Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 6th September 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Once you couldn't give them away.. now flats are a des res



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 June 2008
DOZENS of people are battling to rent flats in low-rise blocks in Muirhouse – when only a few years ago the council couldn't give them away.
The demand in multi-storey blocks is being seen as the latest evidence of the crisis in affordable housing in the city.

Only a few years ago, the flats were so unpopular that nobody would apply to live there.

A flat in the May Court block, which recently became available, attracted 81 bids from people wanting to access social rented housing. That was followed soon after by a property in nearby Gunnet Court for which 79 threw their hat into the ring.

The crisis was previously highlighted when a two-bedroom property in Drumbrae attracted a record 1024 individual bidders in December last year.

The city's housing leader, Councillor Paul Edie, said: "The amount of bids we receive for each property is testament to the housing crisis Edinburgh is currently experiencing. We simply do not have enough affordable homes for people who want to live here.

"We need to build more affordable homes and to do that we need adequate investment.

"The maths is simple and the message is clear – without more new homes at the affordable end of the market, homelessness will grow and more people will end up living in B&Bs, temporary accommodation and hostels."

The council's homelessness strategy shows that the Capital's chronic shortage of affordable housing is creating a growing number of homeless people.

The dwindling supply is expected to get worse with 1700 homes in Pennywell, Gracemount, Sighthill, Leith and Granton set to be demolished by 2014.

Although Edinburgh has three-quarters of the country's affordable housing need, it has under a quarter of the provision.

Inverleith councillor Lesley Hinds, who represented the Muirhouse area for years, said she was stunned by the figures.

She said: "I was shocked to find out recently that so many people, seeking rented housing from the council, had bid for a flat in a 'multi' in Muirhouse.

"I remember a few years ago that it was almost impossible to find people to take empty multi-stories. The demand is as heavy now as I have ever known it."

However, Cllr Hinds said some credit had to be given the improvements made to the properties.

"It's a combination of lack of social housing and upgrades to the flats," she added.

"Now there are intercom systems, they look nicer and the windows have been improved.

"People are more keen to come and live in Muirhouse now, whereas maybe a few years ago when it was more of an estate its reputation came before it."

Rosemary Brotchie, a spokeswoman for homeless charity Shelter, added: "There is a shortage of affordable housing in Edinburgh as this situation and these figures demonstrate."

www.edinburgh.gov.uk
www.shelter.org.uk

The full article contains 487 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 06 June 2008 11:27 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Mortgage and property news
 
1

Aaron Winfield,

Canongate, Edinburgh 06/06/2008 12:03:19
I blame Margaret Thatcher. People should never of been allowed to buy social housing.
2

alex patersons English teacher,

06/06/2008 12:08:27
1
You of gone have the deep end with that.
3

GraemeH,

Edinburgh 06/06/2008 12:11:59
Wonder how many of the people wanting this house were from Edinburgh as opposed to Eastern European immigrants who have less jaundiced views of these areas. Or simply less knowledge.
4

,

06/06/2008 12:16:00
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

Aaron Winfield,

Canongate, Edinburgh 06/06/2008 12:17:31
Not really. The 'right to buy' has created this lack of affordable housing. Have you seen how much a privately owned and rented tenement goes for down Leith or Gorgie way in comparison to the council properties next door?

Anyway, I guess I am sidetracking from the original story.
6

Andy Pandy,

Loanhead 06/06/2008 12:18:08
Sorry - no disrespect to security guards with my last comment (before the administrator bans me yet again)
7

Daft Old Git,

06/06/2008 12:20:48
A des res? People battling? 79 people throwing their hats in the ring? Journalistic drivel yet again
8

Unimpressed one,

06/06/2008 12:33:26
"Although Edinburgh has three-quarters of the country's affordable housing need, it has under a quarter of the provision."

This is a direct result of the council allowing developers a virtual free hand in the rush to profit from the obscene Edinburgh housing market greed over the last few decades. Now that the ar*se is collapsing in this sector things can only get worse.
9

Lang Spoon,

Free State of Leith 06/06/2008 12:40:09
I predict that the council will make a bid shortly for a large chunk of the unsold Waterfront/ Western Harbour flats. This would certainly help the housing crisis, largely caused by the discredited "right-to-buy" policies (which have simply given a boost to the private housing market!).
This approach would be very popular, provided successful tenants were properly vetted; (ie ownership of Staffies would not go down well).
10

blackley,

Edinburgh 06/06/2008 12:45:18
Gunnet Court? It's not a good address is it?
11

JT,

06/06/2008 13:02:44
more fool them, cant believe people who want to go and live there! Its like the other side of town in Craigmillar, doesnt matter how much you tart the place up, there are a huge element of the population living there that noone wants next door to them. Its time the council put affordable houses in nicer areas not just the scummy areas.
12

