Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Saturday, 21st November 2009 Change Date

Impeccable Cohen woos Castle crowd

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 17 July 2008
Leonard Cohen *****
Edinburgh Castle

EDINBURGH clearly loves Leonard Cohen, and judging from his obvious delight at the reception he was given at the Castle last night, the sentiment was very much mutual.

Always the romantic, Cohen wooed the crowd between songs, constantly thanking
them for the generosity of their welcome. That is, when they stopped applauding long enough for him to get a word in.

Not many men of 53 would literally jog onstage waving, so it came as some surprise to see Cohen do exactly that at the age of 73.

The show, all two and a half hours of it, got off to a gentle enough start though, with the lilting Dance Me To The End Of Love. Cohen was impeccably dressed in a double breasted suit and fedora, which he removed as he bowed to the audience or his band mates at what appeared to be every opportunity.

Most of the others onstage – including the backstage crew – were similarly attired, giving the stage a strange but pleasant 1940's feel.

Cohen has an unwarranted, yet enduring reputation as a peddler of misery. His fans have always known that the opposite was true, for within those apparently maudlin lyrics, lay gems of humour and dry wit.

The Future, from the early 90's album of the same name was full of such gems. Midway through one verse, he sang of 'white men dancing', at which he had a little birl to himself, to the crowd's amusement.

A moment later, the line about 'white girls dancing', set backing singers, the Webb Sisters, off on a twirl of their own.

Ain't No Cure For Love, from the well represented I'm Your Man album, found Cohen in impressively low voice, and with a twinkle in his eye that appeared almost cheeky, he sang, 'I need to see you naked in your body and your thought'.

For a moment some of the audience looked like they might even comply.

While many of the arrangements were all but identical to their recorded versions, The Canadian poet would often slightly change a few lyrics, or alter the rhythm of the words, pushing and pulling them to suit his whim. Partly because of this, Bird On A Wire and Everybody Knows, songs from either end of his career, sat comfortably beside one another on the set list.

Song after song poured out of the balladeer. Who By Fire, a song which echoes a Jewish prayer, Hey, That's No Way To Say Goodbye and the often covered Suzanne were some of the numbers that represented the earlier albums in his career.

During Tower Of Song, at the famously quoted ironic line 'I was born with the gift of a golden voice', the audience applauded and roared so appreciatively that they could have earned five stars of their own.

Cohen reclaimed ownership of Hallelujah for himself before closing the show with Take This Waltz.

By the end of the fourth and final encore, Closing Time, the rain began to drizzle.

It didn't stand a chance of dampening the spirits of the happy, sated crowd though.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 18 July 2008 8:59 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Duncan in Edinburgh,

17/07/2008 11:59:08
God I wish I had been there. Tickets were outrageously expensive though.
2

David Weaver,

West Calder 17/07/2008 12:33:51
A consummate performance by Leonard Cohen last night at Edinburgh Castle Esplanade.

I was worried I'd be disappointed, particularly for my partner, who wasn't familiar with his work. I needn't have worried. I enjoyed it immensely and so did she.

This was a truly magical evening performed by one of the great contemporary music legends.

In my student party days, all I knew of Leonard was that unmistakable voice on vinyl CBS albums and his picture on the sleeve. I had spent my pocket money on his first two albums and part of my first wage packet on "Songs of Love and Hate". I never thought I'd ever see him live. I am so glad that I did last night.

The voice is a few octaves lower and he's adapted his rendition of those early songs to suit - "Bird on The Wire" being a good example. But I guess at 73 he can be forgiven for that. Nevertheless that famous deep baritone is still there.

Behind the dark song lyrics is a man with droll but witty sense of humour, who came across as a charming and graceful human being.

This was a night to remember.

That said, I can't heap the same praise on the venue. The seating in the Castle Esplanade is an absolute disgrace - tiny little plastic seats which children from a kindergarden would find uncomfortable. I haven't attended The Tattoo since my parents took me there in 1970 and it seems like the audience accommodation hasn't improved any. And that's not to mention the intermaneable queue to get in - stretching down Johnston Terrace and supervised by "jobsworth" youths in day-glo jackets. If this is the standard provided, I won't be re-visiting The Tattoo anytime soon. Heaven knows what our visitors think.

Overall a fantastic performance by a legendary performer which was spoiled by a sub-standard venue.

3

Mike Hunt,

Edinburgh 17/07/2008 12:37:03
"Balladeer". What a great word, well done Martin Lennon.
4

Logie Almond,

17/07/2008 13:03:46
Sales of razor blades and stout ropes in the Edinburgh area have soared.
5

,

17/07/2008 13:05:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

Victoria,

East Lothian 17/07/2008 13:16:43
He was fantastic and he truly did reclaim Hallelujah - it was a really impressive perfomance - well worth the money
7

Ann Mackenzie,

Edinburgh 17/07/2008 13:19:22
Fantastic show, still wonderful after all these years. Loved the "Thousand Kisses Deep" spoken as a poem, wish it had been recorded!

Totally agree with David about the seating and the waiting outside. After paying £50 for a ticket this was unacceptable.
8

Mike Ritchie,

Glasgow 17/07/2008 13:58:01
Your reviewer has hit the spot with his glowing words of praise.
Leonard Cohen was immense - wry, gracious, warm and in great voice throughout. Great songs, great presentation and perfect delivery swathed by a brilliant band girl backing singers.
At £50 a pop I reckon this was a bargain, worth every penny, regardless of the seating (what whingers.)
This was a memorable gig, a masterful performance by an artiste who's given us so much pleasure for so long.
If he was on again tonight I'd rush back - and pay more, if necessary.
9

Jed Smith,

Moscow 17/07/2008 14:46:02
#8 is right £50 was a bargain.

