Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Monday, 2nd November 2009 Change Date Latest Issue

Resignation rumours spark panic amongst city's Lib Dem chiefs

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 12 June 2009
LIBERAL Democrat leaders in Edinburgh had to ring Germany to check they were still in control of the city after rumours that one of their backbenchers was to quit.
Word spread like wildfire through the City Chambers that Joanna Coleman, councillor for Sighthill/Gorgie, had sent an e-mail to colleagues threatening to resign from the Lib Dem group to sit as an independent.

The move would risk toppling the Lib
Dem-SNP coalition which has run the Capital for the past two years but relies on the casting vote of the Lord Provost.

Lib Dem leaders insist they have seen no such e-mail. But group chairwoman Elaine Morris said they had decided to phone Cllr Coleman, who is on holiday in Germany, over the rumours.

She said: "She denies any wish to become an independent and is firmly committed to the Lib Dems."

It is understood the rumours were sparked by Cllr Coleman's unhappiness at a bid by former councillor Tom Ponton to make a political comeback by standing as the Lib Dem candidate in Chancellor Alistair Darling's Edinburgh South West seat at the next General Election.

Cllr Coleman's husband Ian had been chosen as the candidate but stood down last year because of work commitments. Mr Ponton said he was approached by local party members to stand, but Lib Dem insiders say Cllr Coleman has also shown an interest in the seat.

One source said: "Tom has yet to be approved by headquarters and then a sub-committee of the local party would interview him to decide whether he should be the candidate. Joanna did express an interest in being the candidate, but she has quite a lot of commitments – she is on the licensing board and the regulatory committee and she is doing a degree at university."

Another source said Cllr Coleman's heavy workload at the council was a further source of discontent, feeding the speculation.

Cllr Morris said: "It has been bandied around in several quarters that she may become an independent councillor. She is denying all knowledge of it.

"As far as I'm aware she has no issue with us. She has not raised any concerns with the group.

"Whether she has an issue about the South West candidacy I don't know."

Cllr Coleman did not return calls to her mobile from the Evening News.

But her husband insisted the rumours were unfounded.

He said: "Joanna is a deeply loyal Liberal Democrat member."

Asked about Mr Ponton's bid to become the party's candidate in South West, he said: "Whatever her feelings about that there is no suggestion of leaving the group."

He said his wife had not applied to become a parliamentary candidate, but she had not ruled out such a move.



Page 1 of 1

 
1

It's Leith for me!,

12/06/2009 11:54:59
will you please all resign so we can have an election - anybody has got to be better than the current bunch of numpties
2

Iain Coleman,

Edinburgh 12/06/2009 12:37:01
I am Joanna Coleman's husband - and yes, my name is mis-spelt in the article.

There is no truth in this story. It is a shoddy and shameful piece of journalism. The "rumours" that writer Ian Swanson refers to were in fact his own phone calls to councillors, prompted by a source telling him a flat-out lie about Joanna considering resignation. She has not considered any such thing.

I should think anyone with two brain cells to scratch together could figure out from this story who the likely source of that lie is. That source has played Ian Swanson like the proverbial fiddle. Note that the person who told Swanson about this alleged email was clearly unable to actually show the email to Swanson - not surprisingly, since no such email exists.

This is a classic case of a journalist making up a story out of nothing, and causing my wife considerable distress in the process. Ian Swanson owes my wife an apology.
3

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 12/06/2009 13:35:07
Lib Dem are just a waste of time.
4

Idolatry,

Edinburgh 12/06/2009 13:35:11
I am a friend of Joanna Coleman too. There is absolutely no truth in this. I also happen to have a pretty strong idea who was the anonymous source about this: if I'm right, this would be entirely unsurprising and self-serving. I am making a complaint to the Evening News and recommending that they never use this source again for any news about the Edinburgh administration, which they are not a part of.
5

tomias,

Edinburgh 12/06/2009 13:41:15
Iain Coalman for cooncillor!then we would have Joe Coalman as his backup should any e-mails go a wndering in the Munckine Glad Back door hills !

Is she to run as an independent bnp candidate? Keep Pontoon oot?( I'd vote for that).
How much was the phone call to Mz Merkle?

So Coalman reads the EEN on-line! Tell Johnstone press and get them to lobby hubby !
NEW COONCIL ELECTIONS____NOO!
6

Iain Coleman,

12/06/2009 14:17:01
Furthermore, in the print edition they have an election night picture with the caption "HAPPIER DAYS: Tom Ponton and Joanna Coleman celebrate election victory in 2003". There are two problems with this picture. 1) The woman featured is not Joanna. 2) Joanna was living in Cambridge in 2003, and was certainly not celebrating any election victories in Edinburgh.

Still, the caption is 50% accurate, which is considerably better than the article it accompanies.
7

Vana,

Scotland 12/06/2009 15:30:37
This "Journalist" is clearly in the pocket of that discredited cretin Tom Pontin. How do these scumbags live with themselves spending all day making up lies and acting as puppets for a sleazy idiot like Pontin? Sad. Dear Editor, sack this looser and employ some journalist with integrity.
8

Top Floor,

12/06/2009 15:38:22

No smoke without fire.
9

Edinburgh Writer,

12/06/2009 15:52:18
How to spot a deeply gullible person, part 43a:

They use the expression "No smoke without fire".
10

Jason Scorne,

12/06/2009 16:53:47
Apart from the the participants, why should anyone care about Febrile Dumbocrat infighting?
11

upthehill,

Leith 12/06/2009 16:56:06
The panic in the Lib Dem ranks was caused by the European election results showing them losing across Edinburgh North, East, South, South West & almost losing West to the Tories - despite targeting some of these seats heavily!

Sounds like some Lib Dems are regretting being so welcoming to Mr.Ponton when the Conservatives kicked him out!

12

tomias,

Edinburgh 12/06/2009 18:40:25
Joanne dopple ganger- who does the man sleep with ?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.