Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 3rd July 2009 Change Date

Which is the greatest game your team has ever played?

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

First look at eyesore site's £850m future



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 23 January 2008
Plans today reveal how ugly St James Centre will be razed and developed into a 'world-class shopping destination'
A MASSIVE £850 million revamp of the eyesore St James Centre was unveiled for the first time today in what is set to become the biggest city centre development for decades.

The scheme, which could be completed by 2015, includes new streets, two hotels, scores of shops and luxury flats, and public squares.

The existing shopping centre, adjoining office block and the Thistle Hotel – widely regarded as being among Edinburgh's ugliest buildings – would be demolished to make way for the development, which is designed to ensure the Capital can rival Glasgow and other cities as a major shopping destination.

In place of the 1973 "carbuncle", a three-storey, crescent-shaped arcade would be built – sweeping from Multrees Walk to the east end of Princes Street. The open-ended street would have a glass roof, with buildings made of stone, inspired by the historic 19th- century Galleria Vittorio Emanuele II in Milan.

Lower floors of the development would be home to cafes, bars and restaurants with outdoor dining, while up to 90 shops could be included in the arcade, close to St Mary's Cathedral and along Leith Street, where the entire scheme would link to the existing John Lewis store.

Three distinctive new buildings would be built in front of the arcade, surrounded by a public square and a separate, open-air pedestrian walkway between Princes Street and Elder Street.

CENTRE OF EXCELLENCE: Click here for an artist's impression of the new-look St James area, which is set to rejuvenate the tired-looking east end of Princes Street

At least one of the buildings would be likely to house a hotel, with anywhere between 80 and 150 flats developed alongside – many with spectacular views of the Forth.

A landmark "iconic" building – which could either tower above the development or be similar in height – would form the centrepiece of the scheme, likely to form part of the main hotel with a rooftop garden and Castle views.

Chris Pyne, senior portfolio manager at Henderson Global Investors – owners of the shopping centre and the New St Andrew House office block – said the proposals were designed to transform the site into a "world-class" destination.

"This redevelopment will provide a major boost to the retail offer in the heart of the Scottish capital," he said.

"We plan a contemporary and commercially vibrant development that will sensitively integrate into the urban fabric of Edinburgh.

"We recognise the significant public interest in the St James area, and the importance it holds for the future of the city.

"This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to make a positive difference to a city of global stature – and we want to move forward by working hand-in-hand with the local community that it serves."

The developer's vision also includes another hotel in front of St Mary's Cathedral, on council-owned land. The cathedral area would be sympathetically revamped, with a public square, cafes and restaurants, and another walkway leading to the main shopping area.

Main roads around the east end of the site are due to be re-modelled to accommodate a tram and bus interchange on Picardy Place instead of the existing roundabout, and there are plans to include a three-storey underground car park accessed from Elder Street.

The designs were today set to be revealed at the St James Shopping Centre as part of an eight-week public consultation, before an outline planning application is submitted to the city council in April. Demolition work could get underway in 2010, with the project completed five years later.

Edinburgh architect Allan Murray, along with the Building Design Partnership (BDP), was selected to draw up the scheme.

Mr Murray said the buildings would be of similar height to other properties on Princes Street and George Street, with a gentle slope towards Leith Walk, while the crescent-shaped galleria would be a natural extension from Multrees Walk.

The iconic central building in front of the arcade has been placed to follow the axis of both George Street and Leith Walk, acting as a focal point. Members of the public will be asked to comment on how tall it should be.

"This plan will transform the St James Centre area into a new urban quarter with high-quality buildings and public spaces, allowing it to fulfil its proper role as the commercial heart of Edinburgh's historic city centre," Mr Murray said.

The scheme would also include a number of new offices, as well as the huge number of new shops – up from 50 units at present. The amount of retail unit space would nearly triple. The project is also designed to ensure the area has mixed-use facilities, as both an attractive place to live, or enjoy an evening meal.

Developers hope to attract shoppers from the expanding Waterfront development, which will largely be served by the city's new tram network.

