Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 4th July 2009 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Outrage as Farmers' Market is cancelled at 11th hour



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 01 November 2008
STALLHOLDERS at Edinburgh's Farmers Market have been left outraged after today's event was cancelled at the 11th hour, with some estimating losses will be as much as £150,000.
The weekly market at Castle Terrace, which attracts up to 10,000 visitors every week, was called off just after 2pm yesterday.

Organisers Essential Edinburgh would say only that it was an "administrative error" and insisted they had launched a full inquiry into the problem.

But stallholders have said they are "disgusted" at the late call-off.

It is understood organisers discovered they did not have a licence to run the market and had not held one since taking over from previous organisers, Edinburgh City Centre Management, in July.

Around 40 producers from across the country were expected at the market and much of their produce is now likely to go to waste. For many of the small, speciality producers, the market is their main source of income, and there was outrage at the short-notice, which meant many producers had slaughtered animals "needlessly".

Caroline Hamilton, owner of West Lothian-based Mrs Hamilton's Organic Beef and Lamb, said: "We have been preparing all week for the market and we have orders from regular customers who will be turning up expecting us to be there.

"The market is our main source of income and this is a real problem for us, because we have had a difficult few months anyway.

"It is not good enough to be told that it is an 'administrative problem', as that is just a cop-out – this is affecting real people in a very serious way."

Takings at the market are estimated to be around £120,000 a week, but stallholders say they expect the cancellation to affect future markets.

While Essential Edinburgh insisted the market would be open for business next week, Dr John Fletcher, a partner with Fletcher's of Auchtermuchty venison producers, said the cancellation would have long-term effects for customers and stallholders.

"I am really disgusted at the way we have been treated by the bureaucrats who run the market," he said.

"We rely on the market for our income and quite apart from the fact they will have to compensate the staff who were due to work, we have killed an animal needlessly, which just infuriates me."

Councillor Alison Johnstone, leader of the city's Green group, said there had been no real reason given for the cancellation.

"This is an absolute outrage giving the traders such short notice," she said.

"Unless there's an absolute emergency this should not be allowed to happen."

Jenny Dawe, Edinburgh City Council leader, said she had instructed council officers to try and find places for the affected stallholders at alternate markets.

"It was Essential Edinburgh's responsibility to ensure it had a licence once it took over running the farmers' market," she said.

"It is my view that Essential Edinburgh should consider assisting traders with the unforeseen costs they have incurred."

Organisers Essential Edinburgh apologised for the cancellation, but stressed that the administration issues would be speedily resolved.

A spokesman said: "We have discovered some issues in the paperwork for the event. On that basis, we have an obligation to cancel.

"We apologise for any inconvenience caused and we will be talking with each trader to ensure they are comfortable with the way ahead."


The full article contains 565 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 November 2008 11:19 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

The Judge,

01/11/2008 12:08:29
Councillor Alison Johnstone, leader of the city's Green group, said there had been no real reason given for the cancellation.

How the hell did she become a councillor?

"This is an absolute outrage giving the traders such short notice," she said.

Did they have a valid licence sweetheart?

"Unless there's an absolute emergency this should not be allowed to happen."

If they obtain a valid licence it won't happen again.






2

Jenny MacArthur,

01/11/2008 12:09:23
Like hundreds of other members of the public, I turned up, only to find a handful of the usual vendors, trying to rescue their work preparing by selling from the backs of vans. This itself was probably technically illegal, but a blind eye was obviously being turned.

So why on EARTH couldn't the jobsworth organisers and council bureaucrats have agreed to turn a blind eye for one more week, to a situation that had existed since July anyway, and clearly was doing no one any harm. By sticking to their petty regulations letter of the law they have totally unnececessarily caused masssive inconvenience and losses to hundreds of local people and excellent small businesses. I mean, who on earth do they think would have complained?

