Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Monday, 2nd November 2009 Change Date Latest Issue

Sporting chance to buy out Meadowbank

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
17 July 2007
CAMPAIGNERS fighting to save Meadowbank Stadium are setting up a trust in a bid to launch a community buy-out.
Sports groups and community representatives would head a trust running the facility under plans being drawn up by the Save Meadowbank Campaign.

Their plans have been inspired by similar ventures in other parts of the UK, including a trust in Lond
on, which owns and runs 23 acres of land with two sports centres.

With the Meadowbank site valued at £44 million, due to interest from house-builders, the campaigners bid would be the most ambitious yet attempted.

The trust - called Sporting Trusts Edinburgh and Lothians (STEAL) - would apply for funding from the National Lottery and other sources, as well as exploring options such as bank loans, and issuing bonds to supporters.

The campaigners are being advised by the Development Trusts Association Scotland, which has helped a number of Lothians community projects, including the Fisherrow Trust.

Kevin Ferguson, STEAL's co-ordinator, said: "It is a huge step, we are not kidding ourselves, but the feedback so far has been overwhelmingly positive.

The fact there is appetite for this shows the council are not looking after the sports facilities as the community wishes."

The council has a cross-party working group currently examining the different options for the future of Meadowbank. Existing plans rely on using some of the money from the sale of the 37-year-old Meadowbank to fund the refurbishment of the Commonwealth Pool. However, it is possible that part of the site would be sold for development.

City chiefs have poured cold water on the idea, but the charitable trust behind similar ventures said it should not be dismissed.

Wendy Reid, a development officer with Development Trusts Association Scotland, said STEAL's goal was ambitious but achievable.

She said: "The crucial thing with any development trust is that you have a group that are willing to regenerate through economic development. Taking control of an asset and using it to regenerate the community is crucial."

The Westway Development Trust in North Kensington, London, was borne out of a campaign against plans to build a motorway through disused council land in the 1970s. Campaigners took control of this land and other community facilities.

Local councillor Stefan Tymkewycz, said the trust was "an interesting concept" but declined to comment further as he is a member of the Meadowbank working group, which is meant to report back by September.

Councillor Paul Godzik, Labour's spokesman for leisure, culture and sport, said: "I think people will not be bothered about who is running the facilities, but rather if the facilities are up to 21st-century standards. The real question is just how much [the trust] will be able to bring it up to these standards and how will that be financed.

A city council spokesman said: "Meadowbank is currently run by a trust - Edinburgh Leisure. The council has no intention of considering any other trust to run the facility."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 17 July 2007 9:57 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Meadowbank
 
1

michael w,

calton 17/07/2007 11:30:13

meadowbank has served us well however it is very run down now and a new stadia etc is required but i feel that meadowbank will become a new housing development. RIP meadowbank we had good times

2

alex paterson,

embra 17/07/2007 11:44:33

It would be nice to see Meadowbank used again,And a revamp is not out of the question,No doubt developers will move in,But not all over the place,And use the money from the land sale.

3

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

Newington 17/07/2007 11:55:47

I salute these people for pursuing a private solution. It's clearly far better that those interested in these sports and hobbies pay for it themselves than that taxpayers subsidise them.

If only we'd do the same with all rrecreational facilities, we'd limit the Council to something it could perhaps manage.

4

Evil News,

Edinburgh 17/07/2007 12:14:09

#3 - Well said. Let it go. Campaigners are always caught up in their own little interests - do the rest of us care?

5

Randan,

17/07/2007 12:36:34

Meadowbank is run down because the Council ran it down deliberately to sell it. Like any 30-40 year old building all it needs is a bit of TLC and it will be as good as new.
You can't just keep on building houses on the sports facilities that we currently have and then losing them for good. After that there is no way back from the concrete jungle.
We have a problem with obesity and yet people want to demolish the only decent facilities for half the population of Edinburgh.
Don't be stupid people. Meadowbank must stay.

