Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Monday, 2nd November 2009 Change Date Latest Issue

Owner's £50k cash back offer fails to tempt house buyers

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 July 2008
A HOMEOWNER who offered £50,000 cash back to anyone who would buy his four-bedroom Edinburgh home is set to take the property off the market after it failed to sell.
Malcolm Young, 57, said he, wife Yvonne, 45, and children, Callum, ten, and Sarah, eight, were ready to shelve their hopes of moving to Northern Ireland. Their inability to sell the Queensferry Road home, despite the eye-catching incentive, is a sig
n of how much the market has slowed in the Capital.

Until now, people in homes at the higher end of the market had been largely protected from the worst effects of the credit crunch, as buyers in this region tend to have more disposable income, making them less likely to be badly affected by the peaks and troughs of the economy.

However, as the ESPC reports June sales at just half what they were a year ago, the malaise is spreading.

Experts say Edinburgh is now well into a buyers' market, with the few people looking for a move well-placed to pick and choose from the homes available.

Mr Young's home is a semi-detached stone villa in a quarter of an acre of grounds, with four public rooms and four bedrooms. It has been on the market at £599,000 but, even with the £50,000 cash back offer, has failed to spark much interest.

Cash back offers are often used by developers of new properties, but experts believe in the current climate, owners of second-hand homes may use them too.

Mr Young, who like his wife is a business psychologist, said: "It still has not sold. The offer still stands, but it has not increased levels of interest.

"It's surprising but it's obviously related to the fact that all houses are difficult to sell at the moment.

"I'm going to keep it on for a wee while longer and if it does not sell in the short term I will take it off the market and wait and see if the market changes."

It has been frustrating for the family who have had the house on the market for several months. They had planned to go to Northern Ireland where the couple have business interests, but are getting used to the idea they will probably be staying in Edinburgh for the time being.

Mr Young said: "It's one of those things, we're pretty realistic about it. The disappointing thing is, as I understand it from estate agents, that house prices in Scotland have remained relatively stable, but it's news from England, where things are worse, that is putting people off."

Mr Young would be following the lead of many other sellers, who are choosing to sit it out and wait for the market to improve, rather than make concessions.

David Marshall, business analyst at ESPC, said: "Sales volumes in June 2008 are down 50 per cent compared to June 2007 so, while the top end is still performing better than the bottom end, it is not anything like as strong as in previous years. We don't envisage a return to anything like a ten or 15 per cent growth in the short or medium term."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 21 July 2008 10:35 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Andy Pandy,

21/07/2008 12:01:12
Malcolm please don't be so greedy. You've got an overpriced house with a false cashback once the duty has been paid on your inflated asking price. Go back to the market with a more reasonable price for your house and you might get a bite.....is that a flying pig?
2

Hermitage,

Edinburgh 21/07/2008 12:01:16
Location, location, location.

Doesn't matter how big the house or how fancy inside, not everyone wants to live on a busy main road.
3

Liz,

Edinburgh 21/07/2008 12:08:06
"Mr Young said: "It's one of those things, we're pretty realistic about it. "

Not realistic enough to take the £50,000+ from the asking price though?

Even with the free frontpage advert on the Evening News a few weeks ago it still fails to sell?!
4

I love to eat Sellotape,

21/07/2008 12:18:31
"one of those things"? One of WHAT things?
5

Sarcasm,

21/07/2008 12:27:52
A business psychologist,advertising a £600K house in the evening news.

He's pure mental.
6

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

21/07/2008 13:19:43
Should be worth 200 grand or less by the time we hit bottom.
7

traprain,

21/07/2008 13:31:30
"Mr Young would be following the lead of many other sellers, who are choosing to sit it out and wait for the market to improve, rather than make concessions."

