then I read an article about the world record and thought, I could do that. I talked about it with some friends, and they all thought it was a bit of a laugh.

"I thought some people might be a bit disturbed by it, but they think it's for a good cause.

"I thought it would be really appropriate to raise money for breast cancer. Most people know someone who's been affected by the disease. It's something I'm really keen to support, as my aunt died of it a few years ago."

Simon said one difficulty was practising his skills in the run-up to the event.

"I've got a group of people who are letting me practice, although it might be hard to get enough women together before the event. I think I should do it.

"I think one per second is quite achievable."

Robyn has taken charge of finding 60 volunteers who are willing to have their bra snapped off in an instant.

She said: "We've got a good few of our friends who are willing to do it but to get 60 we've been approaching people at random on the street and once we've explained what it's all about they've been really positive and willing to help out.

"Everyone knows someone who's been affected in some way by breast cancer and when we were talking of ways to do something to raise money this seemed like the best way to do it. It seems to be Simon's speciality, and at first he was pretty confident, but as the event becomes more official and we get closer to the date he's getting a bit nervous.

"I really hope people see it for what it is and react well to it – it's a bit of fun."

Along with fellow students Sabina Ahmadov, 22, and Leah Robinson, 25, Robyn has made contact with the Guinness Book of World Records about the event and they said they may send an adjudicator to the event.

They have timed it to coincide with the last official day of Breast Cancer Awareness Month and are hoping to get an underwear shop to sponsor them by supplying 60 pink bras for the event.


The full article contains 518 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 September 2008 10:45 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

alex paterson,

edinburgh 08/09/2008 12:17:33
Simon if you get stuck give me a phone i will be glad to help you,anything for charity.
2

Skip McClendon,

08/09/2008 12:19:08
If he manages this challenge, he immediately jumps to the top of my "heroes" list, ahead of Chris Hoy and Andy Murray.

60 bras off in 60 seconds? Now THAT is a talent I'd like to have.
3

Edinburghs Finest,

08/09/2008 12:41:20
If you look at the picture he appears to be unhooking a bra whilst punching another volunteer in the nether regions...thats not very appreciative!

4

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 12:55:51
I'm sorry, as a woman I find this to be totally degrading and not to be encouraged. It is completely and utterly disrespecting women and is tawdry and abhorrent.

I am all for helping out with Breast Cancer Charities, my own daughter ran an event a couple of years ago in support of the Breast Cancer Institute at the Western General Hospital, where we raised more than £3,000 and no-one had to stoop to this level and we continue to support various charities in this field.

Surely there are less degrading ways of highlighting breast cancer and encouraging support for those who work so tirelessly to eradicate it?
5

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 13:10:23
#6 Thank you, I agree with your second point.

And yes, these people must volunteer their services but I totally disagree with them. They are not helping the cause of women and in fact I think it is totally indecent.

Well done to them for volunteering but I am sure they could have found a more tasteful way of supporting breast cancer charities.
6

Mist001,

Marseille 08/09/2008 13:14:55
I agree with #5. I think it is degrading, there are better ways for raising awareness of breast cancer than unhooking 60 bras in 60 seconds.

Sounds a bit like t i t s oot fur ra lads and he'll get bragging rights in the pub about how he managed it.

Michael.
7

The Honest Lad,

Musselburgh 08/09/2008 13:17:53
5) honestly degrading??? how is uncliping a bra degrading. Thousands of women on beaches etc go topless so why be bothered. At the end of the day if it raises money for an important charity then good on it.

Get a grip!

8

charlotte,

oer the hills 08/09/2008 13:24:55
Re number 4s comment If you look at the picture he appears to be unhooking a bra whilst punching another volunteer in the nether regions...thats not very appreciative! If you (re) read the story it does say that he is to do it one handed.

There is going to be lots of mixed opinions on this , and i cant see anything degrading about it
number 5 how can you say not to be encouraged ! would you rather the breast cancer charity done without the money he will raise ? also he is raising money for breast cancer hense why he is doing a bra challenge .
this guy is raising money to help a charity , and the women taking part are not being forced to do this .

He gets a thumbs up from me for wanting to help raise money for breast cancer in the first instance !
9

Bling Crosby,

08/09/2008 13:25:30
agrre with #5 and #8.

