Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Monday, 2nd November 2009 Change Date Latest Issue

Pensioner lies dead in flat for five years

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 July 2009
THE body of an elderly woman has been found in her city flat after lying undiscovered for up to five years.
Police made the grim discovery after a neighbour reported water dripping through the ceiling from her flat above to the council.

Officers sent to the property had to force their way past a pile of mail and newspapers three feet deep to discover the badly decomposed remains. Among the mail there appeared to be letters from utility companies, and the kitchen sink was full of water.

Tests are being carried out to identify the body, which is believed to be that of the flat's owner Isabella Purves, who would have been 90 this year.

Neighbours in Rodney Street, Bellevue, said they had seen her practically every day until she suddenly "disappeared off the face of the earth" more than five years ago. They today described their "shock" and "horror" at Tuesday's discovery.

Her next-door neighbour, who did not want to be named, said he had not seen anybody enter or leave the flat since he moved in earlier this year.

He said: "I knew that an old woman lived there but I never saw her. I thought the flat was up for rent.

"The police visited on Tuesday morning after the man living below reported that water was dripping through his ceiling.

"At 11am an ambulance arrived to take a body away. A police officer told me the woman had been dead since at least 2005."

He added: "When they opened the door there was a smell and it hung around all day. Before then I didn't smell anything."

Richard Dyson, 40, who lives on the second floor of the three-storey building, said that he had not seen a single person come from or go into the flat since he moved in more than three years ago.

A couple who run a flower business next door to the property said they used to see Ms Purves nearly every day, but she "disappeared off the face of the earth" in 2004.

Sandra Brownlee and Giovanni Cilia, who own Fioritalia florists, said Ms Purves used to pass their shop pulling a trolley and would always say "hello".

Miss Brownlee said: "We noticed she had stopped coming by the shop and wondered why.

"We thought she must have gone to live with relatives or gone into a home. I was worried for a while and wondered if I should go and check on her. I wish I had now."

She added that Ms Purves seemed like a "pleasant and independent woman".

"It is shocking and very, very sad that nobody noticed this lady was missing. Surely there should be some checks in place to make sure elderly people are OK?"

Isabella Purves, who was born in 1919, is believed to have owned the flat in which she lived since at least 2001. It is thought her bills may have continued to have been paid by direct debit after her death.

Police said there were no suspicious circumstances surrounding the death. Officers are believed to be trying to trace relatives.

Age Concern and Help the Aged in Scotland said: "Although, unfortunately, cases of this nature crop up from time to time, this is by far the longest we have heard of an individual laying undiscovered. The shocking length of time only adds to the tragedy of this situation.

"In light of situations such as this, we would call for the providers of health and social care services to implement a system of automatic checks for non-responsive individuals.

"We would also encourage 'good neighbour' behaviour and ask people to acquaint themselves with their older neighbours."

The city council said it had no reason to be involved in the property.

A police spokesman added: "Police were called to an address in Rodney Street in Edinburgh on 30 June, after concerns were raised over an elderly resident.

"On entering the premises, officers discovered the body of a 90-year-old woman.

"There are no suspicious circumstances surrounding her death, and a report has been sent to the procurator fiscal."

GRISLY FINDS
A SPATE of grisly finds in 1994 prompted Edinburgh Council to launch an emergency programme of contacting council tenants who lived alone.

Ian Pattison, 62, was found by a joiner sent to break into the property. His body was thought to have been there seven months.

Later that week, Brian Blair, 62, was found at his Murrayburn Place home after lying undiscovered for about four weeks, and the next month Angus Cooper, 73, was found in his flat in Duart Crescent. His body was believed to have been there for seven weeks.

In April 2006, Bruce Hendrie, 70, and his sister Robina Marshall, 79, were found dead at their Beechwood Terrace home, having lain undiscovered for 15 days.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 July 2009 1:56 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Driver74,

Livingston 03/07/2009 13:33:38
Well done that florist "I was worried for a while and wondered if I should go and check on her" errr yes you should have!
2

104 years in a row!!,

Edinburgh 03/07/2009 13:38:22
Even better
"A couple who run a flower business next door to the property said they used to see Ms Purves nearly every day, but she "disappeared off the face of the earth" in 2004."
3

Diana,

Edinburgh 03/07/2009 13:49:37
This is shocking. The "concern" of her neighbours is real touching - if only they'd have thought to check on her.
4

