Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 6th September 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

I thought I'd lose my foot because of hospital delay



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 March 2008
A FOOTBALLER who had to wait more than two hours to be admitted to hospital after his ankle was shattered in a horror tackle has admitted he feared he would lose his foot.
Edinburgh United striker Lee Zavaroni, 22, suffered a dislocated ankle, ruptured ligaments and a fractured shin after the tackle in the Juniors match with Stoneyburn on Saturday.

He had to wait almost 30 minutes for an ambulance to arrive at Stoneyburn's Beechwood Park, and was then delayed for nearly two hours in getting to Edinburgh Royal Infirmary after the ambulance became stuck on the pitch and then suffered a puncture.

Mr Zavaroni, from Penicuik, is in his first season for the club and had scored two goals in Saturday's match before being injured.

He said: "I can remember looking down and just seeing my ankle hanging off. It was really horrible. I didn't know how much time was passing, but at one point I was beginning to wonder if anyone was going to come.

"Then when they did arrive the problems with the ambulance just made it worse."

The player was treated by the club's medical staff on the pitch, but due to the serious nature of the injury, which Edinburgh United manager Alan Miller said was the worst he had seen in more than 20 years of junior football, the decision was taken not to move him.

The ambulance drove on to the pitch but it became stuck in the muddy turf.

After staff helped get the vehicle moving again, it was discovered it had a flat tyre, so it was decided to go to St John's Hospital to change to another ambulance for the trip to Edinburgh.

Mr Zavaroni said that on arrival at the Livingston hospital he was refused treatment and driven on to Edinburgh.

He said: "When we got to St John's the ambulance staff said they wanted someone there to look at the injury as they couldn't find a pulse in my ankle.

"At that point I was sure I was going to lose my foot, and I couldn't believe it when I was told they couldn't treat me and we had to go to Edinburgh. The ambulance staff were great, but it was very concerning that it took so long to get to hospital."

Following treatment at the ERI he has been told he will be in a cast for eight weeks.

Mr Miller said: "Our main focus is Lee's recovery, and I will say that we will not be relying solely on the NHS as it is clear their services will not be good enough."

Dr Charles Swainson, medical director, NHS Lothian said: "There is absolutely no question that anyone requiring treatment would be refused or turned away at any of our A&E departments. We have also checked our patient records for this period and they confirm that no-one of that name was in the A&E at St Johns."

A spokesman for the Scottish Ambulance service said it was not a life-threatening injury and that the nearest available ambulance had been assigned to the case.

He added: "The trip to St John's was necessary because of the tyre problems on the ambulance, and I am not aware of any request for treatment being made there."


The full article contains 559 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 21 March 2008 10:40 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Health of the NHS
 
1

Artemis,

21/03/2008 12:02:11
If A&E at St John's refused to admit him, of course there would be no record.
2

dig dig,

21/03/2008 12:25:16
That will teach him to play football
3

THE BPRENTICE,

21/03/2008 13:05:40
the heading should say: 'a boy named sue!!'.
4

,

21/03/2008 13:17:08
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

Duncan in Edinburgh,

21/03/2008 14:26:37
Pity the NHS, when their hard work is thrown back in their faces by ungrateful oiks like this. He wasn't refused treatment - he got top quality treatment from one of the best A&E departments in Scotland. Most people would thank the NHS in the circumstances, but apparently this is beneath this footballer and his manager.
6

AD in sunny Livingston,

21/03/2008 14:43:26
#5 Spot on Duncan - well said.

7

baile atha cliath Hibs,

21/03/2008 15:17:56
shurrup ya dingal

ah nearly loast ma fit cause the doactir wouldnae fix it, n thats no fair so ah'm phonin the paper. It's no as if ye hud tae pay fur it

whair wur you when yer aunty leena couldnae find anyhing tae eat????

nae doubt oot playin kerby or sumhing!!!
8

Dragonlord,

21/03/2008 15:19:54
Lost his foot? Surely it would have been easy to find on a football pitch.
9

barra,

Edinburgh 21/03/2008 15:20:15
As usual everyone is at fault except the other player who caused the injury
10

Nakedheed,

Edinburgh 21/03/2008 16:57:39
Maybe he would like a 4X4 or a helicopter to take him to hospital
11

THE BPRENTICE,

21/03/2008 17:05:24
looking at the picture -has he lost his left hand?
12

Duncan in Edinburgh,

21/03/2008 17:23:39
#11 He's trying to disguise the fact that he's wearing a summer-weight skirt - in March!
13

zav,

penicuik 21/03/2008 17:47:11
yes i agree n.h.s treatment was great when i got to hospital,but st johns on 10 mins away from where i was why not send another ambulance rather than one 35 mins away?why refuse to take me in st johns to ambulance staff when having to go there to change ambulance?so duncan yes i did have the best treatment only 2 hours after the incident,not just a footballer remember i have a job and house to keep!couldnt do that with one foot mate sorry!clearly you havent been in a situ like that yourself.
14

Paul Voltiare,

21/03/2008 18:30:11
#3 the Blood Pressure Appendix, but his name is Lee, not Sue, can't you read ?
15

Duncan in Edinburgh,

21/03/2008 18:30:53
#13 So you really do consider yourself hard done by then? Stories in the EEN are rarely accurate so it's good to hear from the horse's mouth as it were.

