Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 9th January 2009 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

City banks on extra recycling bins to solve overflow crisis



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 September 2008
MORE recycling banks are to be installed in supermarket and shopping centre car parks across Edinburgh in a bid to cope with soaring public demand.
The Evening News has been inundated with complaints about overflowing recycling banks in recent months.

One of the key problem areas is the larger recycling sites, such as the one in the car park of Craigleith Retail Park.

The complex has doze
ns of bins in its recycling centre but they fill up very quickly each day.

The planned increase comes just days before city leaders are set to unveil their latest strategy to increase Edinburgh's recycling rate.

Council chiefs today said the banks at Craigleith suffered from trade waste being dumped in them.

Opposition politicians and environmental groups said upping frequency of collections was just as important as increasing the number of banks.

Inverleith councillor Lesley Hinds said: "I have had a number of complaints about these banks at Craigleith stretching back quite a while.

"It is just not good enough if we have people who are willing to make the effort to recycle but have them facing this kind of thing.

"They can add all the recycling banks they like, but unless they do the bread and butter job of actually emptying them enough then there is no point."

The council's current recycling rate is running at around 26 per cent – below the Scottish average of 29.8 per cent.

The next target facing the council is 30 per cent recycling of all waste by next year.

Mark Sydenham, spokesman for Friends of the Earth Edinburgh, said the scene at Craigleith Retail Park was typical of recycling bins across the city.

He said: "It is a real problem, I am sure if you ask most people who live in the city then they will be able to think of a recycling bank they pass which is overflowing.

"We are in danger of giving recycling a bad name.

"Obviously more recycling facilities are welcome, but I do hope they give serious thought to the frequency of collections."

Figures released to the News last year showed more than 18 people per day are complaining about the city's recycling service.

The number of complaints had increased seven-fold in the past three years as the council has expanded recycling provisions.

The multi-material kerbside recycling scheme now covers more than 112,000 households citywide and there are more than 700 communal recycling points in Edinburgh.

A council spokeswoman said: "

This site has proved hugely popular and is currently being serviced every day of the week.

"Unfortunately, on occasion, sites are not used as they should be and materials are dumped illegally by traders or aren't flattened down before recycling, which can lead to banks filling up quickly.

"We are working with the environmental wardens to prevent illegal waste being dumped at these sites and we are in the process of identifying more sites, purchasing more recycling banks and a vehicle to service them."





The full article contains 506 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 September 2008 11:31 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

SDRAWKCAB,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 12:14:04
Why don't these people get recycle bins in their houses?
I've got them. Just go onto the council website and request them.
You get 2 bins. A blue one and a red one. You also get a schedule of the collection dates.
it's not hard people! quite whining and do something about it if you are that concerned about recycling.
2

Unnecessary Whinge Alert,

08/09/2008 12:19:52
See # 1

Why just do the minimum and fill a little box, but if it eases your conscience.
3

Grumpy,

08/09/2008 12:21:03
(1) - That's fine providing the refuse trucks aren't off the road because they're waiting for spare parts to come from Italy.

But just where do you keep all these bins? Lots of people I know in terraced houses and lower flatted villas have to keep them by their front doors - and that gets really smelly never mind unsightly.

And when you get threatened for big fines if you overload or put a glass bottle in the wrong bin, or they cut back your bin emptying to once a fortnight, then it's hadly surprising that the recycle centres are heavly used.

And of course businesses will use them if they can avoid the charges that the council impose.
4

shopgirl08,

edin 08/09/2008 12:22:13
Not everyone in the city can have the boxes and even if they do use them you cant recycle plastic so you still have to use places like the supermarket to do this
5

Normy,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 12:25:08
#1 you cant put plastic waste in the kerbside boxes so you either chuck it out or still have to make a trip to the nearest recycling place. I've stopped using the boxes because of this and now make a weekly trip to the recycling station instead.

http://www.changeworks.org.uk/content.php?linkid=317#kerb
6

alex paterson,

edinburgh 08/09/2008 12:26:23
Stuff them stick the lot in your Wheelie bin.
7

Cappo Del Monte,

08/09/2008 12:29:16
would this be the plastic that is baled and shipped half way round the world to china to re-use?
It creates a more pollution, a lot more, hardly enviro friendly, as are all the other things dumped in landfill that they profess to recycle
8

David Harrington,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 12:37:41
Personally I think incineration is better than recycling in many cases, but we need to do more of both
9

celtic4,

USA 08/09/2008 12:52:04
Packaging seems to be a problem here. We get more plastic and paper than product. If the packaging plants would use less, there would be less waste. But try and get them to comply....
10

JT,

08/09/2008 13:12:34
This is good news if you have a car, but as alot of the city, I dont and I live in a flat so communal bins are really the only way as we already have mice in the block thanks to our neighbours.
11

PaulB,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 13:26:47
What an excellent diea - we also need the council to crack down on builders stuffing their trade waste into public communal bins - it happens all over Edinburgh - a few hefty fines on the culprits would stop this quick enough. No wonder the bins overflow!
12

Shave,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 13:32:14
"Council chiefs today said the banks at Craigleith suffered from trade waste being dumped in them."

