Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 9th January 2009 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Outspoken trams critic set to get businesses back on track



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 September 2008
HE has been at the vanguard of some of the toughest criticism dished out to the city's £512 million tram project in recent years.
But now Graham Russell – until recently chairman of the Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) for Edinburgh – is set to be appointed as the official champion for the areas worst hit by the tram works.

The Evening News has learned the role will attract a £30,000-a-year salary for a three-day week, and will be funded indirectly by tram firm TIE.

The champion role will last until the tram work is finished in 2011 and would see Mr Russell charged with coordinating efforts to encourage trade back to Leith and the West End, as well as ensuring the remaining tram work is completed as efficiently as possible.

Business groups today welcomed the move, but council chiefs insisted they still had to go through the proper recruitment process for the role.

Mr Russell said: "It is not official yet, but I am very much looking forward to being appointed and I look forward to what is a very exciting challenge.

"What we need to build is a legacy for both Leith and the West End which takes them beyond the tram project.

"I am not, and never will be, a servant to TIE or the council."

The money for the role is coming from the Open for Business campaign, which is promoting Edinburgh during the disruption.

The project was last week handed a £350,000 boost after traders failed to take up all of the £2m compensation payments available from TIE. The money will also pay for other initiatives, such as giving free parking in the evenings and on Saturday afternoons from November in a bid to boost city centre trade.

Gordon Burgess, chairman of the traders association for Leith Walk and Constitution Street, said: "This has the potential to make a big difference if it is done properly.

"I think they have got the right guy. Graham Russell has been working tirelessly for this area in recent years. We certainly need someone to be at the forefront of efforts to reinvigorate Leith because the tram works are having a huge impact on us."

City economic development leader Tom Buchanan said: " It is fairly obvious that Graham is good at championing causes from his work at the FSB and I think both communities will benefit from that."

However, Greg Ward, the council's head of economic development, said a thorough recruitment process still had to be completed.


The full article contains 431 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 September 2008 11:01 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Edinburgh transport plans
 
1

Heartfelt,

EDINBURGH 30/09/2008 11:28:21
A good idea at last. Someone with relevant concerns and a strategy rather than random punters bumping their gums about nothing in particular.

There is plenty criticism of the project - maybe now there will be a focus and pressure brought to bear where appropriate.

lets make our negativity positive!!
2

Howard Moon,

30/09/2008 11:40:24
Keep your friends close, and your 'enemies' closer?

Whatever way you dress it up, a bad idea is a bad idea. Even if every single business on the tram route benefits financially from its creation (highly unlikely), the impact the tram will inevitably have on bus users and cyclists renders the scheme disastrous for Edinburgh. Unfortunately, unlike the Leith traders, there are no representative groups for them (apart from spineless Spokes).

Cue posts attacking the petrol-obsessed fuelheads who are of course the only people opposed to trams...
3

allknowing,

30/09/2008 11:50:12
£30k a year!!! For what?

How much money will this tram line soak up! I hope this is included in the total overall costings of this white elephant.
4

Cassandra,

30/09/2008 11:52:30
Have I got this right? The EEN reports that Graham Russell is to be appointed to this post, but "Greg Ward, the council's head of economic development, said a thorough recruitment process still had to be completed." So either public money and private time are about to be wasted in a recruitment process, where the appointee is a foregone conclusion (very common nowadays, especially in the public & not-for-profit sectors) or Russell may not get the job, which makes him personally irrelevant to the story.

It also seems the scheme to suspend parking charges over Christmas shopping will not cost the Council £70,000 in lost parking fees, as reported yesterday.
5

Duncan in Edinburgh,

30/09/2008 12:15:15
I hope Mr Russell, if he does get confirmed in post, doesn't misrepresent businesses along the tram route as he has been misrepresenting small businesses in Edinburgh. The FSB is nothing more than a branch of the Tory party. It includes and represents none but a tiny fraction of small businesses in Edinburgh.
6

Cassandra,

30/09/2008 12:17:51
#5 Duncan - how do you know? You're not a business owner.
7

Duncan in Edinburgh,

30/09/2008 12:21:46
#6 Erm, yes I am. You're not one of those tiresome Nat trolls are you?
8

Bob 2,

30/09/2008 12:22:12
Jobs for the Boys

Time for a Freedom of Information enquiry to see how the appointment can be made before the receruitment

maybe he could answer this question

Lothian Buses is a Business effected by the TRAMWORKS, yet why is it not eligible for compensation?
9

Andy 52,

Tir na nog 30/09/2008 12:22:45
#6 Cassandra - how do you know he's no? Mind yir ain business.
10

Sarcasm,

30/09/2008 12:23:30
#3 £30k a year!!!