I see tickets for Tom Waits at Edinburgh are now selling for £800 on Ebay. And even then that's for the restricted views on the 120th row.
10

Bretford,

Whitburn 17/07/2008 16:31:45
Having been born less than a month before Cohen's last visit to Scotland in December 1979, to say I've waited a life time for him to come back is not too much of an understatement, but last night was no disappointment.

An amazing night with one of the best writers to ever grace us with their presence, and the first time I've ever seen someone receive a standing ovation for walking on stage without having said a word.

His stage mastery hides the fact this legend is in his 70's, as last night he showed the current crop of modern pretenders how it is done. Can you really see the likes of Robbie Williams still packing them in 40 years time?

Would happily pay £50 to watch him again next year. Please come back soon Leonard!
11

Amandannn,

Harrogate 17/07/2008 18:09:59
We travelled up from Harrogate for the concert and loved it! However, the fact that hundreds of people were still outside trying to get past the muppets
employed by Group Four Security, when the concert had already started was a disgrace. This was after queuing from 7.05pm to 8.05 and for almost a mile - pathetic organisation!
12

liverbird,

liverpool 17/07/2008 20:17:08
After looking forward to this concert since getting my £50 tickets I can't begin to tell you how my 'evening to remember' was spoiled - not by Leonard Cohen, who was superb, but the venue Edinburgh Castle and, sadly, by some of the ignorant so-called Cohen fans.
The 'splendid' castle is just not fit for purpose. You are made to queue the length of Edinburgh and when you get to the entrance you find any number of people who have not spent an hour in the queue just walking in from the Royal Mile with their tickets.
By 8.20 with the castle no-where near full LC came on.
The next half hour was spent craning my neck around scores of people still trying to get to their seat. The next two hours was spent getting more and more irritated with people up and down like yo-yo's doing whatever they do.
What is up with these people. They spoiled almost every song with thei thoughtless behaviour.
And the venue - it's a discrace. Seating you wouldn't put in a primary school and so crammed together you hardly have room to breath let alone applaud.
I'll never go to an outside concert again - not even for the great Leonard Cohen.
The castle is a ruin - for anyone who wants to watch a concert and appreciate the music. And to those of you reading this who never stiopped getting up and down, listen to artists on CD in future and leave the live appreciation to people who have manners and who truly understand Cohen's music.
13

Currie,

17/07/2008 20:18:38
Great gig, atrocious venue, won't go back there again in a hurry. Crampted seats, no bar, from what I could see only one stall selling soft drinks, over zealous stewards, the queuing to get in etc could have ruined many gigs not this one though.
14

olias,

sunhillow 17/07/2008 20:47:30
#13 agree with your sentiments. Maybe I'm getting bigger as I get older (well, I am) but those seats are too small for comfort. Stewards were a real pain - what was the point of the queue to get in?

Good review thanks Mr Lennon. Couple of minor points, I was surprised you never mentioned Thousand Kisses Deep, for me it was a highlight of the show. Also, I think there were five encores, but who's counting?

Great show, thanks Lenny.
15

Proximo,

17/07/2008 21:06:15
Great gig, hideous venue. 1000 Kisses Deep and Bird on a Wire for me, although there wasn't a bad song all night of course.

Would never go back to the castle for a gig, seats were stupidly small and close together, no bar, BIG queues for anything you could possibly want (toilet, merchandise, food).

Had great seats near front but venue would have benefitted from a screen, not necessarily a massive one either. Also thought volume could have been higher but maybe restrictions on outdoor gig?

Best gig of my life, despite best efforts of organisers and venue to spoil it.
16

Bretford,

Whitburn 18/07/2008 10:26:25
Got my wish, as Leonard has announced an extention to his tour and is playing the Armadilo in Glasgow on November 5th.

Can't wait!
17

AJ Fife,

18/07/2008 12:23:57
#17,

It was a privilege to see the great man and the weather didn't seem to matter to anyone. We got tickets for Glasgow today as well.

You can't get enough of a true genius!
18

Dfw,

East Calder 18/07/2008 16:21:52
Leonard Cohen ..... terrific

Edinburgh Castle as a venue ..... shambles
19

tvleeds@aol.com,

AS.Leeds 19/07/2008 11:44:54
After having seen one of the Dublin concerts we decided we needed to see the man again as we enjoyed it so much, hence the trip to the Edinburgh gig. Although the man himself was as good, we wish we hadnt bothered as the great memory of Dublin was marred by the aweful venue as stated by almost all the comments posted. Queing to get in, seats, lack of facilities etc etc. We feel sorry for those whose only chance of seeing the concert was at Edinburgh--wish you could all have been at Dublin ( even though we got rained on for most of the concert)
20

LBoy,

Glasgow 20/07/2008 21:57:51
Leonard was sublime, it did not really matter about the queue or the horrible seats in the end.
I will never go to the Castle again for a concert 'though!
21

David Weaver,

West Calder 22/07/2008 15:17:04
#8 As you can see Mike, in my original post #2 I separated my worthy praise of Leonard Cohen from criticism of the venue in a separate paragraph.

I'm glad to see that most other people seemed to agree about Edinburgh's Disgrace which is the Castle Esplinade, as a venue.

Far from "whingeing", I too would have gladly paid up again if he'd been on the following night.

That said, the very next day I heard of the Glasgow venue on Novemeber 5th and I've bought tickets for that! :-)

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.