This is degrading and surely there are better ways to raise money and awareness. I'm sure the charity was the last thing on this guy's mind, more an afterthought. He just wants to get his face in the paper and a load of men in a packed pub to go "wwwwoooooooo go on my son" etc etc etc. The women who are helping him out in this idiotic display should hang their heads in shame.

I am a man and i find this DISGUSTING.
Is this what the world is coming to?

I feel sad.
10

Bling Crosby,

08/09/2008 13:27:08
the women are probably only doing it as they are praying Nuts magazine will be present in the hope they get signed to do a raunchy photoshoot. Is this what we aspire to these days?

i feel so sad.
11

charlotte,

08/09/2008 13:28:52
number 10 i agree !!!

And can i add to anyone thats not got this story ITS FOR CHARITY !

and also that he is unclipping the bras not taking them off and exposing t*ts

some people are just born complainers and moan at everything .

12

charlotte,

08/09/2008 13:30:02
whoops i meant to say i agree with number 9 (blushes)

lol

Sorry having a wee senior moment
13

derekh,

Bonnyrigg 08/09/2008 13:37:40
Just to point out the blindingly obvious to the degraded ones. Even though those posing in the photo are in their bras, at no point does it say the volunteers will end up topless.

At the risk of spoiling the fun of it all, whose to say they wont wear their bra over a t-shirt at the event ? Nothing degrading about that as all would be covered up.

Now I clearly don't know what the plans are as I have nothing to do with the event, the exact same as those feeling degraded about something they know little about !

Lighten up folks. Getting hot under the collar about nothing if you ask me. (OK, you didn't ask me, but who cares !)
14

Bill MacD,

08/09/2008 13:38:19
What a sad chip-on-the-shoulder attitude to dismiss something like this as degrading. Feminism has done a lot of good for women in the past. But when it becomes nothing but man-hating anti-sexual everything, it's just pathetic. Hey girls, it's just a wee bit of FUN!
15

Bling Crosby,

08/09/2008 13:46:18
#18 Bill you thick b*stard.

i said i was a man.
16

Save Portobello Park,

08/09/2008 13:54:25
#5 is a tad oversensitive. Charities depend on novel ways of raising funds and this is no exception. Ok, its maybe not the norm and Simon must surely have known that he would get on some people's puppies with this stunt but that is all part of the innocent fun.
17

Ed_Izmir,

Turkey 08/09/2008 13:54:50
Not disgusting......pathetic yes...but disgusting...not really.
18

Iain Bhern,

08/09/2008 13:56:42
#17 well said. There is nothing in the article suggesting the ladies bras will be removed, only unhooked, and if they are facing away from the audience no-one is going to see anything other than the chap with his hand at the ladies backs. Just a point incidentally, they should try Michele Mone of Ultimo for both the bras and sponsorship, who knows she may even volunteer herself
19

,

08/09/2008 13:57:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
20

gorgeousgorgieboy,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 14:02:25
My god the nambies are out in force today.
21

miffy the bonfire slater,

08/09/2008 14:10:51
#8 What might you suggest to raise awareness to an unhealthy obsession with David Bowie and cyberbullying combined with mixing drink and meds before lunch?
22

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 14:18:13
#9 Yes - I agree, thousands of women do unclip their bras on beaches but they are not the centre of attention of some man unclipping their bra for charity. If a man was to do this to a "lady" at any other time he would probably be charged with indecent assault.

#11 No - If you read my post you will see that my family are actively involved in raising funds for breast cancer charities and we actually raised £3,000 in one go without removing a stitch. We continue to help and do not go in for such blatant exhibitionism. You can raise money for charity without lowering moral standards.

#14 - I am not a born complainer, I just do not like being exposed to gross indecency in this blatant manner.

#22 Look at the picture - do you honestly think that these "ladies" will not end up being exposed? Highly unlikely, I would say!
23

blackley,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 14:19:36
When did it become a good idea to mix sex and breast cancer?
24

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 14:20:35
#11 He also gets a thumbs up for me for wanting to raise money for charity but a thumbs down for his method.
25

,

08/09/2008 14:22:29
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 14:26:51
#29 No I am not chairman of anything I just don't like the way everything seems to have been brought down to a smutty level nowadays. What is wrong with a little dignity? You would not treat a patient with breast cancer in an undignified manner so why do it to any other woman?

What is wrong is that people in general appear to have lost both self respect and respect for others and that is sad.