Housing market should be back on track around 2015!
8

Palermo,

21/07/2008 14:12:28
For a house located so close to Quality Street I'd want that £50k cash back all gold - and if the market picks up soon he'll still come out of this smelling of roses.
9

Jimmy Twoshoes,

21/07/2008 14:45:08
@ferdinand.. I'd take that bet. £10 says values won't go anywhere near the 70% drop you are suggesting (unless as I hope you were being a trifle sarcastic). Speculate as you will, but be realistic.. or do you have one eye on some tasty investments in a couple of years?
10

HughB,

Edinburgh 21/07/2008 15:19:50
He would obviously be better taking £50000 off the asking price, because cash back is not good value for money.

Ny keeping the £50000 on the asking price, then the buyer has to pay that as part of the mortgage, which will be anything up to 4 times the value of the £50000, so it's just not worth it.

Indeed, if the report says that people in this price bracket have plenty disposable income, then they won't be tempted by a pocket money amount like £50K.

Just reduce the price and be done with it.

It's just as I expected - at the first whif of a house price drop, the speculators go on the run, and will soon flood the market with their "investments" trying to get their money out before prices really crash. However, in doing so, the prices WILL crash.
11

Angus R,

21/07/2008 16:04:27
#10 i'd have thought you would have to pay stamp duty on the £50k also.

Surely its simple demand and supply - the value of a house is what someone will pay for it - clearly no-one values at £550k. This is just an advert.
12

I love to eat Sellotape,

21/07/2008 16:13:51
Let's see what columnist Brian Monteith has to say about this. Brian?

13

Duncan in Edinburgh,

21/07/2008 16:24:36
#13 Brian has just passed this note to me:

"It's clear that the ill-judged smoking ban has cost yet another businessman his livelihood. The SNP stand idly by while Labour continue to ruin the city by osmosis, despite not having been in power for more than a year. The Lib Dems are rubbish and the Tories are too ever since I was booted out. Can I *please* have my old job back?"
14

Jimmy Twoshoes,

21/07/2008 16:33:08

There is no mention anywhere of historic valuation, interest in buying(i.e. 'worth' of the house).

Simply stating it isn't selling and screaming CREDIT CRUNCH CREDIT CRUNCH isn't news.
15

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

21/07/2008 17:38:03
Jimmy Twoshoes: They probably said the same in Japan when their credit bubble went kerplunk in 1989, but there they are with house prices down by up to 90%

People are going to learn the hard way that the long credit cycle is not the same as the 18-year housing cycle.
16

ccc,

21/07/2008 18:29:58
You have to love how the intense 'demand' for houses in this City has just dried up overnight.

It is very easy to understand why. This is due to the demand and supply of CREDIT, not homes.

How many people do you know that have actually gone out and bought a house outright......

If this guy REALLY wanted to sell then a price of 450k would have it sold no problem. I have done a search and I can't find how much he paid for it. However it was bought before 2000, so he probably paid less than 300k for it.
17

Ianfraefife,

Leven 21/07/2008 19:57:33
Just read elsewhere in this literary masterpiece about a guest house being sold for upwards of £850K......... Maybe a change of use could bring about a sale?
18

Julian.,

edinburgh 21/07/2008 22:57:05
Fernando,

You'd make a good spin doctor; "down by up to 90%"

What does that mean? If there were one house in Japan which dropped by 90% and 50 million which didn't your statement would still apply.
19

Jimmy Twoshoes,

22/07/2008 10:05:59
Indeed Julian.

Also, as far as I'm aware this isn't Japan (last I checked anyway). Without wasting time going into detail over a ridiculous point, the rental market quite simply wouldn't allow such a drop.
20

Ticcychick,

Morningside 22/07/2008 12:25:58
It's very sad for all the hard-working people in property who are losing their jobs now :-(
21

Julian.,

edinburgh 22/07/2008 22:16:56
#21 Thanks. Exactly. The only thing that would make house prices drop by 90% would be for over 90% of the population to lose their jobs and for all the migrant workers to go home. Sure, if that happens, prices will go throught the floor.

But here in the real world, there will probably be an adjustment downwards of 20% (less in Edinburgh).

Sorry to spoil the pipe dream of all you people who hope prices will plummet and give you a bargain property to buy.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.