Martin05,

Surrey 03/07/2009 14:18:34
I've never been moved to register or comment before. I'm sorry for this lady in lots of ways, but also sorry for her neighbours who are being abused. They, like me, must think it appalling that the direct-debit/credit obsessed organisations were apparently quite happy to continue operating this lady's life - money going in and out - without ever visiting to, for example, read a meter. Are all of you who are critical of the neighbours sure that you know all your local candidates for an incident like this?
5

echidna,

Melbourne 03/07/2009 14:27:49
Can't blame the neighbours. It's one thing to notice an absence, but quite another to know where she lives, and feel confident enough to visit. It does highlight that it is important to invite people into your home at regular intervals.

The people who are really in a position to monitor vulnerable people are banks: they have addresses, and are in a position to notice when there has been no (unautomated) activity on a bank account for a period of time. Would it be feasible to set up some sort of opt-in monitoring scheme using telephone, water, electricity and bank account usage?
6

Tynieweeguy,

03/07/2009 14:39:30
#5 Do you know you're not allowed on here if you are going to talk sense. It surely wouldn't be too difficult for the banks to have an automated arrangement where they highlight inactivity on an account to social services, it wouldn't even be that costly and it would show their gratitude for the help the tax payer has given recently.
7

Dylan fan,

Planet earth 03/07/2009 14:59:11

Rather Orwellian... We can live, pay our bills ( now there's a plus) without any personal contact..Isn't that convenient? Isn't that great? So Important?
I only hope she was not ill and that death came quickly. She was beyond caring how long it took to find her, though she was probably not surprised...
She knew she was alone and maybe enjoyed it..Who knows? I guess that is the point... Who really knew this woman?
8

animmo,

03/07/2009 15:12:49
Horrible story. Yes, the neighbours should have done more, but it wouldn't have helped her. Feel sorry for those that found her.
9

the Genuine Mario Antoinette,

03/07/2009 15:38:49
#5 - Can't blame the neighbours because they might not know where she lived ? Eh...Neighbour = a person living near or next door to one: an adjacent territory,person,etc: any of one's fellow humans:..these neighbours were clearly negligent & guilty of a complete disregard for the welfare & concern of another human being.
10

,

03/07/2009 17:26:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Ian Ross,

Edinburgh 03/07/2009 18:58:48
The people who can be blamed here are not the neighbours. Rather is the Council Tax folk, Electricity and gas supplier, and the pensions office. Surely it could have been picked up that she had not paid a bill or collected her pension for such a long time ? A personal call from one of those would have led to her discovery earlier. Regarding her owning the flat, you can bet any relatives will not be long in turning up now.
12

piccaso,

edinburgh 03/07/2009 19:25:47
well, just maybe she didn't want to be found, old people have some strange habits and keep themselves to themselves, nothing worse than a nosey neighbour.
cant for the life of me think why the utility companies must have just used estimated readings for 5 years, and the people living in the same stair should have noticed a strong smell, or maybe the whole stair is minging and they wouldn`t or couldn't`t tell the difference, mmmm the mind ponders...
13

AB_R,

03/07/2009 20:00:41
Rather than trying to lay the blame, how about some compassion.

Mrs/Ms Purves, may you rest you rest in peace.
14

crowsteppedbettygrable,

edinburgh 03/07/2009 21:30:32
You can be sure if her money had run out they'd have been round there tout suite to disconnect her. Utilities are the only people who "care" nowadays.
15

lynno,

london 03/07/2009 21:52:05
SO SORRY FEEL FOR THE OLD LADY MAYBE SHE DIDNT WANT ANYBODY TO KNOW BUT IVE A FEELING WEE MIGHT SEE SOME FAMILY KNOW WITH HER HOUSE TO BE LEFT TO HA HA HOPE SHE DONATED IT TO A CHARITY SHE LIKED. I THINK OF MY OWN GRAN AT TIMES LIKE THIS AND THE PEOPLE ON MY GRANS CLOSE THE 8 FAMILIES IF THEY HAD NOT SEEN MY GRAN FOR 2 DAYS NEVER MIND YRS/MNTHS THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN OVER LIKE A SHOT. SHAME ON YOU FLOWER PEOPLE YOU COULD HAVE CHECKED BUT THERE WE GO. SORRY IF I BORED ANYONE. CMON DAVY C IN WESTER HAILES YOUR BUDDY PHILIP TAKE CARE M8
16