The modern car park will also be a significant improvement on existing arrangements. The future of the footbridge between the centre and Greenside remains to be decided.

The Thistle Hotel, which would be demolished in a break from previous proposals, would either be re-located elsewhere in the Capital, or receive compensation.

The flagship John Lewis department store would remain at the site, but would be internally "reconfigured".

Ron Hewitt, chief executive of Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce, said: "The proposed redevelopment represents a massive opportunity not only for Edinburgh, but also Scotland.

"The plan for the St James quarter is the most significant investment in the heart of the city in decades and will act as a catalyst for the regeneration of the city centre, particularly Princes Street."

Henderson Global has already been involved in one of the UK's premier retail developments – Birmingham's Bullring.

The firm bought the St James Centre for £184m in July 2006. The sale was the second time the complex had changed hands in the previous six months.

The chances of redeveloping the centre in the past were hampered by the fact that two parts of the site were owned by different people.

But Henderson Global also purchased the now-redundant office block, which was abandoned by Scottish Office civil servants in the early 1990s in favour of Leith's Victoria Quay, marking the first time in 30 years that both interests were held by the same owner.

The public exhibition will take place in St James Centre on the main shopping level opposite the Royal Bank of Scotland ATMs from today until March 17.

The plans can also be viewed online by visiting the website www.stjamesshopping.com.

The full article contains 1124 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

mrmoneypenny,

23/01/2008 12:07:49
No doubtm it will end up with poundstretcher etc in it
2

Pepper,

23/01/2008 12:13:35
And loads of wee gadgies hanging about
3

,

23/01/2008 12:13:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

reader,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 12:16:04
This finally looks like an excellent plan. Pulling down the existing building is the only thing that makes sense.
5

Iain Bhern,

23/01/2008 12:16:36
To attract me to the new centre they will have to attract better shops. I do all my shopping in Newcastle city centre as that city has the shops I want to visit, Edinburgh doesn't!
6

Pepper,

23/01/2008 12:19:56
#5

What kind of shops does Newcastle have that Edinburgh doesn't? edinburgh does tend to have most of what a lot of other cities have but ours are much more spread out unfortunately.
7

Grouchy,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 12:21:43
I don't like the idea of a hotel in front of St Mary's Cathedral. Also I hope the car park has as many if not more spaces than the current multi storey car park.
8

roberto,

23/01/2008 12:26:41
thank god there's gonna be luxury flats
9

Sarah B,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 12:29:43
This actually looks quite attractive (for once) but a picture of the outside of the development would be useful. As the editorial on this subject says, that devil will, no doubt, be in the detail.

However, I also am not at all keen on the idea of an hotel in front of St Mary's Cathedral.

10

Duncan in Edinburgh,

23/01/2008 12:30:20
Looks fantastic to me.

#7 Neither do I. Fortunately they aren't planning to build one there.
11

Brian Ferrari,

23/01/2008 12:30:52
Looks like Glasgow. Come on, use some imagination!!
12

Sarcasm,

23/01/2008 12:44:30
Well let's hope they make a better job of laying the tramlines than shown in the picture.
13

DonaldK,

Brussels 23/01/2008 12:46:34
#8 - me too, I couldn't sleep for worrying that there would be no luxury flats included in these plans. I'm a bit disappointed it's only planned to make an urban quarter though - I was hoping for a half at least.
14

Bob 2,

23/01/2008 12:54:24
amazing, every year we are told that Shops are struggling.
Yet heres another development of some 90 shops (like how they've sneaked in 150 flats(know doubt affordable, only £350k, right).

15

Jams,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 13:03:50
I think they mean they might get Planning Permission by 2015, but only if they are very very lucky.
16

eric,

Lothian 23/01/2008 13:50:10
Rival Glasgow Hilarious, My family and freinds have been shopping in Glasgow for 30yrs ,Theres nothing here thats going to change that,
17

Country Life,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 13:51:39
The existing John Lewis store is staying. Given that this is one of the most prominent parts of the St James it'l leave the job half done at best.
18

Leila,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 14:03:23
There's no doubt the St James Centre is ugly on the outside, but it's a bit of a risk completely closing the shopping centre for 5 years, and I can't imagine John Lewis will be happy about being the only store open on a demolition/building site.
19

,

23/01/2008 14:43:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
20

Pooh,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 14:43:18
It amazes me how many negative comments there are.

