Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Saturday, 7th November 2009 Change Date

McConnell is sold out by Holyrood over Malawi charity calendars

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 December 2008
IT would never have happened when he was First Minister.
But Jack McConnell has fallen foul of the Scottish Parliament's "petty-minded bureaucrats" after being refused permission by Holyrood bosses to sell a charity calendar.

The now backbench MSP, who counts launching a special programme to help tackle poverty in Malawi as one of his proudest achievements, wanted the parliament shop to sell the £5 calendar to raise money for the African country.

But the parliament's corporate body vetoed the move, insisting the only charity the parliament supports is the Poppy Scotland Appeal.

Mr McConnell took matters into his own hands and set up a stall in the corridor outside his office to sell the calendars himself to fellow politicians, staff and researchers. In just one day, he sold 140.

Mr McConnell was said to be "disappointed" by the corporate body's decision, but did not want to get into a public row with them.

Lothians Labour MSP George Foulkes, however, said the shop ban was "disgraceful". He said: "It's absolutely typical of the pettifogging bureaucracy in the Scottish Parliament. I have never come across such petty-minded bureaucrats. It's absolutely ludicrous."

During his six years as First Minister, Mr McConnell enthusiastically revived Scotland's 150-year-old links with the African country. It led to the creation of a cross-party group of MSPs on Malawi.

The calendars have been produced by Edinburgh midwife Linda McDonald. She said: "You win some, you lose some. I just thought it would be a good place to sell them."

A parliament spokeswoman said: "The corporate body was very sympathetic to Mr McConnell's request. It does acknowledge the special relationship with Malawi and has asked staff to consider various ways to demonstrate it, but the charity policy remains that we only support Poppy Scotland."


The full article contains 309 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 December 2008 11:07 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Labour Party
 
1

Stewarty,

13/12/2008 11:48:54
As usual George Foulkes has nothing constructive to say. Perhaps his wasted energies could be better employed if he set up Del-boy style in Princes Street to flog Jack's calendars.

Secondly, if Jack is so keen to assist Malawi why has he delayed taking up his post there instead of getting under everyone's feet at the Numptarium.
2

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 13/12/2008 11:57:29
Never mind Jack when Labour gets its butt kicked out in 2009/10 you'll have more opportunity to sell calendars because you won't be going anywhere. If he was ploughing all of his own money in to Malawi rather than the very hard-pressed taxpayer, he might be believable. The perception is that this is a vanity project rather than a true commitment, otherwise he'd be there.

#1 Stewarty - "Numptarium" - excellent!

3

Grant Thoms,

Glasgow 13/12/2008 12:05:18
So does Westminster let MPs sell Xmas Cards in their gift shop?
4

AntiEdinburghWhingers,

13/12/2008 12:10:55
I can't believe how much of a moaning, whinging git Jack is: I mean how dare he demand that the shop sell is charity calendars. It's just as well the staff at the Parliament have some sense to stop the entire place being turned into one big charity shop to cater for each and every whim of the MSPs. Could you imagine if they let each and every one of the 129 MSPs sell something for their favourite charity? It would be mess!

Our Parliament IS NOT A CHARITY SHOP! Thank god there's people who work there who have a bit more common sense than the MSPs!

It's a good cause, yes, but there is a place for such things, and the Parliament shop isn't one of them.
5

Nurse,

Edinburgh 13/12/2008 12:20:22
Why doesn't Jack try selling them outside the now bust Woolworths at the bottom of Leith walk, he might also like to see that Edinburgh has places that require charity work also, if not why so many charity shops.

I guess he is to frightened to see the real world outside his comfy office. Also to be honest I doubt that he could cope with real people, voters at home, about time he emigrated to his cosy embassy in Malawi and gave us all some peace.

6

Dragonlord,

13/12/2008 12:24:11
Poppy Scotland is the only charity.Full stop.
How many " charities" for Africa actually send the money there? Admin and beurocrats skimming off the top and very little ends up where it's needed.Food destined for the hungry end up on the table of fat cats, who run tin pot countries, and whilst they are all right, their own people are starving.
7

AntiEdinburghWhingers,

13/12/2008 12:33:17
Hang on a minute, it just occurred to me: the Scottish Parliament Corporate Body's policies are all decided on by... now wait for it... MSPs!

The SPCB is run by MSPs - not "petty bureaucrats"! George Foulkes should be attacking himself!