I am all for raising money for charity, as I have already said, my family are actively involved and will continue to be actively involved without stooping to these levels.
27

Cynicaltalk,

08/09/2008 14:29:44
All the pompous holier than thou doo gooders who are getting their tweeds in a twist over this being 'degrading', get a grip.

He is using this event to raise money for a good cause and having a bit of a laugh at the same time. Any publicity and fundraising for a charity is a good thing. No one has been pressurised into taking part, and no one is getting hurt.

Stop being so precious and get over yourself.
28

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 14:32:37
#31 I think it highly unlikely they will be keeping a T-shirt on, but I may be wrong.

#32 I take it you will be signing up to do the full monty then?
29

Cynicaltalk,

08/09/2008 14:40:59
#33

If it raises money for a charity then i am game for a laugh. I have been 'auctioned' off before for Marie Curie (i'm a firefighter) and it was a great night. A group of guys stood on a stage and got auctioned off to an audience of women. It was a bit of a laugh and its raised thousands.

But you keep going with your tombola's and raffles, the 21st century will wait for you to catch up.
30

Skip McClendon,

08/09/2008 14:41:43
Jeez...

This is all about raising awareness of Breast Cancer, and highlighting the work of the Breast Cancer Charity.

Obviously, it succeeded. Anyone think this story prompts to many views/comments without the pic and with a headline like "Man to raise charity cancer funds?"

I'm sure it will all be done in the best possible taste, sparing the blushes of the volunteers. You can't judge the setup of the day by the photo - that has been staged by the EEN snapper, not by the charity!
31

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 14:44:40
#25 Yes - but would you be willing to strip?

I just see this type of exhibitionism as being totally unnecessary. You can have fun and raise money without being in poor taste as my family and many others have proven.
32

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 14:44:59
Sorry I meant #35!
33

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 14:45:52
#36 You can raise awareness without being downright indecent.

34

Skip McClendon,

08/09/2008 14:47:45
#39

True, but I seriously doubt the final event will be indecent. The pic has been staged by the Evening News, so you can't judge the event on that. I'm sure they will run it in a way to spare any indecent flashes of flesh.
35

Cynicaltalk,

08/09/2008 14:55:44
#37

Yes, i would strip down to my underwear, as these girls are doing. I doubt there will be breasts or genitals on show. That type of thing would not be allowed as part of the license for Finnegans Wake.

So if people in their underwear is what you class as indecent, i'm surprised you leave your house!
36

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 15:03:35
#41 No I do not think people in their underwear is indecent - I just wouldn't go out of the house like that - I might get arrested! (And some people definitely look better with clothes on!). I have a sense of humour but I think there is a line that just should not be crossed, that's all.
37

Iain Bhern,

08/09/2008 15:16:55
Linmal, can I take it you don't watch much TV these days for reasons of decency and taste, every other advert seems to feature people prancing around in their underwear now!. I've no problem with this fund raiser as it can be done easily and can still preserve the modesty of the volunteers, all they have to do is keep their backs to the audience. That said no-one who has objections on grounds of decency will neither take part nor attend the event so I suggest you do the same, i.e. stay away, and just live with the fact that other people have different standards to yourself. My final point is this as a man I've seen my wife unhook her bra I don't know how many times over the years but she still has to physically remove it. All this man is going to do is unhook the bras 'not' remove them. Were he to do that he wouldn't have time to achieve one per second, which is his aim.
38

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 15:17:32
#43 - I go shopping on a Sunday.

And your right. It does all sound a bit tacky and I would not like my daughters to take part either (I have two both grown up). I am no prude, and yes there are worse things going on in the world but I would prefer it if people would think of doing something for charity where the whole family could take part. Far more worthwhile and less open to criticism.

We managed to raise a substantial sum without any of this smuttiness.

As for worse things happening in the world, well if people tried to do something to stop just one thing that they felt wasn't right it would be a start now, wouldn't it? Not sure if I have gotten over what I mean here but think you get the gist.
39

Linmal,

Livingston 08/09/2008 15:19:47
#44 I watch TV on a daily basis and I take your point. As for attending the event, I take your point here too, wouldn't dream of setting foot anywhere near. I wish them luck with the fund raising though but would suspect that more could be raised if it was thought out to be more inclusive, ie you wouldn't be embarrassed to take your granny!
40

Pen Fold,

Here 08/09/2008 15:20:34
degrading, get a grip.

