Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 3rd July 2009 Change Date

Which is the greatest game your team has ever played?

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Hundreds of Sikhs converge on city for race attack vigil



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
18 November 2006
HUNDREDS of Sikhs from across Britain are set to converge on Edinburgh tomorrow to hold a peaceful vigil following a racist attack on a city teenager.
At least nine coach-loads of people are due to come from London and the Midlands to pray at the Sikh Temple in Sheriff Brae, Leith. They will then hold a four-hour candlelit vigil in Pilrig Park from 2pm, handing out flyers to passers-by.

There i
s understood to be concern among Edinburgh Sikh leaders that the vigil risks antagonising feelings in the city.

But the event has been organised by the London-based Sikh Human Rights Group and the British Organisation of Sikh Students (Boss), with the backing of other groups.

The 15-year-old Sikh victim of the racist attack was on his way to see relatives earlier this week when four white teenagers attacked him in Pilrig Park and cut his long hair with a knife.

The crime has shocked Sikhs across the country, particularly because the religion does not allow male followers to trim their hair.

Paman Singh, a law student from Glasgow and a member of Boss, said: "Already we have hundreds of people confirmed, and we're hoping to attract more people from all religions.

"After paying our respects at the temple, we want to promote peace and tolerance in Edinburgh.

"There has never been anything on this scale seen in Scotland. People all over Britain are shocked by what happened.

"In the history of Sikhism, people have died for their hair and it's a fundamental aspect of our religion set down by our gurus. It's really important people know how important hair is to us, so that's why we're holding the vigil."

Mr Singh said the family of the victim have given the event their blessing. Coaches are coming from Southall, Slough, Derby, West Bromwich, Walsall, Birmingham, Wolverhampton, Leicester and Glasgow.

A police spokesman said today: "We have extremely close links with the Sikh community in Edinburgh and they - like all other members of the community - have been shocked and outraged at what happened on Tuesday night.

"We have officers working extremely hard to track the culprits of this truly shocking crime. We have been in liaison with the Sikh community about the planned peaceful vigil this weekend."

Last Tuesday, the boy was walking towards the Balfour Place entrance of Pilrig Park when the gang began to shout racist abuse at him. He carried on walking but the youths set on him, punching and kicking him to the ground.

After the attack, which took place at 7.30pm, the teenagers fled across the park into Pilrig Street, and on towards Leith Walk.

The victim made his way home before his family called the police. They offered to call an ambulance but the boy, who lives in the area, declined medical attention.

However, the unprovoked assault left the youngster shocked and upset. Police described it as "an extremely distressing attack on a young member of our community".



The full article contains 522 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 18 November 2006 11:23 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

HIS,

Edinburgh 18/11/2006 14:01:04

This has the potential to be completely counter-productive.

2

julien brellier,

18/11/2006 14:46:34

they are having a laugh. whilst its not very nice what happened to the young lad its really no different than happens to hundreds of teenagers every weekend throughout britian. what exactly are they hoping to achieve by this 'show of strength'? the police have already set up a phoneline and email address dedicated to this incident. how many other victims of assault get this privelage from L&B's finest. by the way my real name isnt julien brellier and he has had nothing to do with my writing this.

3

Rubbersnap,

Kilmarnock 18/11/2006 15:58:48

the attack on the boy has to be condemned of course, but I'm not sure this vigil is the brightest idea anyone ever had.

I hope the Leith police are going to be out in force ...

4

Elizabeth M,

USA 18/11/2006 17:30:52

The attack on the young boy is shocking but and these mindless attacks seem the norm in Edinburgh these days - I understand that the cutting of his hair is against his religion but being rasied in a sectarian country it's not the first time I have witnessed a person's religion being attached - Glasglow is far worse I fear -

Not so sure either about this march and 'show of force' I truly feel it will only antagonize rather than help tolerance.

