Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 7th January 2009 Change Date

London from only £11.50 with National Express

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Anger as popular mural is covered after graffiti attacks



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 September 2008
ITS pictures of everyday life in the Capital have long put a smile on the faces of thousands of passers-by.
Now the city council has sparked complaints of a "whitewash" after ordering a popular mural be replaced with plain paint.

The "cover up" has been ordered after graffiti sprayed on the artwork on the Telfer Subway was deemed "offensive" by officials.

Most of the graffiti on the murals was illegible, but one piece read "Blair, Bush & Israel – partners in war crime".

Council contractors started overhauling the mural on the tiled subway – which links Fountainbridge with Dalry – this week.

They scraped and blasted years worth of paint, including the latest mural which was painted in the 1990s. It depicted well-known local landmarks and personalities including the subway's stalwart busker.

The council said it would cost too much to replace the mural, opting instead for a £9000 whitewash, using anti-graffiti paint.

However, community leaders have hit out at the move, saying they had not been given any say in the mural's fate. Councillor Joanna Coleman, who represents Sighthill and Gorgie, wants the work halted so that alternatives can be considered.

One idea she wants to be considered is to give graffiti artists the chance to decorate the subway themselves, with the aim of giving them a sense of ownership over the new mural, rather than destroying it.

"We need to have a proper debate. This has worked in other areas of the country. If I had been told about this, I would have immediately asked the public what it wants – that's crucial."

Councillor Eric Milligan added: "Beige is certainly no fun, that's for sure. However, I do feel this is an issue about what could make people use this subway more.

"If there is graffiti, many people, particularly older ones, are put off from going through. If it looks more inviting, they may."

The Telfer Subway allows pedestrians to walk underneath the West Approach Road. It was painted with a community mural in the late 1970s and again in the 1990s, at the request and design of community groups.

Councillor Robert Aldridge, the city's environment leader, said: "Regrettably, it appears not all councillors were consulted about plans to remove offensive graffiti.

"However, this is now being remedied and we will of course take into account all local councillors' views to determine the final scheme for it."


The full article contains 406 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 06 September 2008 9:49 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

alex paterson,

edinburgh 06/09/2008 11:59:05
Paint it in a nice mat white,what a lovely surface for graffiti.
2

Richard Taylor,

Aberdeen 06/09/2008 12:12:08
Does anti-vandal paint actually work:?
3

Jachscall,

06/09/2008 12:14:05
When they clamp down on the dog owners who frequently allow their dogs to 'dirt' in the subway,maybe then i can look at the murals instead of the ground!!
It really is a huge problem,where are the environment wardens????
4

Mister T,

Edinburgh 06/09/2008 12:22:17
What chance do normal residents of Edinburgh stand when the council cant even protect the World Heritage site from the blight of graffiti? This surely is Edinburgh's real disgrace!!!

Why dont we hear more from the EEN about what is being done throughout the city on this matter. There was a few arrests but the graffiti continues have there been any convictions? Who are the offenders? Are the offenders penalisd financially and/or made to clear the mess they and others create?
5

Thistledhu,

06/09/2008 13:33:36
Graffitti atracts Graffiti regardless if some choose to call it street Art.
6

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

06/09/2008 13:41:24
its vandalism, both the graffiti & the mess its covering up
7

Douglas,

Bathgate 06/09/2008 15:37:46
#1, your English teacher is going to carpet you for that.
8

blackley,

Edinburgh 06/09/2008 16:10:04
I wouldn't be seen dead going through that tunnel. Come to think of it I probably would be!
9

Ellie,

Edinburgh 06/09/2008 17:16:31
In places in Sydney, Amsterdam and other cities they are points of interest and well done.
10

Finbarr Saunders,

06/09/2008 17:27:50
" ... have long put a smile on the faces of thousands of passers-by."

According to who exactly? Not me or anyone else I know, that's for sure

It was an eyesore and was always gonnae be vandalised.

11

elayne,

06/09/2008 17:51:31
i didnt mind the tunnel and the graffiti,espec the more "political"stuff,if it makes people think,well why not!as someone pointed out though,theres loads of dog mess which is not so appealling,btw whatever happened to the old guy who used to busk there(he also used to busk in the "clock inn"prevoiusly in dalry rd)
12

rudeskaboyuk,

06/09/2008 18:26:53
Have to be honest , it is a nasty subway tunnel and always has been. It should be cleaned with disinfectant and brushed everyday by the council.

