Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 4th July 2009 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Tougher test to curb young driver deaths



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
02 January 2007
THE driving test would be made tougher in a bid to cut accident and death rates among young drivers under plans being considered by the Government.
Among the measures under consideration is the possibility of expanding the current 40-minute practical test into a two-stage process. This would cover a wide range of skills, including night-driving and the use of different types of road such as moto
rways as well as smaller routes.

The changes could also make it compulsory to have a certain level of formal training before sitting the test, Road Safety Minister Stephen Ladyman said today.

The Driving Standards Agency is understood to be looking at the Swedish system under which young people accumulate 120 hours of driver training before taking their test. The introduction of road safety sessions into the school curriculum to counter the reckless attitude which some teenagers - particularly boys - have when they first get behind the wheel is also being considered.

Nearly 100 young people were killed or injured in road accidents in Lothian and Borders in 2005, according to road safety charity Brake. The charity said the number of people aged 15-25 who died on Lothian and Borders roads in 2005 was eight, with a further 85 seriously injured.

Brake also surveyed hundreds of young people across Scotland and found 30 per cent had driven or been a passenger in a road race, 30 per cent have driven without a licence and 49 per cent had broken the speed limit.

Mr Ladyman is thought to want to tackle the problem of would-be drivers being taught the skills needed to pass the test without tackling their attitude safety.

He said today: "We may need to start doing driver education while young people are still at school, introducing them to the rules, dangers and responsibilities of the road at a much earlier age.

"We have developed this attitude that you first learn to pass the test and then you learn to drive.

"It's an option to have more formal training. We have to debate whether there should be some level of compulsion."

He made clear that changes to the test itself were being considered, adding: "It may need to be expanded significantly and made much more thorough."

A total of 26 people were killed on roads in Edinburgh and the Lothians between January and September 2006 - almost twice as many as in the same period in the previous year.

After a run of seven deaths in two months last summer, police chiefs warned that too many young motorists who have no idea they are driving "killing machines".

The DSA is looking at a range of possible changes to encourage better safety, and a consultation is expected to be launched later this year, though a Department for Transport spokesman stressed no firm proposals had yet been put forward. At present, there is no requirement to have undertaken any formal training before taking the test. Research by the Department for Transport reveals that young males have the best pass rates in the driving test despite being the most dangerous drivers once they pass.

Male drivers aged 17-20 are almost ten times more likely to be killed or seriously injured behind the wheel than men aged 40-59, while young women also have far lower accident rates.



The full article contains 561 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 January 2007 12:19 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Douglas,

Bathgate 02/01/2007 12:17:26

The test is just a means to an end. It has no influence on the hormonally charged mouth breathers once they're let loose.

2

Blindscout,

Fife 02/01/2007 14:28:09

The test should be challenging not tougher, and test more. i.e. Motorways and night time driving. The biggest hurdle is attitude, young drivers know it all and want to impress. I have always though car drivers should progress though cycles and m/cycles so they know what it is like beside cars, (exceptions for classes of driver) and I would suggest limiting new drivers by using "P" plates, engine size/performance, and number of passengers. Motor-cyclist have 3 tests; introduce a handling test (skid pans etc) before an extended road awarness test with a suitable time gap to allow for experienced tuition.

3

rs,

02/01/2007 17:36:43

All cars should be like Modern coaches and be fitted with speed limiters - why do we sell cars that are capable of 100mph plus

Another alternative is a chip and pinned driving licence, given the technology available today.
Why not fit all cars with a Chip and Pin Operated ignition, new drivers could have max speeds programmed in or Max CCs (but given modern cars this is almost obselete given the speed of even small cars).

This could also stop "banned drivers" no licence - no start.

What difference will the P make, given the number of cars that drive about with L plates on - yet there is only one person in the car - or you give a bit more time to someone who you think is a learner - but they tear past you on the road, one hand on the stearing wheel the other on the gear stick - or is this a boy racer learning!!!!!!

What ever happened to only displaying an L plate on your car when there was a Learner actually learning?

But why is the finger always pointed at the young driver - look at the older driver and there driving skills are often much worse - the majority of People on Mobiles are Older drivers.

Just the other day, took the kids out to Ocean terminal - there was a women coming out with a 2/3 year old child, jumps in the car, next thing theres she is - one hand steering, the other holding the mobile, while driving down the multi storey - i find it bad enough with two hands going down this multi storey - but one.

Or try the school run - are the parents who throw the kids in - no seat belts the norm - and then drive at break neck speeds to the school - the highway code thrown out of the door as they cut corners, park anywhere - irrespective of other persons child who has the cheek to walk to school -

is this any different to the boy racer at night - many will tut or shake there head at the boy racer - cutting across junctions - yet come the school run there driving is no better - sometimes worse<

4

Jakey Rowling,

02/01/2007 18:17:08

#3
Not sure what you define as older but I cannot ree with what you say under my terms.

More older people using mobiles - No.
Someone with a 2/3 year old kid - usually not.
School run lack of seat belts - No.

There are good and bad drivers of all ages, but your generalisations and isolated examples cannot counter the facts that the stats are there to prove the likelihood of accidents do involve younger drivers.

Also, how do you expect me to remember my pin when I've had a few beers?

5

Evie,

02/01/2007 19:50:23

I agree with blindscout to make the driving test more challenging for new drivers. It would be a wise decision to limit the types of vehicle a young driver could drive in terms of engine size. Too often I see young drivers in Vauxhall's, Passat's and Audi's driving way above the speed limit and doing manouvers that would incur a license ban.

Also all drivers, should be taught to come in close whilst turning a corner- not turn a corner in the middle of the road forcing cars behind them to stop. And last but not least the Round-About. I wish drivers would slow down whilst approaching a give way. Give way means just that and drivers should be prepared to stop- not put their foot down close their eyes and hope they haven't caused an accident.

6

,

02/01/2007 20:50:00
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

,

02/01/2007 20:52:14
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

IainA,

Edinburgh 03/01/2007 00:57:21

Lot's of problems on the road are caused by drivers who just don't bother taking the test. This is effectively penalising the young lads who do (you'll note I said lads, as they are the most likely to have accidents according to the insurance company's actuarial tables)

If a teenager (or more likely his parents) are prepared to pay for driving lessons and have them take the test, why should it be made deliberately difficult for them to pass?

Expand the test to train new drivers better by all means, but keeping the numbers of new drivers down by making the test harder won't stop accidents.

I note the article says:- "A total of 26 people were killed on roads in Edinburgh and the Lothians between January and September 2006 - almost twice as many as in the same period in the previous year."

The implication being that these unfortunate people were all killed by reckless youths in souped up Subaru Imprezas. I don't believe that to be the whole truth, do you?

9

rs,

03/01/2007 16:58:15

no4

maybe yir blind drunk (based this on your last para) not to see the driving standards of today.

By older I mean the NON Boy racers, take a look around you when yir driving or sitting on the bus like me, its frightening to see what people get up to in the car

well try watching the school run cars, i walk my daughter to school , and I find it frightening some days just crossing the road.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.