5

Darren,

18/11/2006 18:14:34

i cant even understand this - the kid has his hair cut! not murdered, stabbed, or set on fire whilst alive.... He is still alive yet they are having a vigil?! Kriss didnt have one......

6

brettgallacher,

edinburgh 18/11/2006 18:56:01

why is it before anyone has been convicted of a crime against an asian he is guilty is it because only whites are racist and the british born asians are the only ones telling the truth

7

,

18/11/2006 19:00:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 176078, Article id was mapped to record!
8

Darren,

18/11/2006 19:04:59

#7 - yes, i suppose thats why. Becuase Kriss was white, he gets forgotten about, but we can never forget about Damalola taylor and now this case.... because they are not white.

white people are rasist, non white people are not rasist - well, this is the message the media are saying imho.

bout time this country woke up and smelt the.....

9

,

18/11/2006 19:05:15
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 176082, Article id was mapped to record!
10

,

18/11/2006 19:08:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 176088, Article id was mapped to record!
11

,

18/11/2006 19:14:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 176093, Article id was mapped to record!
12

,

18/11/2006 19:16:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 176096, Article id was mapped to record!
13

Scottish,

Glasgow 18/11/2006 21:06:23

Hi, can we all just take a breather? i was born and brought up here. My parents are sikhs.

I am not having a go at any of the posters - the importance of hair to a sikh is not widely publised by sikhs themselves, however in the uk we - yes brett thats WE, live in a democracy. As far as seeing a Scot in Scotland - do u just mean a white Scot, i was born here remember.
I am truly sorry for you and hope you dont get so obsessed by your dislike. Take care all.

14

arran,

england! 18/11/2006 21:59:33

firstly brettgallacher are you related to these kids or something? beacuse it sure does seem that way

and who provides the healthcare? who does most of the jobs other people wont do , a large number who fought in the war?

oh yes ASIANS!!

no need to start being racist , maybee people are coming to show their SUPPORT! for the child and their fmaily. and also show that it has effected the sikh community a lot!

there is no need for inappropriate comments. and espically for racism. it was the kids identity! not those kids so whats it to them?

this could all be inflicted on the parents not bringing up their children correctly! and in a racist environment!

this is totallty outta order and disgusting what goes on!

the british invaded india , did god knows what. yet they still call over asian people for help ie NHS! and in the worldwar 1 /2 ... and this is the graitude they get!

IT IS TOTTALY DISGUSTING! ...

15

Isabel Ronan,

Edinburgh 18/11/2006 22:00:51

It would make a difference if everyone reading could understand the words peace,vigil and candles.The Sikhs are coming to be repectful why can we not simply hold out our hands and welcome them with our own disgust at what happened.Perhaps if we did this after every violent episode no matter race,colour or creed we might learn that violence is the issue and respect,tolerance and understanding can beat it.

16

Scottish,

Glasgow 18/11/2006 22:35:15

Id just like to say, that everyone is entitled to their opinons , but if its not constructive, then why drag other people down.

I have been to edinburgh many times, and have never once suffered any racism, which is more than can be said for other cities in scotland. So if you are in the minority, and are afraid - i urge you to come along to pilrig park tomorrow, take some time out, come and meet me - speak to some sikhs if you are so worried, and watch our behaviour, i have full faith that we will not disrespect anybody, as that is not our aim, there will be no shouting and screaming and mobs - simple demonstration.

Please dont bring Kris Donald into this, the poor boy was horrifically murdered, and i think it does a disservice to him, his brave family, and the whole tragic murder. To use his name and compare it is very cheap. If you have you views fair enough, just dont stoop to such depths.

God Bless

17

Jockyw,

18/11/2006 23:13:56

There are two sides to every incident.
Let’s see the alleged attackers caught & then the law can hear their points.
It might be that the boy (alleged victim? TBC) started it with words or actions.
We will never know until the other parties are brought forward for interview.
It might be that the alleged assault group fired worse? All theory at present

One word against another at this stage, your not guilty until proven so at the moment it’s an alleged assault regardless who came off worse.

