Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Saturday, 7th November 2009 Change Date

Bikers ride to commute victory

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 September 2008
MOTORCYCLISTS have emerged victorious in a battle to find the quickest way to travel into Edinburgh city centre.
The annual commuter time trial saw bikes, buses, cars, and even a jogger battle it out from the edge of town to St Andrew Square.

Participants set off from four separate departure points, with the fastest mode of transport found to be the motorbik
e ride from Ingliston park-and-ride, clocking up an average speed of 18.3mph.

The fastest journey overall was the 16-minute bike ride from Ocean Terminal to St Andrew Square.

The slowest participant was the jogger from Newcraighall park-and-ride to the city centre, who completed the five-mile journey in 38 minutes.

Event organiser Maggie Wynn said: "The challenge compares some typical commuter journeys into the centre of Edinburgh for speed, cost and impact on climate change.

"We hope the results will help people make their own minds up about how they want to travel to work. For the first time we had two joggers and their average speed was very similar to the car."

All of the participants in the challenge had to follow the highway code and other regulations, such as the speed limits.

Patsy James, 56, an IT trainer from Portobello, took the train from Newcraighall with her bicycle, and arrived first from those doing that route.

She said: "Travelling by train with a bicycle makes a really speedy combination. For journeys of more than five miles it is the quickest home-to work option, and if you have a folding bicycle there is no worry about finding space on the train.

"Newcraighall park-and-ride has lots of cycle parking stands and lockers, so it is also possible to leave the bicycle safely at the station."

The commuter challenge is part of European Mobility Week.

Iain Coupar, marketing director for Lothian Buses, was one of those taking part in the challenge, cycling from Ingliston park-and-ride to St Andrew Square in 27 minutes.

He said: "It was a really good event and I think I could have been a bit quicker actually if I had not been caught at a couple of lights.

"For me, the beauty of this is that it shows that you don't just have to stick to one mode of transport if you're commuting.

"Personally I will sometimes cycle from West Lothian into our offices in Edinburgh, but on other occasions I will drive to the park-and-ride at Hermiston and just get the bus.

"It is all about choices, you have to weigh up the hassle of driving or cycling against taking the bus, which is stress-free."





The full article contains 449 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 22 September 2008 11:58 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

allknowing,

22/09/2008 12:12:06
"It is all about choices, you have to weigh up the hassle of driving or cycling against taking the bus, which is stress-free."

Your joking right, rushing to get the bus, which you have just missed becuase its early, or you have to wait for becuase its late. Then sitting next to the general public for 30mins, while then walking/running to work in the pouring rain.

Yeah, stress free my ar4e
2

allknowing,

22/09/2008 12:13:37
ps where did the car come?? I guess faster than the bus, which is poor considering the buses have bus lanes, and almost every advantage afford to them!! Says it all really.
3

Randan,

22/09/2008 12:15:04
I was about to ask how long it would take for some kn0bhead driver to come out with their usual keech, but look - I've been beaten to it already!
4

allknowing,

22/09/2008 12:17:37
#3 what part of my post is keech?

Buses are never on time (stress inducing), the general public has no manners and you get attacked(stress inducing), and then getting wet on the way to work (stress inducing) while running becuase the bus was late (stress inducing)
5

Randan,

22/09/2008 12:21:53
allknowing - you've probably never been on a bus with the horrible smelly proles, so you are in no position to comment.
Bog off you twonk.
6

Randan,

22/09/2008 12:23:19
BTW allknowing, it is better to remain silent and be perceived an idiot than to open your mouth and prove it.
I guess you were ignorant of that too.
7

Plodjfriss, Hammer of the Numpties,

Edinburgh 22/09/2008 12:33:51
I wonder how many people were killed or injured after being attacked on buses last year ("you get attacked")? Let's bear in mind that something like 1500 car drivers and passengers are killed in crashes inthe UK every year.
8

Wingman,

Edinburgh 22/09/2008 12:35:24
Vindicates what i have been saying for a long time, motorcycles have a large part to play in personal transportation and fewer cars on the road, now if the council want to help, bus lanes will be opened up to them. Before you all start banging on about noisy smelly bikes, get real ! I know and appreciate every prat out there cannot be accounted for but the vast majority of m/cyclists are mature responsible adults, riding economical clean efficient bikes contributing greatly to a reduction in cars on the roads in the daily commute, unfortunately the weather is the only thing that is out our control. London is a fine example where they have embraced PTW(powered 2 wheelers) to the extent that there are so many of them that they now charge bikes for parking as a means of income.
9

Road Raga,

EDINBURGH 22/09/2008 12:35:24
I,m waiting for the first ' but cyclist don't pay road tax'

Not long now......
10

Artemis,

22/09/2008 12:37:19
#9 - I'm stunned that we've got to 10 comments and nobody's suggested that the cyclists ran red lights and cycled on pavements - because we all know all cyclists do that, all the time.
11

Cumberland Sausage,

22/09/2008 13:04:44
allknowing is a troll with some major issues and disorders to deal with. Why are you so angry pal?
12

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 22/09/2008 13:04:47
#2:

Bus lanes are there to hold up cars, not to aid the passage of buses.