The cause money is being raised for is breast cancer so naturally off the norm charity raisers are going to focus on breasts.

does linmal think those women who dress up their bras for the moonwalk fundraisers are degrading themselves also as a lot of outfits highlight womens' breasts? crikey, their website even has ideas of how to decorate your bra. if that doesn't attract attention then nothing will! is this not the point?

and then asking a man if he would go the full monty, well if it were for testicular cancer, why not? but getting the nads out for breast cancer, yeah i'm really sure you would approve of that.

good luck to the guy and the women who participate in this event. the EN should start a way for folk to contribute to the event and help him raise more money.
41

Indyp,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 15:54:14
Most of you seem to be missing the point...it is to raise money for a worthwile charity. Even if you don't agree with the method of the fundraiser, you have to accept that some good will come of it.
42

Iain Bhern,

08/09/2008 16:16:34
Linmal, as someone who is employed full time by a charity I know that nowadays fund raising is difficult and has to be something out of the ordinary to generate interest. I'm afraid that it seems you'll need to console yourself with the fact that at the end of the day a charity will benefit from this fundraiser so irrespective of your own feelings some good will come out of it and that can't be a bad thing altogether. Re those adverts I mentioned, I read on Saturday that the European Parliament plans to put an end to them.
43

Blondie,

08/09/2008 16:28:11
Surely everyone taking part is volunteering to do so, so what's the problem? Do those who feel this is "degrading" also feel the same way about the "nude" WRI calendar (which inspired the film Calendar Girls and countless lookalike calendars) and raised a considerable sum for cancer charities? If it's raising money for such a worthwhile cause and the charity is happy enough to receive the cash, then that's good enough for me!
44

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

08/09/2008 16:29:48
the guys an out and out perv, using a charity as cover to get away with this weird, absurd fantasy.
45

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

08/09/2008 16:30:57
and the daft lassies will just giggle & think it a laugh that he's doing this - all in the name of charity
46

Krissy Kringle,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 16:42:07
go on ya simon!!

this oviously will bring in tons of money to a good cause so unless everyone who is against would rather match and exceed and donate the amount of money being raised then they should keep quiet in my opinion.

Your not forcing this upon anyone, and your not asking them to parade around with their boobs out, its just unhooking the bra! If people think that showing ur bare back is degrading then they live a very sheltered life! you see more boobies and willies at the beach then you will at this event!!!

Proud of you Simon! Good Effort!
47

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

08/09/2008 16:53:06
ghandi - you fly with the crows, you get shot with the crows - & there is no use crowing about it
48

Dr Joseph Phd,

Tynescos 08/09/2008 18:16:16

Robyn & Leah, yes... Jo, no.


49

keithface,

leith 08/09/2008 18:18:27
i'd be more impressed if he undid 60 bras on 'The Over' 60's in 60 seconds. bit more work there you might say...
50

Brasforbreastcancer,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 18:19:48
Hey everyone,
All the feedback is much appreciated. It would be great if you guys spent less time on this site and more time giving money to the cause. If you want to make a donation to Breast Cancer Care and help raise money for Simon's feat, please visit www.justgiving.com/unsnap.

Thanks so much and get donating.
51

Dr Joseph Phd,

Tynescos 08/09/2008 18:32:58
Hi #58,
Your comment is not appreciated. Frankly none of your business how much time anyone spends on any website. Would be great if you could drop the holier than thou attitude. If you want to maximise income for breast cancer and help raise money for simon's "feat" please visit www.dontbeapatronisingdobberallyourlife.com/ok.

Thanks again.
52

Brasforbreastcancer,

08/09/2008 18:41:13
I really do apologize, and I certainly didn't mean to sound patronising or offensive. It was a light-hearted comment meant to get people to check out the website. Once again, very sorry if it was taken the wrong way.
53

Lu lu,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 18:45:19
Go SIMON, BRA MASTER FLASH!
54

Dr Joseph Phd,

Tynescos 08/09/2008 18:46:39

Fair dos.
Good luck with the fundraising :)
55

keithface,

leith 08/09/2008 19:35:53
#62,
i knew you at school, only as 'Master Joseph O-Grade', great to hear from you again...
56

Dr Joseph Phd,

Tynescos 08/09/2008 19:59:45

That you keithnose?
57

tomias,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 20:06:24
bordering on the lads mag etc;all to stimulate the drprived/depraved.
58

keithface,

leith 08/09/2008 20:11:10
I knew you'd remember :-)
59

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 20:45:13

Whilst I can see Linmal's point of view on this, one must smile a tad!