The boy’s hair will grow back, let’s thank god it wasn’t taken any further and the boy was hospitalised or worse.

The coach load of people are not required at this stage, I’m not clear what it will do but aggravate so many other more other scenarios and kids who have been killed in similar alleged assaults.

Let’s hope the other group are caught and the facts will be present. Is there any other DNA or weapons are at the crime scene etc.

18

roberto,

19/11/2006 00:11:01

for one of the uk's bigger cities,racist incidents like the one in pilrig park are extremely rare in edinburgh(ones that get reported to police or make the papers anyway)

though i suppose it happening once is once too many

though we have to look at the fact a 15 year old of any race can't walk through a city park without feeling safe

at its not just teenagers who feel at risk just take a look at the meadows every weekend

19

singh,

edinburgh 19/11/2006 01:26:45

i dont think brett gallagher knows much about the sikh religion, so if he doesnt know he shouldnt comment! There are sikhs that have been living in edinburgh as long as 50 to 60 years and now there families are SCOTTISH SIKHS, they work hard, pay there taxes and not all live of benefits. I was born in edinburgh and lived in Leith for 35 years and never seen or heard of anything like this in my life, and its no fair that this lad has had to even be a victim in all this. Darren (5) is bringing Kriss Donald case in to it, but does he know that his murderers are Pakistanis NOT SIKHS! We might speak the same but our beliefs are different, so get your facts right! So why should the sikhs suffer for something they havent even done, so live and let live!

20

R_A_786,

Edinburgh 19/11/2006 02:39:04

I am fed up of hearing racist comments like "these people coming to MY country etc and send them back to where they came from."

I am a muslim of pakistani and indian origin. My grandparents were indian and my parents pakistani whilst i was born in britain.

I have lived here all my life and i AM BRITISH. I have asian friends whose parents and grandparents were born in the UK but are still told my a minority to "go back to where they came from"

If anyone here thinks these people should go back to where they came from, would this be the same for every person. Would this be the case for the WHITE scottish child who has irish grandparents? Or the scottish child who has a welsh mother?

HOWEVER

Racism is bad in this country BUT i for one know for a fact there are scottish asians who are JUST as racist as the worst racist white people in this country.

Racism MUST be tackled at primary school so children know from a young age that this is unaccpetable.... this should be applied to BOTH the white schoolboy who i heard saying he was "off to the paki shop" as well as the asian schoolboy i heard say "i hate that chinky boy." Maybe if these children were better educated racism can be more easily tackled?

21

R_A_786,

Edinburgh 19/11/2006 02:44:17

Also in reference to #22 singh..

Pakistani is not a religion and SIKH is not a nationality.

Kriss donald was killed by ASIAN thugs, to be more precise PAKISTANI thugs who supposedly take the name of the religion of islam. However these thugs were not practising muslims.

Please remember the difference between religion and nationality.

22

harinder,

pune 19/11/2006 06:01:54

Dear R_A_786

please explain how

No Hindus exist in Kashmir , Sind , Baluchistan etc today .

Why are statues of Buddha blown up in afghanistan even today.

Why are u at war with all non muslims be it hindus , christaians , jews etc.

It is time to do some introspection.

You cant tell lies for all the time and get away with it any more .

We fully appreciate how much hatred u all harbours toward all non muslims .

23

harinder,

pune 19/11/2006 06:07:49

also remember the differrence.

We may all be Asians but we are not Muslims.

We are Asian Hindus , Sikhs , Jains , christaians and Parsis etc.

We all cherish and respect life which God gave us all irrespective of the name we worship him by


love

24

Pete39,

Tassy 19/11/2006 09:03:14

Ach you are all human beings albeit of different religious persuasions. You argue and fight, but without the great teachers the majority of you would have enthusiastically killed each other. I do not agree with this large influx of sikhs, any type of ceremony belongs to the community. Get real, some of them could be English Sikhs. By the way I include Scots Christians as human beings.