That seems like a poor person's response to me.
11

Bob 2,

30/09/2008 12:23:57
£30,000 for a 3 day week, how do you apply

that works out to an annual salary of £50,000 !!!!
12

Statsman,

Edinburgh 30/09/2008 12:26:27
All aboard the gravy train.
13

bumf,

30/09/2008 12:31:02
>5. 'The FSB is nothing more than a branch of the Tory party.'

What? The Conservatives have infiltrated the Russian security service?

Federalnaya Sluzhba Bezopasnosti!!! No wonder my gas bill has gone up. Does Vladimir Putin know?
14

The Judge,

30/09/2008 12:31:25
£30k for a 3 day week?

"I am not, and never will be, a servant to TIE or the council."

Well you would say that wouldn't you Mr Russell. By taking the £30k a year whether you like it or not, and no matter what you say you are now a servant of TIE. You will do whatever they tell you to do or you'll lose your nice part time jobs with the obvious expenses and benefits.

15

Top Floor,

30/09/2008 12:34:37
#4 Cassandra,

You've got a point - EN report implies that this is a "done deal" and Mr Russell going to get the job but the Council say there is still a recruitment exercise to be completed.

Wouldn't be pleased if I had applied for this job and was still waiting to hear the outcome though I don't remember seing it advertised anywhere.

£30k / 3 day week jobs would attract a lot of interest one would think ?

16

Concerned of Leith,

30/09/2008 12:36:11
#8 In order for a business to be eligible for the (now closed) Small Business Support Scheme it had to:

1. Be in premises with a rateable value less than £28k.
2. Have a frontage on the tram route (or within 100m, on a side street - per amended eligibility rules).

LRT fails on both these counts.

The clue is in the scheme name - SMALL Business Support Scheme...
17

Filthy Capitalist,

30/09/2008 12:41:18
6.
Duncan does own a business.
It's on the corner of Castle Street and Princes Street.
I bought a balloon from him for my granddaughter.
18

Scotish Exile,

30/09/2008 12:43:15
hush money me thinks!
19

Cassandra,

30/09/2008 12:48:37
#5 - I don't believe you. Your comments usually reek of being a client of the state (in the sense it employs you - heaven forfend I should suggest you're on benefit.) Or are you moonlighting?
20

,

30/09/2008 12:49:03
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 12:51:52
#17 Very nice indeed - fair brought a tear to my eye.
22

scotsol,

Edinburgh 30/09/2008 13:06:18
#5 - Since all anti-trammers are me-first Tories anyway, it seems appropriate that they've got one of their number to speak for them.
23

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 13:08:52
#22 Wee bit of a generalisation there, perhaps? By that token, all pro-trammers are presumably paragons of the socialist ideal?
24

Duncan in Edinburgh,

30/09/2008 13:08:52
#19 You are simply not as good at judging people as you think. You're probably one of those people who think that every businessman is a self-interested, tax avoiding Tory. It has never been the case, and it is not the case now.
25

Bob 2,

30/09/2008 13:09:35
#8 In order for a business to be eligible for the (now closed) Small Business Support Scheme it had to:

1. Be in premises with a rateable value less than £28k.
2. Have a frontage on the tram route (or within 100m, on a side street - per amended eligibility rules).

LRT fails on both these counts.

The clue is in the scheme name - SMALL Business Support Scheme...