#6:

In which case, you have just proved your own quote... Several times over.
13

Incandescent,

22/09/2008 13:08:51
Randan, I was going to suggest that you take heed of your own advice at #6 but I see I was beaten too it. Road Raga might want to take heed of it though...
14

It's heading straight for us!,

Edinburgh 22/09/2008 13:10:12
#9 not to mention we eat our own children and mug old ladies in our spare time, we are probably hiding Bin Laden too!

I think the cyclist would have won if the route had been through Craigmillar on a £2,000 top of the range MTB and a laptop on the pannier!
15

allknowing,

22/09/2008 13:10:14
#'12 agreed, my point was that even though buses have all the advantages going for them, they are still slow and late. It really does beggars belief
16

Incandescent,

22/09/2008 13:10:26
...to it...
17

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 22/09/2008 13:22:20
#14:

What's a Motor Torpedo Boat got to do with it?

Actually, now I come to think of it, trying to get into town using a motor torpedo boat as a means of transport would be quite an interesting experience....
18

Desperately Seeking.......a solution,

22/09/2008 13:30:58
I travel from home in South Queensferry to the City Centre every working day on my motorbike. It's only a 125cc but it only take me 25 minutes. If I used my car it would take me @1 hour. I get @35 miles to the gallon with the car compared to @80 on the bike. Oh, and for those car drivers who try and close the gap between lanes because their jealous of me "cutting" through them, I should point out that "filtering" is actually legal.......
19

lulach mac gille coemgain,

22/09/2008 14:00:00
How did the online working from home fair ? I awoke 40 miles from the city centre and was working online for my EHcentral office location within a nano second !

Whupped the ass of all the commutes ! And i could have been anywhere in the world !

Still there are dinosaurs out there - unfortunately managing all these corporations who are currently on there way down !
20

Anth,

Edinburgh 22/09/2008 14:14:10
I don't think any of us were surprised to see that on the one route the motorbike was on it was fastest. All the benefits of the bike, plus just that little bit quicker.

The buses, as ever, were way behind. I was on a bike from Newcraighall, and naturally ran through red lights, cycled on pavements, blatantly didn't pay any road tax, used no lights and poked puppies with sharp sticks.
21

Artemis,

22/09/2008 14:34:13
You can get all the times for all the participants on the clean air for all website. It's interesting how bikes compare very favourably with cars over these distances. It'd be nice if people would see it as evidence that commuting by bike is a viable option for many people and perhaps consider it themselves.
22

Anth,

Edinburgh 22/09/2008 14:53:59
Damn, we missed the one about being smelly and dishevelled!

Well if that time was to be taken into account, Fresian, then the bus, car and train journeys should have started 15-20 minutes later to take account of that same shower and clothing they have to do BEFORE the commute?
23

Artemis,

22/09/2008 15:07:23
I wish the worst thing in my office was the smell of sweaty lycra.
24

festerlehearts,

22/09/2008 15:10:06
i blame the trams
25

,

22/09/2008 16:44:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

TM,

LA, USA 22/09/2008 17:01:20
Do people really commute on bicycles and motorcycles in Edinburgh in winter when there is a 50/50 chance of rain and it is freezing? Tough folks...
27

Anth,

Edinburgh 22/09/2008 17:13:29
"There's no such thing as bad weather, only inappropriate clothing"

That said, I tend to ride through winter in 3/4 length trousers, though I do don a beanie hat and stick a fleece on. Once you get going you soon warm up.

Vincent, it's the same with riding a bike, a brilliant way to destress at the end of the day. Even spending one day back in the car for the commute makes me appreciate riding to work!

http://www.citycycling.co.uk/issue32/issue32page36.html
28

TM,

LA, USA 22/09/2008 17:37:17
Btw aren't cobblestone streets pretty slippery for two wheelers? Also do the parking police let motorcycles park on the sidewalks, sorry pavements?
29

Artemis,

22/09/2008 17:50:19
#29 - and we play rugby without feeling the need to wear a couple of pounds of body armour.

#31 - parking regulations vary but no, motorbikes can't park on pavements unless the pavement contains a designated parking area, as far as I know.
30

,

22/09/2008 20:24:13
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
31

TM,

LA, USA 23/09/2008 03:44:29
Vincent and fresian,
Even though the east is drier than the west coast it still sounds like an adventure.I have seen horizontal rain in the east of Scotland myself...lol Guess you have good warm riding gear. Here the only obstacle are thousands of Really Bad Drivers....
32

Julian.,

edinburgh 23/09/2008 03:55:28
Allknowing # 4

"what part of my post is keech?"

The bit about waiting 30 mins for a bus for a start. All the routes talked about above have 5 minute bus services.

Just imagine how quick these motorbike riders might have been if they'd been allowed to use the greenways...unlike these environmentally unfriendly taxis.
33

Julian.,

edinburgh 23/09/2008 03:59:54
#33 Vincent,

It's not the severity of the weather we complain about, it's just the general miserableness of it....rains about 200 days a year and short sleeves can only be worn about 30 days.
34

TM,

LA, USA 23/09/2008 04:06:18
#37 Julian
Well on the plus side, guess you don't have to worry too much about skin cancer....right?
35

bananaman,

25/09/2008 13:00:36
Has there been a police round up of idiots who think they're the funniest thing since Jeremy Clarkson?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.