It is a very difficult operation removing a bra with two or three fingers, and can spoil the,..

'Heat of the Moment' not 'of-course' for the guy but for your woman, many a time my DYW just got so fed up waiting for me,..'fumble-fingers' she just jumps up and wheeks it off!

As for the "Breast Cancer" it is many a partner that finds the lump first,...

So 'Men' should take more interest in this department, but by 'no-means' make it 'Smutty' :DD
60

J4cko,

08/09/2008 20:55:02
I have to agree with some people's concerns but to raise awareness and to get in the papers and tell everyone about it, you have to do something out of the ordinary.

This is certainly unusual, and out of the ordinary therefore it will probably get more press and therefore get people thinking and talking about breast cancer which is a good thing surely.

Okay it might not be to some people's liking but at least it raises awareness and money.
61

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 21:00:07

J4cko ~68,

Agree and not nearly soo horrid as about to be shown on television tomorrow night,...

"Other People's Breast Milk" 10pm Channel,4
62

Mini-Scot,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 21:52:39
I'm one of the girls posing in this photo and am highly offended by 5's comment. we are doin this for charity not to degrade ourselves. Women I know have applauded me and the other women participatin. its a bit of fun that will raise money for a worthy charity. and secondly. none of us will have our bras off! do u honestly think we would agree to it if that was the case?we all believe in charity not blatant flashing. and to the idiot that thinks this is coz we're hopin nuts or whatever pervy mag u read will want us...GET A LIFE!!! we are all raisin money for a good charity i think those who look down on this really need to think bout what they believe in and think about the people they know who have suffered from breast cancer
63

Irish Shirls,

Gorgie 08/09/2008 22:36:20
Well done Simon, Really proud of you. I think it is amazing that you are doing it for a worthwhile cause and well done to everyone who is helping and supporting you. You will easily do it and we will all be there on the night supporting you. Thank you for raising this important issue and for those who think it is degrading, get a life and examine the low cut tops / skirts e.t.c. that are worn every weekend by folk... Is that not degrading? It is for charity and well done on being original... Keep those Irish eyes Smiling Lad, you'll du us proud :) xxx
64

is it me?,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 22:59:25
This involves a lot of people giving their support.
65

Julian.,

edinburgh 08/09/2008 22:59:30
#70,

I'm disappointed now. I certainly wouldn't call it degrading if you did take the bra off. Maybe slightly so for all the young guys who would inevitably come to watch. But hey, that's life.
66

Linmal,

Livingston 09/09/2008 09:01:40
#70 I'm sorry you are offended by my comment but I would be offended and highly embarrassed to watch what I would only describe as blatant exhibitionism. It is perfectly possible to raise funds for breast cancer, as my family did a couple of years ago, without being subjected to this kind of loutish behaviour. We still support breast cancer charities having known many friends and relatives who have been affected personally by breast cancer.

Its up to you - go ahead - and I hope the fund raising is a success but what you are doing is degrading to women and I deplore it for that.

I don't object to the moonwalk by the way, that is bras over t-shirts and not indecent exposure.

There is a time and a place for this kind of thing and I don't think a pub is it.

#72 I think they are supporting the event rather than the charity but the charity will, I hope, benefit as well.
67

bra enthusiast ,

edinburgh 09/09/2008 12:36:32
To linmal, and the rest.
I am one of the girls who is participating in this fund raiser. I find it interesting that, at a recent event i saw on television, women who had breast cancer proudly took off their bras and showed their mastectomy scars to the world. As a woman, as a feminist, as a current Phd student at the University of Edinburgh, I find it hilarious that some people are getting so upset over the fact that women might be proud enough of their bodies to walk around in a bra (bathing suit?). First, if you actually had knowledge of the event you would know that we will be facing backs to the crowd and grabbing the bras as the they are unhooked, as someone so intelligently added earlier, finnegans is not a porn palace. Second, this is for the book of world records, so its not going to errupt into an orgy, lastly, it is in the name of a legitimate charity, and if all three of these establishments dont see it as horrible and degrading, and neither do those who are participating, i honestly do not understand what right you have to say..well anything else. take it to heart.
68

duder face mcgee,

The EDI 09/09/2008 12:44:43
Linmal, why don't you get off the internet and go do your own charity if you are so offended by this one, you're not going to change anyone's mind. You are either a) sitting at work wasting your company's money or b) you don't have a job and have nothing better to do, either way, you don't have anything useful to contribute other than your uneducated opinion - get over it.
69

bra enthusiast ,

edinburgh 09/09/2008 12:44:52
and also to linmal, i am so very sorry that we did not raise money the way your family did! that we attempted creativity, fun, and laughs for a good cause, to a new generation. and blatant exhibition? are you joking, shirts on, face bar, shirts off, show our backs, grab bra, shirt on. our backs! oh dear!!! well i will be sure to never wear a backless dress again!