Ask yourself: do you seriously think that the ambulance service thought "let's screw this guy around for no good reason"? Or do you think that perhaps they might have had a good reason for sending the vehicle they did?

Do you think that the staff at St John's preferred to get you quickly on your way to your destination, rather than attempt to start treatment there, in order to make things worse for you? Or do you think they assessed the situation and decided your interests were best served getting you to the RIE?

I wish you a speedy recovery, but honestly, do you really think you know better than the highly trained staff of the ambulance service and St John's?

If I had been in your position I'd have been thanking them, not complaining about them.
16

,

21/03/2008 18:34:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

Paul Voltiare,

21/03/2008 18:47:45
#15 Duncan - but you weren't in his position, so his feelings & experience is exclusive to him, do you not seriously think so ? Or do you not think at all ? Or do you really think you know better about things based on your knowledge of life, as viewed from a pc keyboard ? Or do you yourself think that you are hard done by ? I wish you a speedy recovery, but do you really know better than everyone else ? If I was in your position, I would really think it better to keep my mouth shut.
18

Carebba,

Edinburgh 21/03/2008 19:48:57
You have shown yourself up Mr Zavaroni and hopefully after a period of recovery and reflection you will realise how foolish your comments have been. As a healthcare worker having to deal with medical emergencies and trauma on a daily basis, i'm disgusted at your self absorbed attitude. We have one of the best healthcare systems in the world and you received top class teatment for FREE. Was it the ambulance staff's fault they got stuck? No, they were trying to come to your aid, on a muddy football pitch. They needed to collect another ambulance because believe it or not, they would have to have answered further call-outs after you. If you felt your care was so urgent at this point, could you not have called a taxi? I guess that would have cost money. I'm appalled at this story, it's shameful. You have no idea the wait that some elderly patients with broken bones have to endure when emergencies take priority over their care. They have every right to complain, but seldom do,understanding the need for others emergency care and appreciate the care and treatment they receive. You should be ashamed.
19

,

21/03/2008 19:51:37
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
20

Duncan in Edinburgh,

21/03/2008 20:23:33
#17 But you are in my position, and you have already posted three comments! And none of them have addressed the issue.

#18 has it bang on. I hope the lad was grateful to the people who cared for him in person, at least - but he has done neither them nor himself any favours in running to the local rag to complain about it.
21

Who let the dogs out?,

21/03/2008 22:14:17
So ungrateful !!

Did you lose your leg ? No!
Did they end up giving you first class treatment? - YES!

so many people is far worst situations that you. think about it before you go crying to a newspaper
22

Think Tank,

21/03/2008 22:29:41

Just to be clear there's no trauma/orthopaedics at St John's hospital, so admission would have been pointless unless in life threatening extremis. In fact it would have delayed the necessay ortho intervention by several hours.

23

bythelight,

21/03/2008 23:10:29
Can I ask as question to those who have posted on this......... how many of you, if you were in the same situation, would have been happy of the wait and mucking around to get the correct treatment???
I know for a fact that if it had been me I would have been a bit worried as to why it took so long to get my leg/foot looked at.
Granted it wasn't a life threatening injury but I for one wouldn't have been liking the thought of being told 'I'm sorry sir, the injury you sustained hasn't been treated quickly enough and because the blood circulation has been cut off to your foot for so long it's just not possible to save it........ we're going to have to amputate'
As the guy said......... he's got a life outside of football which I'm sure, like many of you, need both your feet for
24

Duncan in Edinburgh,

21/03/2008 23:28:17
#23 What mucking around? Honestly, I don't think you have a grip on what happened here. Do you seriously think that ambulance service staff and hospital staff were "mucking around"? It is quite evident they did all they could to get him the treatment he needed as soon as possible, and in the event, the treatment was successful.

Frankly I'm amazed that the NHS manages to retain any staff at all given the expectations of miracles, and the readiness of complaint, that this story has exemplified. The people I feel for are the ambulance staff reading this, who do their best day in and day out, and get nothing but public opprobrium for it from ungrateful little ... people like this chap.
25

Carebba,

Edinburgh 21/03/2008 23:47:42
#24 Spot on. I think this non-story really needs to come to an end.
#23 'Mucking around'?? Priceless.