Thanks for the Info ....You could say that they qualify on 1 out the 2 criteria, as they have a bus on the tram route!!!

by the time TIE has finished they may be a small business

26

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

30/09/2008 13:12:38
become a rebel & get a £30,000 sweetner to buy you out
27

Alice in Embraland,

30/09/2008 13:16:08
#22 - wrong, wrong, wrong! I am anti-tram not because I am anti-public transport (I have a bus pass), but because this tram scheme is a bad idea, incompetently and corrupty executed. It will fail because its only purpose is political hubris, not public service.
28

Epicuras,

30/09/2008 13:20:40
give me 30K a year and I'll stop slagging off the trams 3 days a week - seems fair to me :-)

I do hope the selection/appointment proccess is/will be very clear and above board - in fact I hope an enquiry is already underway, to assure the people who are paying for the tram monstrosity, that this is not in reality just another 'brown envelpoe' - they come in many shapes and sizes you know
29

Hissy Fit,

30/09/2008 13:22:05
Duncan has gone from "hot air" to "steam from the ears" in only three posts today - a new record!

At this rate he'll be hired to power the trams.
30

Cassandra,

30/09/2008 13:25:44
#24 Pot and kettle? Atleast you're predictable. You always rise to the bait.
31

Duncan in Edinburgh,

30/09/2008 13:26:18
#29 I see no steam. Are you another character invented to launch ad hominem attacks on me? Someone must be very troubled that I continue to speak my mind around here.
32

Duncan in Edinburgh,

30/09/2008 13:28:31
#30 And why do you lay "the bait"? Why make things up about me just to rile me? What do you get out of it?
33

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 13:28:40
#29 I imagine the steam makes a "rather shrill" sound as it escapes...
34

Bob 2,

30/09/2008 13:33:15
YAWN............................
35

mockingbird,

30/09/2008 13:33:56
"What do you get out of it?"
More pleasure than you can possibly imagine, Big Boy.
36

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 13:41:59
#31 Dunc-E "I see no steam."

That'll be because steam is an invisible gas that only becomes visible as water vapour as it cools.
37

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 13:42:33
#34 Bob 2. Move along now. Nothing for you to see here.
38

The Meringueian,

30/09/2008 13:46:57
Ah yes, who have we here? Business person manqué Duncan, and the lovely Incandescent, of course. I and my wife Persephone welcome you to our little ménage à mock.
39

Anton Marionette,

30/09/2008 13:51:58
38

The bankers draft is on its way, Mario.

Please cease all respiratory activity forthwith.
40

Edinburgh 100,

Musselburgh 30/09/2008 13:55:02
He has basicly been bought off. I wonder how big a brown envelope was handed to him??????????/
41

Rap,

30/09/2008 14:00:28
#2 There is nothing stopping pedestrians and bus travellers from creating a group which can act and speak on behalf of them. Why don't you start one Howard? The West End Trader's Association (which is made up from the smaller shops in the West End, not those on shandwick place) have done a great job of joining together and promoting themselves, without Russell. Anyone seen the West End Village signs they have created? People power, free to everyone.
42

Slobberchops the Aesthete,

Leith 30/09/2008 14:09:32
Speaking as a small businessman, I'd like to contribute to this discussion, but unfortunately I'm too small to reach the keyboard.
43

Skip McClendon,

30/09/2008 14:10:26
#10

Nicely played.
44

Hissy Fit,

30/09/2008 14:29:37
It's been over an hour since we had any Dunc-E bo££ocks. Think he's exploded? It's not like him not to try and have the last word.
45

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 14:35:52
#45 Davy Descartes was quite clear on that point yesterday, but I didn't expect it to be heeded.
46

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 14:36:29
Come to think of it, where the deuce is G-Tone?
47

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 14:37:39
What an amazing coincidence that Tony and Jenny drop off the radar at the same time...or is it?
48

Incandescent,

30/09/2008 14:39:10
Perhaps Geekpie will be good enought to grace us today with yet another copy-and-paste of his critically flawed research?
49

Agent Smith,

30/09/2008 14:41:07
#39. In The Matrix, Frenchman, surely you are called The Merovingian?
50

ouime,

glasgow 30/09/2008 14:57:04
is it not a bit too late? surley this should have been done a long time ago!
51

Hissy Fit,

30/09/2008 15:01:30
Geekpie? What an open goal! He would be asking for an session of Mock-the-Geek. Much too easy.

Gorgie-T hasn't been heard of since: http://edinburghnews.scotsman.com/topstories/Dancing-banned-after-rival-clubs.4531818.jp
52

The Meringueian,

30/09/2008 15:14:56
Mais non mon ami, I have not any time for this old Salian Frankish history stuff. We are gourmands here at Le Vrai. we are enjoying the sweet dessert things of life.