it is up to us, and we are going ahead, with a great deal of success i might add. but i do appreciate your concern, for all of us degraded women everywhere.
70

Linmal,

Livingston 09/09/2008 12:47:39
#75 I have the right to say.?.?.?. Because it is a free country, that's why! However, that said, just because I don't agree with you, doesn't make me wrong and vice versa (although I would say that you are, wrong that is). Good luck to you, I hope you make a stack of cash, just stop and think next time if there isn't a more dignified way of making money for charity.

As for the ladies who showed their scars to the world - it was done in an entirely different context. This was to show other women who may be facing the same awful illness, what it is like and that it is not the end of the world. I am fortunate enough not to have had breast cancer but have friends who have. I don't know how I would react to losing a breast (or both) but I think I would rather be alive without my breasts than dead with them, which is why I nag all my friends of a certain age to remember and go for their mammograms.

Lecture over!
71

duder face mcgee,

09/09/2008 12:49:17
And to 'The Geniune Mario Antionette'
you're not impressing any ladies here you're just some lonely dude that needs to go get laid, now go back to looking at internet porn.
72

Linmal,

Livingston 09/09/2008 12:52:11
#76 I resent being called uneducated, I have a very good job thank you very much and have worked for nearly forty years since leaving school not that it is any of your business. I have not resorted to personal attacks, merely my opinion on what I believe to be degrading and, as I have already said, in context there is nothing wrong with what the ladies on television did.

#77 I have no objections to backless dresses, or even low cut dresses, I've worn them myself in the past. I haven't exposed myself though and, from what you are saying, you will not be doing that either. However I would be mortified if a man tried to undo my bra in public and, rightly so.

Good luck to you, as I have already said, I hope you make a lot of money for the charity as my family and I do year on year.
73

bra enthusiast ,

edinburgh 09/09/2008 12:53:50
being proud of our bodies is dignified. and i am glad you think i am wrong, because i think you are wrong and judgemental and completely uneducated on the subject at hand. but hey, agree to disagree! and "vice versa"
74

Linmal,

Livingston 09/09/2008 12:54:59
And just as a matter of interest, most of the charitable giving that we are involved with is entirely anonymous. I may be on this website but you don't know who I am and you have no idea how much I donate to charity which is considerable. That is our choice as what you are doing is yours, just don't expect everyone to agree with you, the world's just not like that. Live with it.
75

,

09/09/2008 12:58:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
76

Linmal,

Livingston 09/09/2008 13:11:00
#83 No I am not sixty for a while yet - I rounded it up, I said "nearly" forty years. However, I'm neither scared of my microwave nor of you. I'm on my lunch break, what's left of it.

Thank you for conceding that I can't be uneducated. Education gives us the opportunity to think for ourselves and come to our own opinions, but you will never agree with everyone, that's life.
77

Linmal,

Livingston 09/09/2008 13:13:59
#81 Just because you don't agree with something does not make you "uneducated". The whole point of education is to make you think for yourself and come to your own conclusions.

I wish I could be proud of my body - joking! However, neither am I ashamed of it, I just wouldn't want to flaunt it. That's my choice, you must decide for yourself what is yours.
78

Linmal,

Livingston 09/09/2008 14:27:28
#83 I cannot begin to know why your post was removed. I do not remember seeing anything untoward in there apart from the fact that you did not agree with me and that's fine, most people on this site disagree with each other - does anyone else know why this post was removed?
79

Lu lu,

Edinburgh 09/09/2008 18:38:07
Linmal you're anoying and completely entitled to your opinion no doubt. Let's stop the fight people. We can all think what we want, but in the end this isn't about our opinions, it's about making CASH for a wicked cause. GO SEAMONKS!!!!!!!!!
80

SamboK,

09/09/2008 23:22:10
Hi - Simon, good luck for the 31st I'm sure you'll do great.
Would just like to say that I'm a girl and unfortunately will be in the States so will be unable to volunteer. Will contribute at www.justgiving.com/unsnap now though!