In any case, Lord Foulkes knows all about being petty - considering his petty comments in the chamber. About time he retired, I think. He's clearly lost it.
8

Macuistean,

Isle of Tiree 13/12/2008 12:42:55
How much charity money goes to Africa and how much is spent on guns and bullets? Add to that, how much do these charities pay their executives? For years and years I've heard nothing but helping Africa from starvation to lack of drinking water but the bullets keep being used and as we all know "An army marches on it's stomach". Who feeds the armies?
9

Warden An' All, Reborn,

13/12/2008 13:34:07
A country we have a 150-year-old link with, and we have had a cross-party group of MSPs on the country, and still the Scottish parliament would veto the sale of a charitable calendar in support of this country. A country Scotland has charitable links with officially. Nonsense, total nonsense.
The Scottish parliament want to realise that there are areas where party politics are not welcome, and this would be one of them.
It would seem that losing his position in the last Scottish elections has benefited Mr McConnell with his humility. We can always hope that one day this Scottish government might find some of their own.







10

subrosa,

13/12/2008 13:40:12
# 10

Funnily enough, it was the labour party who set the policy of only supporting the Poppy Scotland Appeal back in 1999. Parliamentary rules would have to be changed and that would mean a vote in the chamber.

Good to see another stupid rule of labours coming back to bite them.
11

The Squirrel,

13/12/2008 13:41:58
Jack McConnell's wee Malawai hobby is a sick joke, and his association with that country probably reduces its standing in the world much as his association with Scotland did the same.

Does McConnell think he's some kind of Bob Gelfdof character?

McConnell - you walk funnt, you've got a lisp, you supported an illegal war. Harping on about malawi like you've got an autistic obsession with it, well that's just daft.


12

,

13/12/2008 13:43:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
13

Warden An' All, Reborn,

13/12/2008 14:18:31
11-subrosa-There was me believing the scottish government's involvement stemmed from a visit to Malawi in February 2005, post dating that 1999 agreement on only supporting the scotland poppy appeal. Looks to me the scottish government at the time believed it was a given scotland would back such charitable endeavours.
I guess politicians are not so charitable with projects they don't believe are their own.
14

Warden An' All, Reborn,

13/12/2008 14:52:53
12-The Squirrel-You believe helping the poor in Malawi is a sick joke do you, or is your hatred for Jack McConnell so great you would rather see others suffer to get one over him?
15

Warden An' All, Reborn,

13/12/2008 15:01:35
13-The Squirrel-There’s one thing for sure, they can’t all be useful. Not with you being so inclined and unable.
16

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 13/12/2008 15:18:58
It's ridiculous that the Parliament only allows support for one charity. The rules should be changed as soon as possible.
17

Zohan,

13/12/2008 15:40:00
end police brutality
18

Ju@n Kerr - the ex labour sheep,

13/12/2008 15:40:54
"Lothians Labour MSP George Foulkes, however, said the shop ban was "disgraceful". He said: "It's absolutely typical of the pettifogging bureaucracy in the Scottish Parliament. I have never come across such petty-minded bureaucrats. It's absolutely ludicrous.""

Says the man who asks written questions at 70 quid a time on "how much bog roll the parli goes through and which parties use most...."
19

Schot,

13/12/2008 15:42:11
If the Scotsman think this is an important enough story to be printed then it would be hypocritical if they themselves didn't offer to sell the calendars as one of the 'readers offers' that they regularly do. At the very least you could have included a postal address or a website link where they can be bought.

The parliament supports many charities, it is just their 'charity starts at home' - all the MSPs relatives who get jobs, the second houses, the unjustifiable expenses. The fact McConnell is a ba'-heid doesn't justify running down that or any other charity. I've never been inside the flea-pit so was bemused to hear they have a shop inside. Why is there and what does it sell ? I hope the people who are saying the Parliament isn't a charity shop will be campaigning for them to stop selling poppies.

Macuistean, there are so many things wrong with your post I suspect there is something wrong with you. You start off by implying that charities buy weapons, then back track and say slightly more sensibly food-aid feeds armies. Remind me again, who is Malawi at war with? Do you think their army are just waiting for a decent meal before they go on a killing rampage ? Perhaps you genuinely believe you oppose charity and support starvation to reduce the level of violence but it reads like a mean-spirited excuse to justify your own Scrooge-like greed.
20

Westfield Bairns,

falkirk 13/12/2008 16:00:58
Lets get real here, wee Jack was a major part of the wasted years of the last Scottish Exective, ye, Exective, as even though its Devolved Government the Liebour party couldn't, and some still can't even call it Government. Thats how petty they are and George Foulkes another useless trough feeder.
Is it not about time the Liebour party concentrated on issues relevent to the Scottish people
21

go boil ur heid,

13/12/2008 17:48:41
if cancer mcconnell did as much for the poor of scotland as he does for malawi then we wouldn't have to do without to pay off the debt he left us with
22