The idiot bureaucrats responsible for this debacle should be sacked. The jobsworths who chose to cause such damage to protect their own paper-pushing backs due to the lack of one stupid form should be roundly condemned. Ideally they should be sacked for not having the common sense and initiative to take a simple decision to bend the rules for once.

Bureaucratic idiocy at its worst!
3

Jenny MacArthur,

01/11/2008 12:11:31
Oh, and FYI 1.The Judge, it's not the stall-holders who made the mistake. They suffered from the failings of the Council-appointed organisers. So get off your high horse about blaming the poor sods who work their guts out and then have their produce wasted and ruined due to paper-pushing jobsworths who care for nothing but their petty rules.
4

Black Five,

edinburgh 01/11/2008 12:13:43
What a red tape shambles.The people who caused this should have more common sense....sorry I forgot ANYONE who is a councilor or works for the council have no common sense..it`s part of the credentuals to be employed there.
5

alex paterson,

edinburgh 01/11/2008 12:13:48
Bring back Edinburgh City Centre Management they never made a mistake.
6

fruitmachine,

Edinburgh 01/11/2008 12:19:25
#2 + #4, surely the Council could have given authorisation - without having to 'turn a blind eye'.

We seem to be able to deprive people that have done nothing wrong of their liberty by mis-using anti-terrorist legislation, but can't approve a local farmers market in 24 hours!
7

NotaNumberYet,

Tollcross 01/11/2008 12:35:08
Administrative Mistake = Real Financial Loss

Heads must roll at Essential Edinburgh.

Jenny Dawe must also reflect on her pitiful 'nothing to do with me ' attitude. Take some responsibility Council Leader. Could the council officers instructed to find places for the stallholders at other markets not have been better employed speeding up the licence issue?
8

Dav,

Edinburgh 01/11/2008 12:36:43
Jenny #2 & #3 - Agree with you totally. Well said.
9

The Sheriff,

01/11/2008 12:42:52
Why don't they hold the "farmers Market" in a "farmers Field"?

I ask because why should the city centre be disrupted by this market who steal valuable parking spaces every weekend?

P. S. this is a windup
10

Anonym,

01/11/2008 12:50:33
Since this matter is going to be sorted out in time for the market next week, will the licence be backdated to July?

What a bunch of pedantic pillocks!

11

Scott_B,

01/11/2008 12:51:35
Calm down judge.

There has been no license since July, and the market has gone ahead - anyone with the ability to reason can see that one more week would make no difference, and impact the least number of people. Instead the people "in charge" proved themselves unfit to make decisions, by electing not to make a decision, stick to their rules, and inconvenience the maximum number of people.

Whoever made this decision is not fit to hold such a position.
12

Kirspin,

Fergus, Ontario twinned with Blairgowie 01/11/2008 12:58:45
I pity the many Vendors who use this outlet for most of there income, such things should not happen in the City of Edinburgh, is Edinburgh not a "World Class City" or just a back water Town? Some one needs to be "sacked"
13

observer9,

01/11/2008 13:05:42
If only the powers that be could shut down and penalise, drug dealers, jakies, counterfeiters etc so quickly.

The stallholders were dealing in healthy food, open and transparent commerce, no one was hiding their identity so why shut it down. The council dont seem to be pursuing the oxymoronically named Honesty Box that the councillors dont honour at the expense of Edinburgh council tax payers.
14

miffy the bonfire slater,

01/11/2008 13:32:23
#1 judge

come on now, be a nice chap and apologise. You are sooo wrong on this one.

Eejit
15

The Judge,

01/11/2008 14:01:12
I'll repeat for the hard of understanding.

Did they have a licence?

No

Have they had a licence since July 2008?

No

Should the market have went ahead on a "nod & a wink" until the licence was issued/backdated?

No

What's your problems? Some of you seem to think it's ok to break the rules when it's a market you attend.

How about we do away with licenses all together and have a free for all? Would that make you lot happier?

