Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Monday, 2nd November 2009 Change Date Latest Issue

Leadership is not the only change needed

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 11 September 2008
LABOUR'S new Scottish leader will be unveiled at a special gathering in Glasgow this weekend. Whoever gets the job faces a tough task – and it's not just taking on Alex Salmond every week at First Minister's Questions.
If Labour is to have any chance of returning to power at the next Scottish Parliament elections, it has to find an effective way of opposing the SNP Government, reinvigorating its own activists and re-establishing its credibility with the electorate.


Voting in the three-way contest closed at teatime on Tuesday and the ballot papers are now being counted by independent polling companies.

Labour officials say no-one in the party will be told the result until Saturday morning and the three candidates – Iain Gray, Cathy Jamieson and Andy Kerr – will only find out moments before the official announcement.

The winner will become Labour's fifth leader in the nine years of devolution.

Pundits have made Mr Gray, the East Lothian MSP and former Enterprise Minister, the favourite. But even some of his supporters say the contest is "too close to call" and predict it will come down to Mr Gray against Ms Jamieson, with the outcome being decided by the second preferences of Mr Kerr's backers.

Once the result is announced, as if to underline the problems facing the party, the new leader's first engagement will be to go to campaign in the Glenrothes by-election, where Labour faces an uphill battle to hold on to what should be a safe Westminster seat.

The party is still struggling to come to terms with its loss of power in last year's Holyrood elections and now needs to start again after a virtually wasted year with Wendy Alexander as leader.

Its task is made harder by the unpopularity of the UK Labour Government and the difficulties faced by Gordon Brown.

Critics have claimed when Labour ministers were in power at Holyrood, they spent too much time looking over their shoulder to make sure they were not deviating too far from the Westminster line. Many believe the new leader will have to prove Scottish Labour is not simply following the UK party's line all the time.

The Prime Minister's speech to CBI Scotland last week, in which he signalled support for further financial devolution, was a significant shift which could help put the party in Scotland in a better position to combat the SNP's drive for independence.

But it is still unclear whether Mr Brown is in favour of the Scottish Parliament having more power to set taxes or whether he wants a system of "assigned revenues", where some of tax revenues collected in Scotland stay here.

The timing of the Prime Minister's speech – on the same day as the final stage of the Wendy Alexander saga, the vote in parliament against suspending her over the donations row – had a certain ironic poignancy.

Perhaps Ms Alexander's one notable success during her short reign as leader was to move Scottish Labour from its stance in last year's election against further devolution to acceptance of the "more powers" case.

Her St Andrew's Day lecture at Edinburgh University gave birth to the cross-party Calman Commission – though not without some resistance from Gordon Brown.

One Labour MSP says the Prime Minister's comments to the CBI are effectively a green light for whatever the commission comes up with, probably a combination of assigned taxes and new tax powers.

"We will have to wait and see what they come up with, but that's the general direction of travel and there is a growing consensus across the parties, and the Prime Minister has come to a decision to back it."

More immediately, the first test for Labour's new leader is likely to be next week's First Minister's Questions.

Mr Kerr claimed in an interview last month he was the best placed of the candidates to tackle Mr Salmond at FMQs. "We need to take him head on, take him on at his own game and stand up to him," he said.

But one MSP argues Mr Kerr's "bruiser" style is exactly the wrong tactic. "Salmond would relish having Andy as Labour leader because he aspires to be like Salmond but never will be."

Mr Gray has almost played down the importance of FMQs, saying he does not claim he could outdo Alex Salmond in the "playground abuse" approach to politics. "I don't think that's how our politics should be," he said.

Ms Jamieson has acquitted herself well when, as deputy leader, she has had to stand in at FMQs – she did it again last week against Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon.

Her supporters argue her quiet but pointed style makes her the one Mr Salmond would find most difficult to handle. "Cathy is the leader they would fear the most," says one backer.

Whoever is named the new leader on Saturday will be taking on a host of challenges.

But after the troubles of the last 18 months, Labour will be hoping this weekend marks a new start.





Page 1 of 1

 
1

,

11/09/2008 11:54:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Danny Mather,

Edinburgh 11/09/2008 12:10:03
just watching FMQs. Was Cathy Jamieson attempting kamikaze?
3

Brian Hill,

11/09/2008 12:38:55
Until Labour adapts to the seismic shift in Scottish politics resulting in a far more positive attitude towards the SNP and Independence they will continue to drift in the doldrums no matter who becomes leader.

Scottish Labour has to become just that: Scottish
4

hhhmmmm,

Edinburgh 11/09/2008 12:39:49
You can put lipstick on a pig, but.....
5

Ewan M,

11/09/2008 12:46:04
1 & 3 more SNP dribble. Ask yourself what has the SNP done apart from attempt to divide the Scotland from the rest of UK. Every second they spend wasting there time on taking about Indepedence they waste more time not focussing on health, education, transport, crime, drug probelms, peoples real future.

You tell the ten of thousand of people whose lives will be turned upside down by the mindless pursuit of Independence that it is good idea. Armed forces, Defence indudstry, shipbuilding, biosciences, argriculture, media, etc
6

Merouane,

Edinburgh 11/09/2008 13:07:05
#5. Nice one. Good to see a Unionist that won't be outdone on the dribbling stakes.
7

Busymale,

11/09/2008 13:11:33
I thnk if this parcel of rogues is the best the Labour Party can come up with we're in for a dull Parliament.

Bendy may have been hopeless but at least she had a resemblence of a personality.