Can i just clarify here: man fractures shin and dislocates ankle(ankles do not 'hang off') kicking a round piece of leather around a mucky field; man phones 999 for white taxi(this is a non-emergency by the way, even women in labour have to take a taxi to hospital and that can be life-threatening);ambulance has difficulties rescuing man, medics makes every effort to secure replacement vehicle to ferry man to correct hospital(orthopaedics is at Royal Infirmary with some of the best surgeons in the country); man receives free treatment and follow-up care. End of story. No amputation (which even after a few days of waiting would have been unlikely). Where is the story??? By all means Mr Zavaroni, go private. The cost will horrify you, you have no idea. Free up the NHS for people with more serious injuries and who appreciate the unconditional attention of an overworked but committed team of individuals. As i said earlier, this is shameful.
26

Paul Voltiare,

21/03/2008 23:58:14
#24 Duncan, what does it take to get through that thick bone in your head that you are over reacting to a hypothetical situation that you see yourself in & that you unfairly & unjustly level criticism towards someone who has actually lived the experience, which is something you cannot possible come to terms with in the wee twee world that you dream & live in. When you have lived the experience, then you might be in a better position to judge & criticise the actions of others who may well take a more realistic & different view & approach to that held by yourself. Until then,have the decency to respect & appreciate the sentiments of those dealing with first hand experience & pratical knowledge of something you know absolutely nothing about. Brown nosing to ambulance & hospital staff to make out you are a "good guy" is not necessary. Shame on you.
27

Paul Voltiare,

22/03/2008 00:03:48
#25 - ankles do hang off, shame on you for your ignorance. Try watching Extreme A&E - you might end up better educated.
28

Carebba,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 00:15:34
#27 Extreme A&E is for uneducated voyeurs. I've been a nurse for 8 years, don't insult me. Ankles do not 'hang off'. This is not a medical term but a lay term. Ankles dislocate or fracture, They do not 'hang off' unless you have a mishap with a chainsaw.
29

Duncan in Edinburgh,

22/03/2008 00:36:18
#26 I'm not over reacting, and it isn't a hypothetical situation. You appear to be of the opinion that the only person fit to pass comment on this story is the individual himself, and yet here you are on your - sixth? - comment. The fact is that he went to the paper, and he criticised the ambulance and hospital staff, so he opened the door to criticism of himself.
30

zav,

24/03/2008 13:20:45
haha you people are pathetic point 1 the newspaper called me and asked to do story i said no problem and told them what had happened,point 2 i had no problem with the treatment from hospital at all everyone there was great for me even the ambulance staff were all fantastic!so where you all think i am ungrateful is beyond me!i hope you enjoy slating more injured people.
31

zav,

in bed recovering 24/03/2008 13:21:28
haha you people are pathetic point 1 the newspaper called me and asked to do story i said no problem and told them what had happened,point 2 i had no problem with the treatment from hospital at all everyone there was great for me even the ambulance staff were all fantastic!so where you all think i am ungrateful is beyond me!i hope you enjoy slating more injured people.
32

zav,

in bed recovering 24/03/2008 13:22:28
haha you people are pathetic point 1 the newspaper asked me to call them when i got out hospital and asked to do story i said no problem and told them what had happened,point 2 i had no problem with the treatment from hospital at all everyone there was great for me even the ambulance staff were all fantastic!so where you all think i am ungrateful is beyond me!i hope you enjoy slating more injured people.
33

zav,

in bed recovering 24/03/2008 13:22:32
haha you people are pathetic point 1 the newspaper asked me to call them when i got out hospital and asked to do story i said no problem and told them what had happened,point 2 i had no problem with the treatment from hospital at all everyone there was great for me even the ambulance staff were all fantastic!so where you all think i am ungrateful is beyond me!i hope you enjoy slating more injured people.
34

zav,

in bed recovering 24/03/2008 13:22:38
haha you people are pathetic point 1 the newspaper asked me to call them when i got out hospital and asked to do story i said no problem and told them what had happened,point 2 i had no problem with the treatment from hospital at all everyone there was great for me even the ambulance staff were all fantastic!so where you all think i am ungrateful is beyond me!i hope you enjoy slating more injured people.
35

Carebba,

Edinburgh 26/03/2008 01:06:14
so, the newspaper randomly called you? No offence meant here, but you're not a premier league player, why would they have any interest in you and how would they have known about your accident and your 'issues' with the care you received? Hundreds of people have accidents in edinburgh every day, i dont believe the newspaper calls every one of them I think you're telling a half-truth here. A bit late now to back-track.

Also, who exactly are you complaining about then? If you're saying ambulance and hospital staff were great, then who are you complaining about?? Orthopaedics is at Royal Infirmary, not St Johns. Why do you think St Johns should have seen you?

I'm puzzled. You're either not very intelligent, or you're feeling sorry for yourself at the expense of all the people who helped you.
36

Carebba,

Edinburgh 26/03/2008 01:22:50
I re-affirm to you sir, you have made a complete idiot of yourself with this non-story. Quite sad, because you'll have to go back to hospital for follow-up care and some of the hard-working hospital staff will have read your critical comments in the evening news.
You have shown yourself in a bad light and havent done yourself any favours.

You're not David Beckham.....
37

fairybubbles,

21/07/2008 19:09:09
may i just add to this on going fued that it is not lee who was slating the nhs it was in fact mr.miller but it seems that the people quick enough to slate the injured part can not read!it makes me sick to think what the poor lad has been through and you get childish people not letting him put this horrible expireance behind him.and another point i would like to get across is maybe it isnt the injured party or the nhs we should be slating but infact the goverment as for it is them who give the nhs the funding for their services.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.