Try some of this fine wine. It is 50% alcohol and 50% caffeine. It is selling so well to you Scottish that I have named it Fastbuck.
53

Jingsitsme,

EDINBURGH 30/09/2008 15:46:12
Another consultant! Another job for the boys!! They have the cheek to say they have to go through a proper recruitment process with these bias opinions.

It should go to someone with relevant experience but someone from outside area with fresh ideas and who has favourite areas!. The FSB to me are not forward thinking they are more a reactive organisation. Having been involved with them for years I was not impressed. Small businesses never grow. Growing ones do!!

If the FSB were anything and had ideas of getting business's back this would be in action now!

So it's a nay from me for FSB member to get post.
54

James (1),

30/09/2008 15:46:54
#52 Gorgie Tony has gone to a car boot sale, as he heard they were flogging cd's.
55

Jingsitsme,

EDINBURGH 30/09/2008 15:47:39
Re 54 above - I mean in 2nd paragragh NO favourite areas.

Sorry folks
56

Marie Antoinette,

30/09/2008 16:01:21
Did someone mention Meringue?

Mmmm, let me eat cake!
57

Jason L. McKenzie,

Moredun 30/09/2008 16:28:32
no. 2:

"Cue posts attacking the petrol-obsessed fuelheads who are of course the only people opposed to trams..."

Any bus users here care to take issue with this obvious nonsense?
58

Howard Moon,

30/09/2008 16:42:58
#58

Read it again.
59

The Meringueian,

30/09/2008 16:49:39
Be gone Marie Antoinette, you little squeaky pip. We do not allow you here to dine with us any more. You are liking to eat all of my special cake and spending the afternoon panting and moaning like the Austro-Hungarian trollop you are.
60

bumf,

30/09/2008 16:53:30
>55. He always struck me as more of a rammy badge than a bammy radge.
61

Proximo,

30/09/2008 16:55:59
Bob #11

"£30,000 for a 3 day week, how do you apply

that works out to an annual salary of £50,000 !!!!


Wow, sharp as a tack...
62

rs,

. Holes in the road 30/09/2008 17:28:47
yawn or snooze or boring as a few commentors have repeated about these NON tram stories

At the end of the day No One believes the TIE SPIN that Edinburgh is Open For Business, given the amount of Holes in the Roads and the Bus Diversions that are happening at the moment.

Journey that normally take 30 mins can take up to an hour....heavens knows what happens tomorrow when the Mound is CLOSED FOR BUSINESS.

West End Village... have you ever heard so much !!!!!

Good Night
RS

63

jdships,

30/09/2008 17:36:28
22 scotsol,
What a load of tripe .
There must be an awful lot of Tories in Edinburgh just given the number of anti tram posts on here .

A Lib/Dem Councillor told me a few weeks ago " Pity it will only serve 8/10% of Edinburgh residents but if nothing else the new tram line will be a great tourist attraction "

Says it all !!!!!
64

Jingsitsme,

EDINBURGH 30/09/2008 18:05:55
jobs for the boys and to a guy who is leader of a group of people who are reactive and not pro-active for business.

He should have been working all along helping the so called small business men keep in business, thinking up new ideas etc. They are small because they think small.

Some of these so called business's will jump on the blame factor rather than look at themselves. Others are doing better with all the road works as more people are on the pavements!

Peace of nonsense spending this money and 'appointing' before going through the due process! A job for the boys is what it is!

Think small they will always be small.
65

Jason L. McKenzie,

Moredun 30/09/2008 19:26:22
#59:

My bad! All my brain registered was the last para. Sorry!
66

,

30/09/2008 20:47:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
67

Julian.,

edinburgh 30/09/2008 22:33:52
jdships,

Thought the Tories were in favour of this tram line. I'm impressed with your memory that you can remember word for word what someone said to you several weeks ago.

And of course another way of saying the tram line will only serve 8 to 10% of the people is "as many as 55,000 people will be served by Edinburgh's new tram system"....all depends how you spin it, doesn't it.

Where's Euan by the way???

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.