Suffered!!?! If some businesses take the trouble to recycle it should be welcomed, not discouraged because it causes the council a bit of extra work.
13

PaulB,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 13:36:38
#12 - the bins are for the public - not builders - they are abusing the system instead of paying to have their rubbish removed. Since when were bricks, old plaster board and pieces of wood meant to be recycled - fine these cowboys heavily and make an example of them and leave the bins for their proper purpose!
14

Shave,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 13:56:23
#13 PaulB
I fully agree that trade waste should not be dumped in bins. And, yes, they should be fined.

However, there is a lot a trade waste that is going into landfill when there should be a way for it to be recycled. Landfill tax isn't proving incentive enough for private waste companies to do recycling collections. That leaves no other option for responsible minded businesses but to use public recycling banks.

Reduce, re-use, recycle for the common good.

p.s. Bricks can be recycled into hardcore at council depots.
15

Ed_Izmir,

Turkey 08/09/2008 13:57:38
Don't put more bins....empty them more often!!
16

shopgirl08,

edin 08/09/2008 15:40:33
Maybe you lot should get your facts straight before you go hell bent for leather bashing all recycling in the city - not every Council sends recycling to China, and when has any home owner in Edinburgh actually been threatened with, or given a fine for not recycling or doing it wrong? That's right, never, because there is no such system in place. I think you'll find the only people at risk of fines are the companies/builders using bins meant for the flats and I think these fines are right because the bins get full of their rubbish (which they legally need to pay to get rid of) so we can't use them.
17

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

08/09/2008 16:43:39
#16 - they harass you though by questioning you every time you don't put out a recycling box. Its like its compulsory to do so. They'll introduce fines next for people who dont put out these boxes.
18

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

08/09/2008 16:45:36
#14 - whether it is trade waste or not - the fact is its waste & these bins should be able to cope, regardless of who uses them.
19

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

08/09/2008 16:46:16
some people don't have talk rubbish !
20

shopgirl08,

edin 08/09/2008 19:33:53
#14 Do you know there is legislation which requires businesses to pay for the disposal of their waste. By using bins designed for home owners they are breaking the law. The Council shouldn't have to foot the bill and put up with the grief you folk give them for not coping with the service because businesses are too cheap to get rid of their waste legally. If it were okay for businesses to use the bins they wouldn't be sneaking to them at 3am and dumping bags and bags of glass bottles in banks in a housing estate like my local pub does now would they? They wouldn't peel identifying labels off their cardboard like my local chinese does? I known they do it because I've seen them with my own eyes! They do this because they know its wrong and they can get into trouble for it. Yes businesses should be encouraged to recycle, but like home owners are being asked to, they should do it the right way. Businesses would be the first to complain if i rocked up and dumped my household waste in their bins when they pay to have it taken away!
21

Tam189,

edinburgh 08/09/2008 20:00:45
I think the bin men should me kept to the official finishing time
They do there route then off home they go
and now they are getting overtime to lift the bins that are overflowing if they worked to proper hours the rubbish could all be cleared up in normal hours


22

tumshie heid,

08/09/2008 21:16:37
#20 Most buisnesses get humped every which way by the council and I don't blame them for getting rid of rubbish this way. If it isn't hazardous waste then why shouldn't it go out with everyone elses rubbish? Why should they have to pay someone to take away glass that they (the council) are then going to make money on by recycling? Perhaps if the council got its finger out and upped refuse collections these problems wouldn't occur.
23

Shave,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 21:43:03
#20 shopgirl08
So you would prefer all those bottles to go into landfill rather than be recycled?
24

Julian.,

edinburgh 09/09/2008 01:25:14
Alex Paterson,

Maybe we should stuff you in a wheelie bin.

With all these cctv cameras we keep hearing about why not just put one up at each superstore. That would soon deter people from illegal dumping.
25

tumshie heid,

09/09/2008 08:09:49
#24 Great idea. As if we aren't being watched enough. This country is a joke. Crime is at a peak yet people wan't resources wasted on trivia like this.
I agree with Alex and I do just throw the lot in my wheelie bin. If the council wants to recycle then let them sort it out.
As for recycling at the supermarket car parks etc, how much c02 is emitted by people DRIVING to these places just to dump a few plastic bottles? The logic defies belief.
26

Julian.,

edinburgh 09/09/2008 17:55:00
Turnshie

"As for recycling at the supermarket car parks etc, how much c02 is emitted by people DRIVING to these places just to dump a few plastic bottles"

Probably about zero grams as most would do it the same time as their shopping. That's the thing about those who give a sh!t about the environment. They think anout things like that, unlike those like yourself:-)
27

starloveruk,

Edinburgh 09/09/2008 22:17:41
Alex you may think that putting it in the wheelie bin is you making some kind of stand against the council, but you are wrong!! Are you not aware of the EU legislation that puts pressure on countries to divert rubbish from landfill (which to dumb it down for you is what reycling schemes do!!). If these targets are not met then member countries will be fined - who do you think will pick up the fine- The people that produce the waste-YOU!!
get with it and stop your moaning!!
28

John Abbey,

Worksop 08/01/2009 21:21:25
A very interesting article highlighting a subject that is about to become more and more of a problem in the coming years. The company I work for has recently developed a recycling station encompassing four bins for internal or external use in offices, schools, public buildings etc. The station consists of bins for the recycling of: Glass / Plastic / Paper / cans. The stations are ideal for any company or public body wanting to enhance their recycling capabilities and can also help towards achiving the ISO 14000 Environmental Standard. We are now looking into all the systmes currently used for recycling and looking at ways of developing new improved systems. Our present range of recycling bins can be bought at http://www.impbins.com


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.