25

toby,

edinburgh 19/11/2006 12:32:40

What we should remember is that these kind of assaults both on teenagers and the elderly are becoming commonplace and accepted as being part of life. How often do we see people prepared to protest at the inability of the Police to teake action. In the same area there are incidents where shopkeepers have been intimidated, graffiti with the name of the offenders, sprayed on walls etc yet the only reply by the Police is 'we know who the offenders are and we're monitoring the situation'. Its time more people got off their backsides and done some form of protest.

26

Concerned Colleague,

Edinburgh 19/11/2006 12:57:18

I live in Edinburgh, I was born in England and have a slight English twang in my accent after being up here for almost a decade. I am a white person in apparently a very white country.
As many of my Asian or African/Carribbean friends will testify the racist remarks I receive when certain people hear my dulcite tones are usually far more public,offensive and common than the remarks they receive because of their skin colour. To the extent where I have had a hospital visit or two because I murdered and raped Scotch ancestors apparently until Wallace's forces took charge-their words not mine I might add.

27

Concerned Colleague,

Edinburgh 19/11/2006 13:06:43

In Scotland it also appears that I can be called an English B*stard or other without anyone blinking an eyelid. If an Asian person receives something similar it is considered racist and offensive. Sorry but what did I do to deserve this.

28

cf,

edinburgh,leith 19/11/2006 13:10:33

this attack was based on a rasist attack!!! all these sikhs (think thats how you spell it) coming from all over britian is just going to make these white rasist people million times worse!! all these people are all better to pray and have a vigil in their own home! If that is what they think will save this boy! i think it was bad what happened but everything hapens for a reason!

And may i just say based on experience asians, etc are more rasist than white people

29

Karin,

19/11/2006 14:24:24

CF,

and what, pray tell, do you think the reason for this attack was? are you are relative of brett above by any chance?

Why should Sikh people hide in their own homes because of racists? Oh yes, and you spelt Sikh correctly, but racist has a c, not an s.

Get a life, and a dictionary. Racists have to be challenged not appeased and hidden from.

30

SeRaNADE,

19/11/2006 15:06:36

a few people here think that this is vigil is pointless...well to add another thing this vigil is also to make people realise what Sikhs are...alot of people call them muslims or another form of hindus Sikhi is a religion on trust and the hair thing? its a Gift from God himself everyone here ty to imagine what it is like first of all to have the thing that u keep Most Sacred and imagine someone not giving a damn about it and screwin it up nonetheless....only wen u are in that situation u truly understand And for that Brett Guy? this isint your country get over it

31

Papa Smarv,

Glasgow 19/11/2006 15:11:29

Clearly those who have a problem with this PEACE vigil have no idea about Sikhism which is the exact purpose of it: to explain to people the princilples of Sikhism and why Sikhs have been so deeply hurt by this attack. So why are a people so afraid of being educated?! Its not healthy to shy away from the unknown. I see this as an attack on human rights and therefore had it been an attack on an individual from any other faith I would be just as disgusted.
peace

32

Fred Blogs,

Edinburgh 19/11/2006 15:16:28

It may not have dawned on people but Leith is being noticed around the World considering the news articles I have seen. What are they talking about that Leith people are decent, hard working, law abiding, forward looking, going places, the Dock Development etc etc.

Er, No not quite what they talking about is that a young Sikh boy was attacked in Pilrig Park by four white youths and his hair was cut of which is the worst insult possible to a Sikh. The sooner these animals are brought to book the better for all our sakes otherwise our names and the name of Leith will be mud and the work and efforts gone into making Leith a better place to live will have gone for nothing.

So if you have any information tell the Police as soon as possible for all our sakes.