The old guy who busks in the tunnel is still there. I saw him twice last week around 3ish. He has played at this spot for many years with all money he raises going to the 'sisters of the poor'. Please give as you go by.
13

Richard Lewis,

Little Rock, Arkansas, USA 06/09/2008 19:03:50
Gee - Scots = Learn from silly things in East Los Angeles - Rope off the area, paint the walls Pure White, Organize a Graffiti Show of their BEST Artists - and do this Monthly. Encourage the arts by allowing the arts to flourish. Let them have their say - and then, someone else, then, someone else. Let the People's Art fill in the blanks. It's as simple as that. Why make it a crime to express - Once expressions are given a venue, they evolve and become brilliant and clear. It is only by distortion of Freedoms that makes Freedom frightening. Open the walls - make it a joyful way for locals to express themselves.
Cordially,
Richard Lewis
14

John Knox furr First Meenister,

06/09/2008 19:42:57
"community leaders" have hit out at the move... errr who??? I'm the effin community leader and I think it's fine.
15

rabmataz,

06/09/2008 19:51:15
#14, oh no you're not, i'm the effing community leader and i think it's fine too - viva la revolucion!
16

Anonym,

06/09/2008 20:01:15
£9000 to paint that wee subway white?
17

Finbarr Saunders,

06/09/2008 20:44:21
#13 - Richard Lewis - If anyone painted anything remotely artistic in this particular subway, some wee Buckfast-fuelled neds would quickly deface it with a string of badly-spelt obscenities.

The Telfer Subway is not a place for artistic expression.

What it needs is a high-tech CCTV system to discourage the local pondlife from hanging about.

18

Journalistic licence,

In the community 06/09/2008 20:53:06
#14 and #15 I'm a carer in the community and I didn't vote for youse. Imposters.
19

Mr Fuzzy,

Edinburgh 07/09/2008 00:07:43
#2
Yes, it makes the graffiti paint as permanent as mud on a window. It just washes off with the application of water.

#4, #5
There is a simple solution - many cities in the USA have an anti-graffiti hotline. You make a phone call to report the damage, and the city sends out a team to paint over the graffiti, whether it is on gates, doors, telephone equipment or road signs. Removing the graffiti within 24 hours has a strong deterrent effect.
20

fmuldar,

New Jersey, USA 07/09/2008 02:51:19
Yes!!! ANTI-GRAFFITI PAINT DOES WORK!
Did its job in NYC subways & buses.
Someone here suggested that the lawbreakers (graffiti vandals) be given a say in what is painted on a building? "GIVE ME A BREAK"!!
There are so many "LEGITIMATE" ARTISTS! living in the Capital they would repaint the old mural for free!! just too get the publicity & sign their name at the bottom of their work.
21

Douglas,

Bathgate 07/09/2008 10:16:34
#2 Richard Taylor: It works best when sprayed directly into the eyes of the vandal.
22

S'me,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 02:36:20
Its going to be graffiti'd whatever happens, just let it be and concentrate on the surrounding filthy streets.
23

Julian.,

edinburgh 08/09/2008 02:44:20
#19 and others

Wouldn't it be simpler to have cctv cameras up to deter those vandals. Along with an enforced £1000 fine for those caught and a community service project to make them repaint it.

Would also make the tunnel safer as well.
24

yorkshirepudding,

hfx 08/09/2008 11:46:24
will the Aberdeen bin wagon fit down the subway to collect all of the dog mess....?
Don't you have enough parks and green bits of Edinburgh to walk you doggies? If you cannot give them a decent walk, don't have one I say.
25

Richie Biscuits,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 16:52:34
£9000 could have been spent on a year of monthly painting events in the tunnel. Giving artists from all over Scotland the opportunity to showcase their talents and meet like minded folk. Check what the Vapour Trail events have done for the DPM park in Dundee. Edinburgh needs legal spots for people to express themselves and push their artform forward. the artists that attend these events usually use their own paint at great expense to themselves (providing we are not sponsored) and produce fantastic work. I thought this city was 'enlightened'. £9000 on a whitewash is a waste of everyones taxes
26

CSL,

Edinburgh 12/09/2008 14:59:22
I live right next to the subway. I normally feel quite safe when walking through it as it is always busy.

The mural was great - made the subway less threatening, some of the graffiti was quite amusing, some just rubbish graffiti. But I agree - it will be graffiti'd anyway - so allow it!

And whatever you may think about graffiti, the other posters are quite right - the dog dirt is a whole lot worse. I have complained to the council about this on several occasions, they said they send plain clothes patrols, but actually have to catch the owner allowing the dog to do the deed and then walking away before they can issue the somewhat pathetic £40 fine. I walked through the subway yesterday and between fountain park and dalry road I would estimate that I had to avoid at least 15 different deposits - next to the recyling bins seems to be a favourite spot - absolutely disgusting.

What can be done about this?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.