Salmond will murder them!
8

,

11/09/2008 13:12:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
9

Resolutions,

11/09/2008 13:39:22
It would help if they produced some 'Scottish policies' in the first place and stood up to London. In fact be the Scottish Labour party.

As for the contenders, it seems hopeless, utterly hopeless.

#2 Agree obviously the strain got to her and she snapped

#4 Rather thought Health, education transport, crime,etc had been well dealt with and agriculture, fishing and so on been given far more attention than under the other lot! Are you in Scotland? Comments like that make me wonder.
10

Arrow,

edinburgh 11/09/2008 13:44:03
#6 he is competing for Sir Stanley Matthews' title as the Wizard of the Dribble. i am sure the people of norway will be only too glad to return to the bosom of Sweden and Finland and other Baltic state back to the arms of Mother Russia. there are a lot of people who support independence and lot that do not. but they can make up their own minds can they not instead of being told to by the south east of England power cliques. until the labour party is Scottish and does not ask how high when the party leader says jump they are an appendage to the Labour Party. they are acting not in the interests of Scotland but of the Party.
11

JoeMiddleton,

Edinburgh 11/09/2008 14:37:12
Whoever gets it will have his or her strings pulled from London so quite frankly who cares? Wendy A. came up with one decent idea, to support the self determination of the Scottish people. All of the MSP's agreed with this decision but now they are all waiting to be told what to think now.

If Alexander had admitted she was wrong with her illegal donation, apologised and took her punishment she could probably have survived. This shower (is there a good original idea between them?) proves Labour had no other credible alternatives.

What a sad end to a party that long ago believed in helping working people. The former leaders of Labour must be turning in their graves.
12

subrosa,

11/09/2008 14:39:32
# 2

I was wondering what she was up to at FMQs also. Goodness me what a silly woman to use the breakup of a couple's marriage as her main questions. The whole issue is not about a councillor who used a gun in Pakistan but between and man and wife's vindictiveness during a marriage breakup. That couldn't have done her a lot of good.
13

Jimmy Le Pie,

11/09/2008 15:41:52
The Three Stooges are as relevant to Scotland as Comrade Broon is.

Until there is an independent Scotland there won't be a truly Scottish Labour Party.

New Labour Sleaze were seduced by big money. Just look at Blair, Mandelson etc. They sold out and grabbed what they could.

Vote SNP, the ONLY party for ALL the people of Scotland.

Join the SNP, the ONLY party for ALL the people of Scotland.

Join at www.snp.org from only £1/month
14

Alan B,

11/09/2008 16:31:25
All the leadership contenders for labour look poor. Kerr probably the best of a bad bunch.

"If Labour is to have any chance of returning to power at the next Scottish Parliament elections, it has to find an effective way of opposing the SNP Government"

Disagree with that comment as while it may work it is that approach that turns people of politics.

Labour should really start coming up with a positive vision for scotland a policies to match. ie how will it turn round scotland economy and match the best high growing small countries in europe.

It also needs to come to terms with why failed in its 10yrs in power. Labour do not seem to have actually addressed the fact that it was a failure in power. It needs to accept it policies failed and come to terms with that and come up with new ideas and policies.

Slagging of the opposition without coming up with alternatives is just sad.
15

Mr White,

Prestonpans 11/09/2008 17:17:58
Labour has made a lot of errors in its first few years and it is probably a point they would not like to think of.

They must hurt at the idea of having spent over 400 million on the dodgy building they call the parliament.(What a statement it could have made to the world if they agreed a simplier building so that we could address the poverty in scotland.

Until we move on from silly discussions about independence (people passionate about it shout about it but so many of us are uninterested).

They need to show they are a party of the people and fight poverty, stop employing teachers who have no chance of a job after their training, admit to a simplier building design - STOP WASTING CASH ON SILLY REPAIRS AND JUST SIMPLIFY THE DESIGN EVERY TIME ANOTHER THING GOES WRONG.

Strong leadership is about making a lasting impression, b=not a few cheap cheers on a soap box or laughs at FMQ
16

go boil ur heid,

here 11/09/2008 20:11:57
no5 people like you disgust me and any true scot
17

chico y,

11/09/2008 20:38:51
Hey no.5

No illegal war
No social injustice
No liebour
No team GB
Go dribble yourself
18

Ian down under,

Musselburgh 11/09/2008 21:33:01
Politics only confuses me. Salmond talks independence but jumps to the call of an American billionaire. Labour seems lost and their old working class fighters have all gone to be replaced by the guilty middle classes.
It's not just Britain or Scotland. I had 14 years in New Zealand and the ruling Labour party is made up of people from wealthy families and who went to private schools. They go on about increasing benefits and being kind to criminals. The opposition National party which is supposed to be the Tory equivalent has a leader from a working class single parent family and he talks about encouraging people to get on in life.
Perhaps the old political divides are irrelevant and we need to look at the whole system. How about a grand coalition of the best and brightest from all the parties working for all of us and how about all the citizens also doing their bit............Nah..would never work. Within 24 hours of election the grand democratic coalition will be getting protests from fascists who feel they are being victimised and will demand special rights and proportional represnetation............
19

Dave Gordon.,

OddPolitics.com 11/09/2008 22:18:21
"Pundits have made Mr Gray, the East Lothian MSP and former Enterprise Minister, the favourite. But even some of his supporters say the contest is "too close to call""

Well one bookie has Jamieson as the favourite http://tiny.cc/OddPolitics

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Who would make the best Scottish Labour leader?
Iain Gray
Cathy Jamieson
Andy Kerr

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.