Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 25th July 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Planning row recycling plant operators go into liquidation



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 April 2008
THE operators of a controversial recycling plant in Leith have gone into liquidation.
The Alba Recycling site on Bath Road had been at the centre of protests in the local community, amid claims it had been operating without the correct planning permission.

City councillors agreed to take enforcement action to shut it down, while th
e Scottish Environment Protection Agency also banned it from taking in any more rubbish over concerns about a "stockpile" of waste on the site.

Alba hit back and said the site never legally required planning permission.

However, it has now been confirmed that the company went into liquidation on April 22, with accountancy firm Deloitte and Touche appointed to deal with the company's assets.

Yesterday, the gates to the site were padlocked and the plant was deserted.

Leith councillor Gordon Munro said: "A company going into liquidation is never usually good news. However, this will hopefully see the end of speculative and tenuous planning applications in Bath Road which were of huge concern to the local community."

Leith Links Residents' Association, which has been battling with the plant for nearly three years, was celebrating the news.

Linda Tarbuck, chairperson of the association, said: "It would be a great relief if it was all at an end. I would be delighted.

"We have been fighting for this for nearly three years now. I'm certainly not against recycling, but they had no permission for a change of use of the site from a goods storage site to a waste transfer and sorting plant."

The Bath Road plant was licensed to store up to 24,000 tonnes of waste, but the association and council chiefs have argued for years that it never had planning permission.

The company said it did not need permission as the site was owned by Network Rail and some materials were removed by rail, meaning it would benefit from development permission granted to railway activities.

A spokesman for Deloitte and Touche said that the accountancy firm could not comment on the future of the company.

He said: "I can confirm that Brian Milne has been appointed as liquidator and (managing director) Theresa Binnie has been invited to attend a meeting, which is scheduled for Friday."

He said the firm would await the outcome of the meeting.





The full article contains 389 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 April 2008 10:52 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Environment
 
1

Epicuras,

Leith 30/04/2008 14:13:49
mmmm, Alba Recycling - wasn't it called Recyling Scotland when the row first broke out; and supported by un-named oficials from Edinburgh Council (remember the public meetings?)
Doubt this'll be the end of it but wouldn't it be nice if somebody could find out where Theresa Binnie lived and dumped a few tens of thousand tons of rubbish outside her front door - no planning permission needed of course - just drop a brown envelope off at the planning dept':-)
2

paul the binman,

30/04/2008 14:23:55
I wonder if she lives in Oatsley or did she live in Kaimes or maybe near Roseburn,yep,these are all the places were the good people of Edinburghs rubbish gets dumped.But I suppose thats ok because its not on our door steps huh......
3

Epicuras,

Leith 30/04/2008 15:06:55
Morningside, Bruntsfield or the New Town no doubt.
And while I'm here; Independence For Leith! - and stuff yer stupid unwanted, un-needed trams where the sun don't shine (it shines only on Leith)!

feel better now :-)
4

gotalottosay,

30/04/2008 16:11:43
epicuras...

i agree with you whole heartedly.. leith is a wonderful place, i lived there for just about 2 years and the sun difinetely sun on leith. ive stayed in a few places in edinburgh i.e. corstorphine, the grange, barnton, and leith is tops for friendly folk. DEFO!
5

gotalottosay,

30/04/2008 16:13:09
or maybe "the sun definetly "shone" on leith. opps!
6

Haveit,

Edinburgh 30/04/2008 16:55:10
#1 Epicuras,

Would be delighted to know exactly how close to your doorstep Bath Road actually is... or are you just another ar*e that clearly has nothing better to do with there time than post pointless and uneducated comments about a subject you clearly know very little about. I don't suppose the fact that bath road is not a residential area makes any difference to your views. Can I also ask what exactly you would propose the council does with its rubbish? And when we as council tax payers get hit with rises when the council gets fined millions of pounds for missing its recycling targets, will you be complaining about the need for something to be done - wasn't this preventable? I know - how about a recycling transfer station..........as long as its not within a hundred miles of your palace of course......
7

,

30/04/2008 19:19:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

Epicuras,

Sunny Leith 01/05/2008 12:00:41
#6 Haveit - about a 100 yrds, and you obviously don't know Leith if you think it's not a residential area - come and have a look!
while the rubbish is annoying its the hundreds of lorries per day that would arise if they ever got the site running as they want to that's the problem.
There are plenty of brownfield sites away from residential areas they could use. As for the millions of pounds in fines - don't make me laff - seafield sh*t farm only got fined a few thousand for pumping huge amounts of raw sewage into the forth - at worst, a telling off and a few more brown envelopes will cover that problem.
don't think it's me talking out of my ar*e!
9

Don't know jack!,

Sunny Leith 02/05/2008 15:55:32
#8 - about a 100 yrds, and you obviously don't know Leith if you think it's not a residential area - come and have a look!

Ha bloody ha of course there are houses - most of them are in converted mills and factories as Leith was and is the port for Edinburgh!! Look at the industry that's still there - a concrete plant opposite the Alba site spewing dust and carbon dioxide into the atmosphere - are they next on your hit list?? All the vehicles coming and going and all the jobs they provide? How about the skip hire companies who operate from the docks? The fertiliser company? The engineering companies? The carpenters? How many jobs do you want lost by turning an industrial dockland area into a swanky shore residential site?

#8 - open your eyes!!
10

Haveit,

The Pond 02/05/2008 16:08:15
#8

If you think you stay 100 yards from the recycling plant - I hope your not an estimator or a carpet fitter!!!
11

Waste Warrior,

Work 03/05/2008 11:23:29
#2 Paul the Binman,

I'm sorry to have to correct you, but as you are evidently not furthering your career by doing an SVQ in waste management you would not know that the waste stream you refer to is municiple (Household) waste and unlike the good people of Edinburgh who sit oblivious to the fact that their waste by going straight to landfil under the control of the council is more than likely in breach of the European Landfil Directive... Whereas Commercial or Industrial waste streams must go to a Recycling Center By Law! so I'm affraid that we must get used to these establishments. After all we vote the members who draft the Laws into power. Paul you did vote Labour didn't You?
12

Waste Warrior,

Work 03/05/2008 11:56:31
#8 Pedicure or whatever,

You hit the nail on the head, Unfortunately Leith is a brownfield site. How do you think all those developers decided that Leith was the place to build houses - Yes thats right because the land was cheaper than Morningside. So where do we stand? The speculative developers bring residential elements int the heart of Edinburghs industrial lands and you expect the other 80% of Leith to roll over and give way to the newcommers? not on your nelly.. The lorries will still run because thats what feeds an industrial area like the port of Leith and as such the Recycling centres associated with the industrial heart of a major city will be close at hand. Im sorry, the council know this or else why do they have Seafield, so perhaps you should have looked to buy a house in a residential area.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Do you think it’s right for the council to spend £100,000 on a tree survey?
Yes, urban trees are so important to the quality of life
No, the cash could be spent on better things
Idea’s great, timing terrible given the cuts to services

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.