33

,

19/11/2006 16:12:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 177257, Article id was mapped to record!
34

ednbru,

Edinburgh 19/11/2006 16:46:55

Well I'm sickee as well, lets take this oportunity to round them all up and transfer them all on to boats down leith, Ahh that would be nice

35

Budgie,

Scotland. 19/11/2006 17:05:55

The ignorance of some contributors is evident. Why else would they link the Kriss Donald case with the Sikh boy incident?
What happened to that boy by these thugs is absolutely deplorable, and the Sikh community should be assured that all reasonable thinking Scots share their revulsion at what occurred.
The sikh contribution to the culture of this country is a positive one, and their firmly held beliefs should be respected.

36

SeRaNADE,

19/11/2006 17:09:41

running away aint the bloody answer if anything stand up for it wasnt there huge banners and slogans and stuff about this? mayb its time people listen to that and stop takin crap like this and i agree with #34 this attack isint just to cause harm to a single person...its causing harm to the whole Religion And it must be stopped

37

Budgie,

Scotland. 19/11/2006 17:18:07

*30. cf. Edinburgh.

You are correct when you say that "everything has a reason", and the reason for carrying out this disgraceful and disrespectful act was a desire to indulge their anti social behaviour.
I sincerely hope he perpetrators are caught and are punished to the full extent of the law.

38

,

19/11/2006 19:13:34
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 177463, Article id was mapped to record!
39

harpz,

glasgow 19/11/2006 20:07:46

#41 that comment was proper disgusting. people are tring hard to put a stop to racism but still there are narrow minded poeple for exampleyou who are still making cheap comments such as you just did. you need to open your eyes and step into the real world. sarky comments like that are just not acceptable. joke or no joke.
im proud of the sikh religion. they were able to come together on the first sound of trouble to their religion. not many poeple are capable of that. ...

40

harpz,

glasgow 19/11/2006 20:17:05

#41 that comment was proper disgusting. people are tring hard to put a stop to racism but still there are narrow minded poeple for exampleyou who are still making cheap comments such as you just did. you need to open your eyes and step into the real world. sarky comments like that are just not acceptable. joke or no joke.
im proud of the sikh religion. they were able to come together on the first sound of trouble to their religion. not many poeple are capable of that. ...

41

Freebird,

UK 19/11/2006 20:51:48

It seems to me too many people posting here don't understand the significance of hair to Sikhs, the boys attackers seem to understand it though, this was a henious crime as it takes advantage of the fact that so many don't understand why it was so wrong. This was a sectarian attack something sadly too common in Scotland.

42

Doreen,

The Cyber Shebeen 19/11/2006 21:53:14

27....Toby....absolutely there has been silence for too long regarding ned attacks.

You dont half get a load o' numpties comin oot the woodwork when articles like this appear.

43

the snooper,

19/11/2006 22:07:13

eh ,you do-not think he is after a cash payout,they get cash if the are upset .

44

singh,

edinburgh 19/11/2006 23:11:39

46 the snooper, What do you mean we get cash if were upset! you dont even know this boy so who the hell do you think your referring to! listen no money in the world could repair the damage done to this boys confidence, people like yourself dont make it any easier for the lad that has had his hair cut off by SCUM! and right now your not any better.I wish you were a sikh and you got attacked by 4 white scumbags and had you long hair hacked off by them, then you would know exactly what pain the lad is going through.

45

Angus Mcdonald,

Edinburgh 20/11/2006 13:06:04

Fair enough the thing that happened was bad and uncalled for however this is just a joke. All that bother over that?Noone was hospitalised or killed so why all the fuss?.

46

Ellen,

Edinburgh 20/11/2006 13:10:12

Yes, racism is alive and well in Scotland (as Kriss Donald would attest) and is unlikely to be remedied by any number of public information films or vigils. A "show of strength" is unnecessary and likely inflammatory.