6

heatherp,

Happy Glen 17/07/2007 15:25:48

Well done STEAL, get the council thinking. Meadowbank is the most used sports facility in the city, nationally, regionally and locally. Yes it needs a revamp and upgrade to make it fit for purpose. I would rather the council spend 18 million doing that than spend my tax on building Sighthill at a cost of 93 million. The sale of the land will only generate 50 million (councils own projection) and SportScotland is giving 7 million, so there is a shorfall, much more than the cost of upgrading Meadowbank.
We do not look only to save Meadowbank but to upgrade and give it the TLC it deserves.

7

Mallory,

17/07/2007 15:41:58

Good idea - hope it works. Why not offer simple £25 shares or whatever to ordinary Scots who can take a proper stake in their sports facilities?

8

The Judge,

17/07/2007 17:04:37

A city council spokesman said: "Meadowbank is currently run by a trust - Edinburgh Leisure. The council has no intention of considering any other trust to run the facility."

Firstly EEN can you stop quoting unknown council spokesmen, at least let us know who's saying garbage like this. If they don't want to give you a name go directly to the director of the department.

The above quote is typical Edinburgh Parish Council at its best. Its our way or no way. They talk as if Edinburgh Leisure has been doing a good job.

Good luck to STEAL but you don't stand a cat in hells chance of saving Meadowbank.

9

Bauldie,

17/07/2007 20:50:38

Why don't Hibs buy Meadowbank, sell their present piggery and build an 11,000 capacity stadium which would be more than enough for those daft enough to buy one of their season tickets.

10

Lewis McDonald,

17/07/2007 20:57:18

Does it really matter

11

AaronL,

Hillside 17/07/2007 21:49:38

I would have thought Edinburgh Council officials would be glad to get rid of the site they've been so negative about. One less thing for them to worry about. Let those that care about Meadowbank look after it. Its obvious to me and those that are on the working group that Edinburgh Council has given up on sports facilities for the whole of East Edinburgh. There are no promises or even half promises for the East in the future. And they want to make Edinburgh "Europe’s most physically active city by 2020". Come on! Pull the other one.

12

Estella,

Porty 17/07/2007 22:43:17

#9
They would even have space for the football academy they were meant to build years ago and never did.

13

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 18/07/2007 09:05:20

There is something fundmentally wrong when the public have to buy something from those who are supposed to serve the public in order to stop them from conflicting with the public interest !

Corrput, unthinking Labour at work.

I know they are not in power any more but this is their legacy - we will be sorting out the Labour mess for years.

14

Peter - very disappointed/concerned,

Edinburgh 18/07/2007 10:09:47

"City chiefs have poured cold water on the idea"

No wonder, the losses to the Council both in terms of Capital Gain/Council Tax which would be generated if they are successful in selling on the site to private 'developers' for housing, etc. must be potentially huge (£44 million for the site alone). Councillors, etc will be very miffed if they lose out on this little cash generator.

#14 "The City of Edinburgh does not have a Culture and Leisure Department, or a Director specifically responsible for such functions."

Can we assume then that Edinburgh Leisure is a stand-alone budget driven organisation which is not directly responsible to the City Council and who's function is to operate places like the Common Wealth Pool, etc at a profit?

It does raise the question, what does our Town Council do with all the funds it raises from Council Tax, grants, etc? I had always fondly (and no doubt incorrectly) assumed that a proportion of such funds went into the running and maintenance of such facilities for use by the public.

Having already paid excessive Council Tax in this town, why are its inhabitatants having to pay entry fees, etc for the use sports facilities which are supposed to paid for out of Council Tax? It is not just sports facilities of course for which we are required to pay additional fees, many other services are charged for over and above Council Tax.

I hope STEAL manage to get the funding needed to purchase and maintain Meadowbank for the pleasure and use of the people of Edinburgh.

15

JennyF,

Edinburgh 18/07/2007 13:14:50

#16, the Council sends you a leaflet with your council tax bill each year that explains how council tax is spent. The majority goes on education and social services.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.