Victoria Ian,

06/06/2008 13:04:36
Nothing wrong with Muirhoose!
13

ccc,

06/06/2008 13:06:14
#9 I think you could be right. Only question is where do the council get the money from....
14

erin go' bragh 1875,

06/06/2008 13:15:09
3

is that where the hearts have based thier new training camp for the pre season then?
15

Louis Catorze,

06/06/2008 13:15:15
#13..try living somewhere else and you'll see exactly whats wrong with 'Muirhoose'
16

MoragtheToerag,

Argyll 06/06/2008 13:15:58
Having lives on that estate for years, I'd rather live in an unheated caravan with midgies and ghosts for neighbours than one of those hovels.

17

gotalottosay,

06/06/2008 13:26:32
it wouldnae matter how much they had spent to regenerate that area, people who already knew it would run a mile but you get folk from our other european countries who are not really as fussy as some others and are only looking for a place to stay while they take our jobs and they will love it.
18

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

06/06/2008 13:36:57
its great that they stuck a canopy out front of some shoddy houses. If people want to live there good luck to them.

But not me. No siree. To me it's awful, very trampy and demeaning.
19

Metal Mickey,

06/06/2008 13:54:02
#2

Are you really an English teecher?
20

Joe,

Livingston 06/06/2008 14:36:25
I wonder how many successful applicants will eventually be driven out by anti-social neighbours?
21

Filled Rolls,

Edinburgh 06/06/2008 14:49:01
Top Marks to lezley. The sight of her porcine features would be enough to scare most people away. Another first for the cooncil when it comes to managing housing demand.
22

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

06/06/2008 14:51:46
She looks like a Cooncil Scheme Makeover Booncer.
23

The Judge,

06/06/2008 15:26:39
What a load of phish this story is, a high rise in Muirhouse has never been and never will be "desirable".

Lesley Hinds had decades to sort out housing in this city yet she and her New Labour colleagues failed on every single level. Is it any wonder there is such a long waiting list to live in a slum?

I wonder if anybody from the council finally got round to fixing Lesley's "Lord Provost" lamppost yet? Or did she finally work out how to change a lightblub.
24

FrankGallagher,

06/06/2008 15:43:57
Attractive villas for sale with a birds eye view of the city. Local evening entertainment provided nightly, includes bonfires and car racing. 24hr pharmacist on hand. Ideal for those looking to lose weight with 24 flights of stairs to climb. Would suit those who are not offended by the smell of p1ss.
25

K.R,

06/06/2008 15:44:06
I lived in high flats for years. it was a nightmare. the council fills them full with drug addicts and other undesirables. from neigbours overdosing on my doorstep to idiots partying all night, I had to put up with it all and go to work the next day. As soon as I could afford a private let I moved.
26

porters at 9,

06/06/2008 15:55:13
they should close this down and turn it into a swimming pool
27

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

06/06/2008 16:09:37
This paper is a joke, it really is. yesterday we had some flat rentals in Lauriston street touted as the best hotal in europe , now we are getting some ex druggy slums in muirhouse described as Des Res.

I guess its supposed to make the working class feel better about their humdrum lives.
28

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

06/06/2008 16:11:42
Tomorrow :- stenhouse Dog run chippy the best in Western europe.
29

suse,

06/06/2008 16:15:58
the truth of the matter is, homeless people are forced to make 'realistic bids' via the council's choice bidding system so these 80 or so people probably dont actually want to live in these flat at all as is bengi suggested, but risk being struck off if they dont do so. some Choice eh.

Its a pity lesley Hinds didnt look into this a bit further before going for her photo shoot and giving a quote on something she clearly knows very little about.
30

Maroon tinted glasses,

06/06/2008 16:18:31
Remember Bingham, they moved everyone out, rebuilt it so it was really nice..........

Then moved all the jakeys back in and before you know it BISH BASH BOSH back to being a slum again.

Its not the houses they need to look at its the lack of respect and pride in your community that needs to be sorted.
31

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 06/06/2008 16:32:49
I thought for a moment that Lesley Hinds had got herself a job as a concierge. Then I thought, no, that's a kind of responsible job, she's way underqualified.....
32

MoragtheToerag,

Argyll 06/06/2008 16:37:40
Ah, now, no. 26, you forgot about the fires in the rubbish chutes.