47

Ellen,

Edinburgh 20/11/2006 13:33:42

"There is understood to be concern among Edinburgh Sikh leaders that the vigil risks antagonising feelings in the city." [Rightly so] "But the event has been organised by the London-based Sikh Human Rights Group and the British Organisation of Sikh Students"

Is this the rise of militant Sikhism now?

48

harinder,

pune 20/11/2006 15:25:58

Is this the rise of militant Sikhism now?

I think you are being naive about sikhs.

Sikhs are a peaceful and law abiding citizens of any country.

If to say collectively that one has been hurt by some ones foolish action then I think the word militant needs to be redefined.

The only time Sikhs fought in Britian was when british were being rammed by the Nazi guys.

The next time sikhs shall be fighting in Britians is when there is a attack to british society by terrorist (to what ever out fit he may belong )to or an invasions by aliens.

so cool up

49

Ellen,

Edinburgh 20/11/2006 15:59:07

Harinder, sending bus-loads of London Sikh students as a "show of force" on the strength of one assault, and against the wishes of the Edinburgh Sikh community (who can see that this action might be antagonistic), sounds a bit aggressive to me but I hope you're right.

50

R_A_786,

Edin 20/11/2006 16:00:55

#24 and #25 Harinder

Your post clearly shows that you are racist towards muslims.

So you are trying to tell me there are no hindus, sikhs or christians in the areas you stated? Do you know this for fact and have you actually gone yourself to investigate this?

I am assuming you think there are no other religions present in Pakistan but Prince Charles did visit these different groups of religions when he was in Pakistan.

Not all muslims have HATE toward non-muslims. For you to think this clearly shows racism is strife in all walks of life.

love!

51

Ellen,

Edinburgh 20/11/2006 16:40:33

"Not all muslims have HATE toward non-muslims" but a vast majority do or are not prepared to say anything to the contrary? "racist towards muslims"? Maybe it needs to be pointed out AGAIN, but "racism" is a skin-colour issue, Islam is (apparently) a religion (of peace...apparently) open to all races. The current fashion for using the "racist" (fascist, nazi, etc.) label at any opportunity only serves to demean the word(s).

52

Christopher Parton,

Leith 20/11/2006 20:47:23

do we want our country to gain a reputation for racism? we're trying to attract tourism and business and any racist atacks must be deplored and the perpetrators brought to justice.

i know little about the sikh faith but i know that the hair is very important to them as they keep turbans for a reason. in my experience of them they're well mannered people and the candlelit vigil they did was very peaceful with old people and mums with young children attending.

they gave our leaflets about how hundreds of thousands of sikhs died fighting for Great Britain in world war one and WWII whilst wearing turbans. Let's just spread peace and make life better for all of us.

53

R_A_786,

Edin 21/11/2006 01:02:13

Ellen

Muslims are prepared to speak out against those Muslims who hate non-Muslims. Just take a look at the response from the Muslim community as a whole to terrorist attacks.

Racism can be against a particular group of individuals rather than that based on colour, the term racism can be interpreted differently.

"What Is Racism?

A more universal definition of racism is "Prejudice or discrimination by one group toward others perceived as a different 'race', plus the power to enforce it." Groups may be almost identical physiologically, yet be divided against each other on the basis of culture, language, religion, nationality, or any combination of the above."
(http://anitra.net/activism/racism/index.html)

Islam is apparently open to all races? - Yes, there are Muslims from all walks of life, Islam is the second largest religion in the world and the fastest growing religion in the world.

54

dicky,

21/11/2006 11:52:59

did they bring the P.R.S with them???

55

Ellen,

Edinburgh 21/11/2006 13:36:49

I have seen the response from the Muslim community to terrorist attacks - I have seen very few condem them outright (without a "but..." at the end). Here's a link to an article by the Muslim Press Association which should clarify the position:
http://www.mpacuk.org/content/view/2465/34/

You're link to some lefty's view of the neo-liberal definition of racism carries no weight - look it up in a dictionary!


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.