Fecker,

13/12/2008 18:16:28
how much of Jack's own money goes to Malawi, I wonder......
23

Stef,

Edinburgh 13/12/2008 18:19:06
Why doesn't 'Del Boy' McConnell punt his calenders in the hundreds of empty Pubs, social clubs and business's that his policies have closed. Maybe the 1000's of people he has made unemployed might eagerly want to spend that £5.00 for a calender out of their social security benefits. Maybe also some of the millions of people awaiting unemployment might want a £5.00 calender, saving Scotland might be the real issue. It would be a better thing for Scotland if McConnell went there and stayed away. Then again do the poor and starving of Malawi would want a burden like McConnell in their country.
24

brianmca3,

auld reekie 13/12/2008 18:23:08
what with brown being the new geldof,"i saved the world"
scottish banks now gone
soon ill be more skint than an african
maybe bob geldof can do a concertfor me
no doubt gf and jm would be flogging the bloody calenders outside
25

Brian Hill,

Edinburgh 14/12/2008 01:21:41
I find my self agreeing with George Foulkes...again (2nd time in 2 weeks, worrying.)

As we have a special relationship with Malawi and as Jack McConnell is so closely associated with this relationship and as we are talking about temporary sales at Christmas surely a quick way can be found round this?

The new Scotland needs a 'Can Do' attitude if it's going to make any serious progress in this highly competitive world, oh and a 'Can Do' attitude is for everything, you can't cherry pick.
26

florence f,

Edinburgh 14/12/2008 12:03:23
12 - kindly do not use 'autistic' as an insult. If it's not acceptable to use 'spastic' in that way it very definitely isn't to use any other handicap. Thank you.
27

alanh,

ek 14/12/2008 12:33:43
#32 why should the shop change its rules just to suit joke mcconnel?

there are very many charities that the vast majority of msps have a soft spot for that are equally as deserving as his pet project and future job prospect when the new liebour party, north briton division, get brave enough to hold a bye election. Would they be allowed under the new liebour flexibility inititive (but only when we aint in power bye-the-way) to sell from the shop too even tho the rules were set by the previous administration?
28

Anonym,

14/12/2008 17:57:44
I agree with George Laird's points.

Also, I think that support for one charity need not mean scuppering an opportunity for another charity, regardless of what the frickin rules say!
29

is it me?,

Edinburgh 14/12/2008 20:47:57
This whole debate is puerile.
Buy a calendar and save Malawi.
Send 50p. and save Zimbabwe.
Donate £5.00 to Congo and buy an assault rifle.
Send troops to Afghanistan and look out for children with bomb-laden wheelbarrows.

F... off and let them get on with it. This small island has done enough.
30

is it me?,

Edinburgh 14/12/2008 20:54:44
p.s.
To all you starving people in Africa.
Get out and do some gardening. Christ knows you've got enough land. And the perfect climate.
ps.
ever heard about hens ?
31

is it me?,

Edinburgh 14/12/2008 21:05:04
pps.
(I'm getting really annoyed now)

If you can't do it yourselves, forget about the evils of 'Colonialism', get rid of your hollow dictators and get Asda or Tesco in.
32

is it me?,

Edinburgh 14/12/2008 21:18:03
...and before any well-meaning advisers come on telling me I'm an arm-chair critic- I spent a lot of years in these places.
I know these people. I know what they can achieve.
But I've never understood why they don't.
33

The Squirrel,

15/12/2008 00:21:26
numptarium

autismatarium

spazztarium
34

The Squirrel,

15/12/2008 00:25:39
It ain't a "handicap" my friend, it's a lifestyle.

Kindly do not use 'handicap' as a label. If it's not acceptable to use 'golf' in that way it very definitely isn't to use any other handicap. Thank you.

Andy Capp, now there was a real drongo retard.


35

The Squirrel,

15/12/2008 00:29:31
Mums Recipes

1 illegal war

1 cringe

No votes

A road map for peace in the middle east

A handicapped Malawi MSP fanboy with a calendar

No votes

*Cringe*

36

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 15/12/2008 18:16:41
Why does the Scottish Parliament have a shop? What is it for? Is it taxed as a business? Does it pay rent? Are the staff pensions gold plated? Does it make a profit? Isn't the rule on charities discriminatory?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.