I don't think anyone would disagree that the current building is unattractive, with a dire shopping experience, reminicent of a larger scale Cameron Toll.

If it is done tastefully and to a high standard, then this can only be a benefit.
21

Johnny Yen,

23/01/2008 14:50:22
the sketches might as well have included flying pigs for all the chances there are of it looking like that. Seen all before in visions for Princes St and the like. It all never happens.
22

Aye Right...,

23/01/2008 14:54:16
They'll change their minds in 5 years time and decide on building a trams terminus... with a Poundstretcher outlet.
23

Duncan in Edinburgh,

23/01/2008 15:48:28
#24 There is a Harry Ramsden's in the Waverley Market but it's sh!te.
24

Andrew,

west of Edinburgh 23/01/2008 16:10:39
For a second or two, I THOUGHT I SAW TRAM LINES!!!
25

Tomsk,

23/01/2008 16:15:44
#16

Eric

It is impossible for me to say the following without patronising you, so please take it in the spirit is it offered.

I am sure you have something very interesting and very important to say in each of your daily contributions. Alas, because you are illiterate, it is invariably difficult and often impossible for your readers to comprehend your intended meaning.

Perhaps it is because you are of primary school age. Perhaps you are a moron. Perhaps you are a Weegie. Perhaps you are just plain thick. Of course, I am not discounting the very real possibility that you are all four.

Can I suggest you take a course in basic communication skills? Ask your carer to point you in the right direction. We would all benefit.
26

tomias,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 16:21:16
Re Tomsk; a little more sympathy please- he( she) and the family have been stuck in a Glasgow shopping centre for 30 years! Now the film.
Kelman has it all down on paper.
27

Duncan in Edinburgh,

23/01/2008 16:26:13
#27 Typical Edinburgh Womble. The Wombles in Glasgow are far nicer.
28

Sarah B,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 16:52:31
Oh, my word - I've just taken a look at the suggested elevations for this project on: http://www.stjamesshopping.com/development.php

If this is what they are talking about, I suspect the inside of the development may be a great deal more acceptable than the outside!
29

Duncan in Edinburgh,

23/01/2008 17:12:00
#30 Where?
30

Ian Ross,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 17:47:29
Put it back to how it looked pre St James Centre - the place had character.
31

Ganjass,

23/01/2008 18:11:04
Ocean Terminal, there's a quality piece of design. If it's going to finished to similar standard then fair play, it's got to be better than whats there already!

If it's going to be world standard though, they best get shops other than Claire's accessories and the disney store in there!

If the consultants need an idea on how to do the shopping thing, look no further than Hong Kong, they've got the whole experience down.
32

Sarcasm,

23/01/2008 18:42:15
34.
Have you ever stood back and looked at the monstrosity of Ocean Terminal.

aye Hong Kong right enough, that'll blend in nicely.
33

Dave B,

23/01/2008 19:13:17
The rooftop garden sounds good.
34

Ghost Of Scotland Past,

23/01/2008 21:36:40
1) The John Lewis Bit is ok
2) If you don't want a hotel in front of the cathedral
demolish the Cathedral, it serves no useful purpose,and is an offensive eysore too.
3) If the eating establishments are to have outdoor areas
does this mean we can smoke there? I rather doubt it.
4) Will they be re establishing the surgical supplies shop and radio shack next door which used to be in the
little arcade bit at the bottom of Leith Street
across from the wee churchy place Pope JP2 went to.
35

Mr Fuzzy,

Edinburgh 23/01/2008 21:42:29
#30
PDF Document

http://www.stjamesshopping.com/stjamesconsultation.pdf

The document seems to be concerned more with sticking something up in the skyline than accessibility or the stores that will be there. No doubt the luxury flats will be somewhere up there.
36

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 23/01/2008 21:58:59
just.looks.like.another.big.greenhouse.last.30yrs.
37

Ganjass,

23/01/2008 22:15:51
Sarcasm, aptly named, is you're other name waste of space??
38

Sarcasm,

23/01/2008 22:54:00
So that's a no then for the "eyso're"
39

Roger Irrelevant,

24/01/2008 00:06:16
The entire article is testament to Scotsman/Evening News hacks' abilities in the "cut and paste" department.