After all, the tower a few buildings down from the Gunnet isn't known as 'Inchfiery' for nothing.
33

AngSW,

06/06/2008 17:02:10
#31...Remember Bingham, Aye, very fondly... still live there actually. And the Jakeys they moved back in where infact from other undesirable areas. The Auld Binghamers who decided to come back, if you take a look around you,look after and respect their community. I'ts the radgies the council have listened to pining for a "NOO HOOSE TAE HELP IMPROVE MA SITUATION" who have let their offspring and their pals vandalise this once tight nit community. And as a matter of FACT, any original ex decanted tenant who applied to move back in where indeed knocked back in favour of the folk who never wanted to stay there when it was the Orlits..... Aye , Bish Bash Bosh indeed eh?
34

The Sheriff,

06/06/2008 17:03:50
Shoddy journalism in the title and no more than a publicity stunt by Lesley Hinds to get her less than pretty face emblazened across the evening news.

As has been commented on by a previous poster,the problem is with the type of people that live in the properties without a care in the world and allow them and the area to fall into a hovel.

The list of areas where the 1700 properties are being bulldozed is testament to the majority of undesirables that have lived in them over the years and that I suspect is the real reason they are coming down.

So in short,we the tax payer pay for new properties in these areas,the council then move in the undesirables and the cycle starts all over again.

My soloution is simple,find a nice big area away from the rest of us to put these lowlife on....inchkeith Island would do nicely for starters.
35

Andy Pandy,

Loanhead 06/06/2008 17:07:26
#4 and #6 - doh! New I'd get it. She still looks like the door security though even if she's looking more sturdy these days
36

M33,

06/06/2008 17:26:01
She looks like a Gunnet in the picture. Whatever that may be.
37

Daniel Salaman,

NICOSIA CYPRUS 06/06/2008 18:04:20
I have been reading every single comment with great interest. I feel very sorry for a lot of young couples who are homeless along with a lot of single people who are desperate to find any place to live. In this country there so much government land, where prefabricated houses could have been build to alleviate the accommodation problem for millions of people for ones and for all. You would think that the Labour party being the party of the poor, should have started a housing project many years ago but instead they have done nothing to help people. In Britain there are very few new houses build, most of the houses in our country are very old and very expensive to maintain. In many countries abroad they pull down old houses and build new ones in there place, that's all done with government help, nothing is free but people pay resonable prices, affordable prices. In Britain we have all these CAPITALIST SHARKS who are taking advantage of the poor people who are blessed as far as i remember by every single government in power. Under Gordon Browns government the quality of the standard of living in Scotland is getting realy bad, and the situation is going to get even worse. I hope that the next government in our country will find modern solutions for young people who would like to create a proper family. I can see a lot of poor young people who stand no chance to settle down and have kids, because they can not afford even the minimum expense's of a decent living. This is a very sad development for a country which dose not belong in the Third world. Perhaps those matters, are giving us a better explanation as to why , so many people turn to drugs and alcohol let alone the level of crime.
38

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

06/06/2008 18:40:53
Well written Daniel. apart from the fact that its the poor that are having all the kids and the middle classes are too busy running about earning money for the poors benefits to have children of their own.
39

KiwiJambo,

New Zealand 06/06/2008 19:28:22
Just been looking at this article and wondered..... Whatever happened to Rab C Nesbitts good lady "Mary Doll"?

Looks like I need wonder no more..... she's gone east and entered politics.
40

M33,

06/06/2008 21:28:14
What is Eddie Izzard doing in Muirhouse?
41

Daniel Salaman,

NICOSIA CYPRUS 06/06/2008 22:02:30
39 The Genuine Mario Antoinette. Thank you for your comment. I think that you have a point looking matters from that angle. Could you do me a favour Mario to elaborate you thoughts, as i find your point quite interesting. I would love to hear your thoughts. Daniel Salaman Nicosia Cyprus.
42

Julian,

EDINBURGH 06/06/2008 22:10:48
Mario,

You're a bit serious today are you not?

In my opinion, the lack of affordable housing is down to private landlord moguls hoovering up hundreds of properties and causing prices to go up. Curb this activity and you go a long way to solving the problem.
43

Julian,

EDINBURGH 06/06/2008 22:13:17
#41,

He's looking for some cheap accomodation for the Edinburgh festival but got the months mixed up.
44

Mad Vlad,

06/06/2008 22:37:52
Crikey - looking at that picture, she's fallen upon hard times since being lord provost !
45

Alistair from the New Town,

07/06/2008 19:02:40
I on't understand why so many of the posts refer to a lcak of affordable housing and then complain about the low life druggies who inhabit some of these sink estates. Some people have bought nice new flats in Leith and Granton and whether you would like to live there are not is irrelevant. Somebody got a mortgage to buy over there. I think that the "solution" of filling some of these privately owned flats with some of the scum that the council has on it's books is nonsence. Would you like drop outs and drug dealers in your neighbourhood? No one minds giving housing to women escaping violent homes or people who are hard up, but we all know that some of the people on housing lists are just spongers.
46

,

08/06/2008 03:10:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.