I didn't mention the stallholders nor the customers.

My post was about the idiot councillor who doesn't understand the reason why we have licences in the first place. I'm sure she could find something more worthwhile to be "outraged" about.

Don't panic I'm sure you'll all be able to buy your *ahem* organic produce in a week or two.
16

Douglas,

Bathgate 01/11/2008 14:12:06
I'm "disgusted".
17

SPG,

edinburgh 01/11/2008 14:28:50
Did you not know? Edinburgh is closed for business.
18

The Squirrel,

Princes Street Gardens 01/11/2008 14:34:38
Could I get three pigs,a sheep and a some horse steaks please.
19

Americanbob,

01/11/2008 14:45:04
Steady all the above, just think, no license = no public liability insurance. Something goes wrong as it did in Castle Street recently and all hell breaks loose. The faults here lie with both the city officials AND the company organising the event. Somebody somewhere must have known that the market was operating without a license. Stallholders must now be consider suing the organisers through the small claims courts for breach of contract to compensate for their losses. One test case should decide the issue for all.
20

The Judge,

01/11/2008 14:51:33
#19 Instead of starting legal action shouldn't the stallholders/organisers be thanking their lucky stars their not being fined for running an illegal marketplace since July 2008?



21

Peeter Reed,

fae Peterheid....... volvo for sale 01/11/2008 15:26:24
this story really winds me up. Incompetency is the word. Totally agree with Jenny, this is a disgrace.
22

tomias,

Edinburgh 01/11/2008 15:51:43
Agreed Jenny.
23

The Squirrel,

Princes Street Gardens 01/11/2008 16:18:44
Selling dead animals for profit isn't clever - a lot of horses, iguanas and molluscs I used to know ended up on dinner plates.

It's not comforting cheery or kind, it's murder.

24

Alberto.,

01/11/2008 16:19:55
If, as it seems, the Market has been operating since July minus an appropriate / necessary by Law license, something presumably laid down by ' The Council' - and they, 'The Council' presumably were apparently aware of this illegal activity situation, then someone, somewhere on this obvious 'Lax' Council, should be accused of dereliction of duty to the taxpayer, and also an accessory to the illegal operation, if only by way of turning an ‘alleged’ blind eye - or whatever and penalized for not taking appropriate action to put a sop to it!

The Council must surely have some ‘legal’ responsibility to see that the Laws they introduce are adhered to - by all, and not simply left to chance - unless, of course, there is more to this, shall we say - ‘Bureaucratic oversight!!’

Could be a classic case where eventually we discover it was really a ‘brown envelope’ operation - or maybe not, for whatever reason!

Surely as we trust, our Councillors - and their staff, are above such devious activities for Personal gain! However, from what we have and / are experiencing from people at many various levels in the current Bureaucratic organizations, seemingly here, there and almost everywhere - it would be foolish to overlook such possibilities - and only ‘fools’ would do so!

Seems like a few ‘fingers need extracting’ and much better attention being paid to administration, in this particular situation - from ‘both sides of the stalls!’

Next please!


25

Jock MacSprog,

Edinburgh 01/11/2008 17:42:24
It really is getting VERY tiring and depressing watching this City going down hill little by little. We should be one of the most vibrant and attractive small cities in Europe but our elected officials continually mess up one thing after another. Yet we then read that they place priorities on things like taking trips to India, and other junkets whilst the simplest things that other cities all over Europe and the world seem to do as a matter of routine, our numpty council leaders cant seem to pull off. Next election we all really need to take a close look at these "goverment worker for life" types who have been ruining this city for the past 20 years and start electing some competent LEADERS from the private sector, the military wherever. People who get things done and have more than a primary school education. No more party hacks, ex journalist, teachers etc. OUR COUNCIL IS RUINING THIS CITY !!
26

Scotish Exile,

01/11/2008 17:42:38
Jenny love, they were breaking the law, you are normally the first one to jump off your broom stick and complain when car drivers break the law, so keep quiet and give us a peace
27