For all those who are against this wonderful charity event because it's 'degrading' to women I have this to say - the wars of feminism weren't fought so that it could be dictated to each of us what we chose to do with ourselves. Showing the back of a bra-strap to a crowd can hardly be called exhibitionism when you can see full bras displayed regularly on daytime TV commercials. This is the 21st century guys!

And to Bling Crosby's comment: 'The women who are helping him out in this idiotic display should hang their heads in shame.' - Have an opinion, but by condescending what these women have freely chosen to do you sound like nothing more than a male chauvinist. Feminism was fought so that we did not have to answer to men for our actions, and if it is not breaking any law or hurting anyone, in fact, it is bringing people together, I deduce that you must just be a miserly fellow who enjoys complaining about the way the world is advancing.

Many women every year participate in a charity run in only their bras and that does not receive the same negativity and neither should this.
Good luck everyone involved and well done!
81

Bzzzz,

Edinburgh 10/09/2008 00:17:45
Good to see someone using a bit of intellegence to highlight a good cause... good luck !!!


ps. I reckon I could give you a run for yer money tho fella ! ! ;-)
82

Bzzzz,

Edinburgh 10/09/2008 00:18:22
(intellegence and humour)
Good luck
83

Linmal,

Livingston 10/09/2008 09:10:51
#88 Have never answered to a man for my actions in my life, that doesn't mean that I would throw my self respect out of the window, which is what you are doing when you expose yourself in this way.

If you read my posts, I already support breast cancer charities and will continue to do so, without comprising my standards.
84

Lu lu,

10/09/2008 13:18:07
Linmal, your still very irritating. I'm sorry that you are not receiving enough attention about your own charity work, but I will say it right here on behalf of everyone involved in this scandelous act of charity, good on you. We all support what you do %100, you are an asset to society. Now go pick on someone else and let us do our part as well. If you can't, then just leave us alone.

Thanks for your contribution Sambok. Everyone take an example.
85

Lu lu,

10/09/2008 14:31:03
P.S. Nuts magazine has not been invited or informed about this event.
86

Linmal,

Livingston 10/09/2008 15:36:32
#92 Sorry if you find me irritating. Could this be because I don't agree with your point of view?!?!? Heaven forbid.

The last sentence of my post should have read "without compromising my standards." Apologies for the typo.
87

Lu lu,

10/09/2008 18:45:20
No Linmal it's not.Please refer to my comment at #87. Then re-read the comment above I made and it may be more clear why I am finding your negative attitude completely destructive to something we are putting a lot of time and effort to construct and make happen. If you need the last word fine have it, this is a waste of our time, thanks for the support. All the best,

Luther.
88

Lu lu,

10/09/2008 18:47:39
http://www.justgiving.com/unsnap
89

Linmal,

Livingston 11/09/2008 14:22:11
The last word
90

Irish Shirls,

Gorgie 11/09/2008 23:56:07
Linmal,

Your comments have been noted by everyone, well done on your charity work. Simon and the 69 + volunteers now wish to do theirs in a way that suits them and they CHOOSE to do it that way so LET IT BE!!! Accept it and you will be happier for it.

Good Luck Simon xx
91

Linmal,

Livingston 12/09/2008 09:06:45
#92 I don't want to receive attention for my charity work. I would far rather do it in the background as I don't want praise from anyone. I will continue to support breast cancer and one or two other charities I am involved with. I will wear pink next month on the appropriate day - have to check when it is as I have just sent off for my pack.

#98 I hope the others do well and raise lots of money, don't agree with the method, but that is my choice and if that's what they want to do, fine. I still think its in poor taste, but I suppose it has a lot to do with my upbringing and you can't really change who you are, can you?
92

Irish Shirls,

Gorgie 13/09/2008 19:12:20
#99. As mentioned it is only your opinion and it is not only your upbringing but society, friends and your environment which you choose to live in all impacts your atttude. If we use "upbringing" as a reason for our opinions then those with a less fortunate upbringing might never develop to be the fantastic people they are, equally those with the best upbringing in the world cannot stop those that choose the wrong path. Life is what you make it and you must be free to choose what you want to do and everyone is entitled to their opinions.

Good luck Simon... Well proud of ya dude x

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In