Pilrig,

Livingston 03/07/2009 23:38:09
Embra, such a carin, sharin city.
17

Artemis,

04/07/2009 00:18:49
It's quite possible she had no family. Lots of women of her age never married or had children because of the war, and if she had siblings she could easily have outlived them and been the last of her family. If her pension was paid directly into the bank and her bills were paid by direct debit things could easily go on for quite a while. I'm surprised her GP didn't notice anything untoward though. GPs are supposed to do an annual check on all the over 75s, so how come nobody ever tried to make contact, or go round and knock on the door and look through the letterbox? Poor lady, what a sad thing to happen.
18

Leigh Oats,

Sydney 04/07/2009 01:14:48
During my ransacking of the innernets I've failed to find mention of Isabella Purves's _landlord_, the person or organisation that the world must assume has been complacently and perhaps even happily collecting rent from her bank account for five years.

In all that time did the landlord experience not even one episode of inquisitiveness about the possibility that a visit for maintenance of the flat's physical condition was needed?

And I can't help thinking that the computers of every bank nowadays should be tweaked so that the computers raise an alert if an account has had no activity other than pension credits (or other automatic credits) and direct debits for more than a certain stretch of time.

There seem to be big holes in the laws that relate especially to elderly people.
19

Leigh Oats,

Sydney 04/07/2009 01:37:51
Oops. A few minutes after sending my previous post I learn that Isabella Purves was the _owner_ of the flat. So my mentions of "landlord" should have been mentions of "strata manager", because we must assume that one outfit or another must have been collecting strata fees from her bank account by direct debit.
20

thank god i left,

swansea (but fountainbridge born and bred) 04/07/2009 10:34:39
i work as a home help/carer and i do believe people today dont care and thats really sad but gorgie tony,you cant expect a goverment to FORCE people to neighbours to cook them meals and clean up for them. it would be nice to think that some peole would help out of kindness but not in todays world. maybe if a little more money was spent on promoting things like help the aged a bit better an improvemt might be seen
21

2F3,

Edinburgh 04/07/2009 10:54:01
#11 GT. I was a neighbor for 18 years spoke to her regularly and in latter years called upon her to make sure she was OK and see if she needed anything. Last time I spoke to her was on the 25th June 2004 when I went to say goodbye to her. Now wish I had went back to visit regularly as this may have been the last time anyone saw or even spoke to her.
It saddens me that she has passed away in this way.
22

the Genuine Mario Antoinette,

04/07/2009 14:52:42
#14 - What a stupid, sanctimonious remark. What is the point of showing compassion to the dead, when we can't show it to the living ?
23

G Fairweather,

Edinburgh 04/07/2009 20:01:55
Should the Health Board / GMC be investigating the GP practice that would have been claiming additional payments for this elderly patient - and clearly delivering nothing for 5 years?
24

Leigh Oats,

Sydney 04/07/2009 23:18:20
# 24: Well, G Fairweather ("04/07/2009 20:01:55"), I can't afford to comment on your suggestion of the possibility of a GP's "claiming additional payments [. . .] for 5 years" on account of Isabella Purves (if you have relevant information then I urge you to give it to the author of this story, or the police, or both), but it certainly beggars belief that a GP could be so SarahPalinishly uninquisitive (like #14's author, perhaps?) as to fail to raise eyebrows at an elderly customer's unexplained cessation of requests for medical attention even after several years.

The story seems to be a lesson not only for the managers (!) of such collections of dwellings—in which the dwellings are packed physically so cheek-by-jowl with each other yet socially so distant from each other—but also for the coiled-serpent profession.
25

Leigh Oats,

Sydney 05/07/2009 06:59:11
Says a story in the Edinburgh Evening News website headed "Not a single visitor in 18 years for quiet OAP who died alone", dated "04 July 2009":

"A 3ft pile of post on the floor of the residence included several newspapers and utility letters, including one from Scottish Gas. The company confirmed that Ms Purves had an account with them, but it had been closed in 2004 and had been inactive since."

So the gas account "had been closed"? By whom? By Isabella Purves herself? If so, what on earth would have prompted her to close it? Or by the gas company? If so, what prompted the company to close it?

This case has countless other questions, with too few people to ask them and probably even fewer who'll be willing to answer them properly.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.