At least Radio Froth* tried to make the story interesting by calling the proposed new development a "skyscraper". Oh, how I smiled to myself!

(*not a typo.)








Joke of the Day:
Q:What's the difference between an EN hack (Gibbo, perhaps) and a supermarket trolley?
A: You can get more food and drink in an EN hack.
40

Graeme Gibson,

Sydney Australia 24/01/2008 08:31:58
How come so many flash new buildings and so many street problems with drunks and the unemployed. Dont you want to control future crime?
41

Nick Keene,

Edinburgh 24/01/2008 10:52:58
Ghost of Scotland Past
I don't know if you are trying to be deliberately offensive by saying that a place of worship for 2,000 people each weekend serves no useful purpose but you should at least respect the fact that for a great many people the continued existance of St Mary's Cathedral does matter.
The cathedral has been blighted by the St James' Centre for 35 years and it does not deserve to be to faced with an even worse situation whereby it is entirely surrounded and with a hotel literally on its doorstep. More to the point perhaps the 'Evening News' could enquire as to whether the architects concerned have along with BDP satisfied themselves that the City Council hold a recorded clear legal title to the land upon which the hotel is to be built. It may be the case that the cathedral authorities once owned this land-in fact I am sure that they did-and that if was gifted/ acquired by the council presumably at the time the roundabout was built then is it not likely that the cathedral representatives at the time required the council to seek their approval to any developmant on the site? Step forward the agents who acted for the cathedral and look at your old files.Someone needs to research this.
42

Pmonkey7,

24/01/2008 11:39:50
#44 Nick.

http://www.edinphoto.org.uk/0_eng_ma_060/0_engraving_-_ma_072++b_picardy_place_col.htm#engraving
43

Buttress,

24/01/2008 11:44:15
A new Director has been announced today for the Edinburgh World Heritage Trust.

44

Ghost Of Scotland Past,

24/01/2008 14:08:12
Thanks 45)nice picture which reinforces my point it looks much better with a large natural tree in front of it and sandwiched between period buildings of it's own time. Much less obtrusive.
44) Of course I was being as offensive as possible and trying to engender debate about such wastes of spaces as buildings for the pursuit of ritualised and habitual superstition. when there is so much homelessness, hunger and disease in the world about which these hypocritical and rich institutions do very little.
If you want it to be as you want it start praying to the deity of your choice.
45

Buttress,

24/01/2008 14:28:25
http://www.ewht.org.uk/New-Director.aspx
46

Old Town Resident,

edinburgh 24/01/2008 15:58:34
"This plan will transform the St James Centre area into a new urban quarter with high-quality buildings and public spaces, allowing it to fulfil its proper role as the commercial heart of Edinburgh's historic city centre," Mr Murray said."
Is there any pie this Murray doesn`t have his fingers in?
http://independentrepublicofthecanongate.blogspot.com/2008/01/whos-that-guy.html
47

Nick Keene,

25/01/2008 16:40:52
Ghost of Christmas Past

I will include you in my prayers this Sunday .
48

Mallory,

Edinburgh 11/02/2008 12:54:23
..The open-ended street would have a glass roof, with buildings made of stone, inspired by the historic 19th- century Galleria Vittorio Emanuele II in Milan...

They used the same rubbish about the development at Haymarket at Morrison Street.
49

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 12/02/2008 02:06:06
THEY WILL TREAT THE CATHEDERAL LIKE THE CEMETERYS
50

Young Gordon,

The Shore 15/02/2008 13:59:42
Inspired by another Spanish architect? - oh dear!
51

jamtart,

Beechboro 06/03/2008 02:07:42
#3 You sound fu#kin ugly

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.