Mallory,

Edinburgh 01/11/2008 18:12:29
Essential Edinburgh is, according to their website,

Ian Broadfoot, Chief Operating Officer
Mike Gallagher, Operations Manager
Richard Darke, Events Manager
Mhairi Potts / Shona Davidson, Office Manager (job share)
Emily Johnston, Marketing Executive
Lisa Ross / Gillian James , Administration Assistant (job share)
Grant Roberts, Markets & Events Assistant
Brian McAteer, Markets and Events Assistant
Joe Huckle, Exchange Warden
John Devlin, Exchange Warden
Charles Laurie-Magyar, Exchange Warden

So who forgot to apply for the licence and will the stall-holders sue for loss of business?

Maybe the Board of Directors will find out.
Andrew Murphy, John Lewis Partnership - Chair
Greg Ward, City of Edinburgh Council
Ian Bell, Royal Bank of Scotland
Gordon Drummond, Harvey Nichols
Ian Elder, House of Fraser
Ron Hewitt, Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce
Roger Littlewood, HBOS Group Property
Vinnie O'Brien, Standard Life Investments
Denzil Skinner, Hamilton & Inches
Jane Wood, Alliance Boots

Although some were probably pre-occupied with other matters.
28

Road Raga,

EDINBURGH 01/11/2008 18:13:55
#25, did you read the story ?

It was the organiser's responsibility to get a license.
Their fault entirely. Now lets stop blaming everything on the Council for once.
29

miffy the bonfire slater,

01/11/2008 19:25:05
#20 judge - you are still an eejit, we all know this fact and so do you.

30

Caitlinjean,

Edinburgh 02/11/2008 01:48:51
Americanbob correctly points out no licence = no public liability insurance. Five people were injured when market stalls blew over at the Italian Market in Castle Street , also operated by Essential Edinburgh , 3 weeks ago. These rules are not dreamt up by the Council. The licence is part of Scotland wide legislation in The Civic Government (Scotland Act) 1982.
31

,

02/11/2008 06:46:35
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
32

bumpkin,

02/11/2008 15:14:50
typical incompetent council.
lets screw private business, dig up the roads, increase the rates,make parking impossible, blow a billion on trams to non existent leith flats,from non existent expanded airport. how soon till the council goes bust? it cant happen quick enough.
33

JFW,

New Town 02/11/2008 15:27:42
A licence for this is just a bit of red tape that generates a wee bit of extra income for the council. The lack of licence for the event would not invalidate liability insurance (assuming the organisers didn't forget to organise that as well). This is just pen-pushing at its worst. 'Forgetting' about the issue and getting it resolved before the next market would've been the only sane decision. Well done you bureaucratic fools.
34

Caitlinjean,

Edinburgh 02/11/2008 23:53:35
#3 Bumpkin, it's up to the person running it to get the licence, same as any-one running a pub has to have licence.Operating a market without a licence is a criminal offence.
#JW , the licence is not just a bit of red tape, it's there to make sure things are run properly. People were injured at the unlicensed market held at Castle Street.As for the insurance, without the licence the whole thing is illegal and insurers are entitled to refuse to pay out for an illegal act.
35

Journalistic licence,

03/11/2008 12:37:34
I'm outraged, angered and disgusted
36

White hart,

Fife 04/11/2008 18:12:21
I'm one of those farmers market traders who has lost income. This impacts on the hardworking little team at our farm who are equally disgusted that their hard work has gone to waste. It may interest you to know that in order to trade at the Edinburgh Farmers Market, we all have to have public liability insurance anyway. So it was just the issue of Essential Edinburgh and the Council not managing to get their act together within a week. They knew about this days beforehand, yet as late as thursday evening we were being urged to dress up our stalls for Halloween. If they had only communicated with us, an awful lot of food need not have been wasted.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.