Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 16th May 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Only £19.99 for a new kilt . . tat'll do nicely!



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 January 2008
THEY have been branded the kings of "tartan tat".
So when discount supermarket chain Lidl announced plans to sell Scotland's national dress for just £25, the Gold Brothers were naturally determined to repel the challenge to their crown.

Now the Royal Mile retailers have announced plans to sell a range of kilts for £19.99 – which they say will make them the cheapest in Scotland.

Dildar Singh, who along with his uncles runs the family's chain of gift shops in the city, said the decision to reduce his cheapest kilts from £40 to £19.99 was a direct response to Lidl entering the market last week.

"We've been selling cheap kilts for two or three years. Now Lidl are jumping on the bandwagon.

"We're going to go into direct competition with them and show people that we are prepared to keep prices low."

Mr Gold said he could "guarantee" that the kilts, which are manufactured in China, were good quality and had not been made using child labour. "There are a lot of people who can't afford £1000 or £500 for a kilt," he said.

"Does that mean they're not allowed to wear the national dress? Kilts are just so expensive, we're providing a service to those who can't afford one elsewhere."

Cut-price kilts have been sold for as little as £20 before by the Gold Brothers but this is the first time a range of tartans have been sold across all their stores.

The price reductions mean the whole Highland outfit can be bought for £185, compared to the usual price of between £500 and £1000. However, the move will do little to calm the growing tensions amid the city's tartan retails.

Kiltmaker Geoffrey Nicholsby has repeatedly spoken out against "tartan tat", amid growing tension between him and the Gold brothers. The Gold Brothers have hit back saying their souvenir stores give tourists what they want.

Brian Wilton, a spokesman for the Scottish Tartans Authority, said cut-price kilts from abroad were bad for the industry's reputation but not regarded as a serious threat to business.

He said: "It certainly devalues the Highland dress industry if people are buying cheap kilts under the impression that they're made here in Scotland.

"But I don't think the industry will be worried about this."

Lidl said its kilts were being provided by "a Scottish supplier," but could not say where they had been made. A spokeswoman said the kilts were aimed at those who wanted to wear national dress for Burns Night but could not afford a traditional version.


CUT-PRICE CLOTH

How the Gold Brothers' kilts compare to the cheapest on offer elsewhere:

• Geoffrey (Tailor) Kiltmakers, High Street £160

• Nicolson Highlandwear, High Street £150

• John Morrison Kiltmakers, High Street £75

• Lidl, stores nationwide £25

The full article contains 478 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 16 January 2008 10:23 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Kilts
 
1

JulesF,

16/01/2008 12:07:21
Excellent, they can slash the price by 50% and still make a profit.

Obviously vastly over-priced to begin with.

This is getting more and more amusing by the day.

All we need now is Tesco to pop up with a BOGOF offer !
2

Hamish B,

Edinburgh 16/01/2008 12:23:04
Load or garbage this is. What we need to do is to warn tourists of trashy shops with the gold brothers shops being on the top of the list. not only are they screwing up and making this country a laughing stock by selling a load of junk,they are also deceiving people. We ought to ban them from opening anything to do with Scotland or Edinburgh
3

barmeyfred,

16/01/2008 13:15:52
whats this obsession with wearing the Kilt for Burns night.
The Bard himself never wore the kilt,the wearing of the plaid had been banned after the 45 rebellion.
Mind you the is a Burns Heritage tartan,the poor man is probably birling in his grave.
4

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

16/01/2008 13:17:15
Market forces , and they arent decieving anyone. If you want a nice house, you pay a lot for it. If you want a shoddy one , or can only afford a shoddy one, you buy a shoddy one.

If you want a good pen you buy one. If you want a cheap one (need i go on...)
5

Bill MacD,

16/01/2008 13:23:31
I used to work in a kilt shop, and they were flooded by emails from Pakistani firms offering their 'kilts' (read cheap skirts!) for about £3 per piece wholesale. Yes, three quid each. And the Gold Brothers buy them in such bulk to fleece tourists with they probably get them cheaper still.

It should be illegal to call these 'kilts'. Would someone selling blue nylon trousers be allowed to market them as 'denim jeans'? I think not! Trading Standards are a bunch of wimps.
6

PaulB,

Edinburgh 16/01/2008 13:34:06
All this cheap tat must be causing great harm to the traditional kilt makers - at least a real kilt will last longer than this sort of rubbish. Unfortunately the cheap stuff will sell. Real kilts should be protected in the same way as certain types of regional foods. I also agree about Burns - he was an Ayrshire lad and would never have worn a kilt.
7

Iain fae Elgin,

London 16/01/2008 13:37:02
Rather have a suit than wear something that'll give you nylon burns in a matter of minutes.
8

James2122,

16/01/2008 13:48:55
They should be welcomed at £20 a pop as kilts have been way overpriced for ages. It's become awfy fashionable in the last 10 or 20 years to wear kilts at weddings, stag nights, plain old nights out and parties. It wasn't always this way I'm sure.
And ... bagpipes all over the place, aggressive beggars.
The best way to play the pipes is wi a pen-knife.
9

,

16/01/2008 14:08:27
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

brettgallacher,

edinburgh 16/01/2008 14:09:21
james this isnt about price this is about our heritage
11

shuggery mcvinchi,

edinburgh 16/01/2008 14:11:21
why are you all getting your kilts in a twist?
do you honestly believe that everything in your wardrobes
is made in Scotland? do me a favor stop moaning, go upstairs, and take a deek at your stuff, and see how much of it is made in the uk, and how much of it was made abroad? lets just face the facts that the u.k is too expensive to manufacture goods in.
if you dont want to buy a cheap kilt, DONT BUY ONE!!!
theres always going to be "the cheaper option"
12

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

16/01/2008 14:17:17
brett, it seems to me you have only some kind of fairytale story of "our" heritage (are you a lowland scot ? Its not your heritage mate).

I would suggest taking the big stick out your ass and allow people to do business in a capitalist society.

If people dont want them , they wont sell.

If the do , they will.
13

shuggery mcvinchi,

edinburgh 16/01/2008 14:17:51
comment number 9.... if your so proud of being scottish brett......why dont you open your own shop and do your self a favour...and as for your comment obout mohammod,
(did you even go to religious education at school?)
the guys that own the shops are sikhs! hahaha and they wer born in edinburgh so double hahaha for you mate
14

shuggery mcvinchi,

edinburgh 16/01/2008 14:18:53
nice comment number 12;-)
15

billyboy08,

kirkcaldy 16/01/2008 14:36:58
I have not got £400 for a kilt outfit, I was going to Lidl to get mine but if the Gold Brothers are doing it cheaper im going there for mine.
16

Walleroonie,

Edinburgh 16/01/2008 15:03:05
I'm English and am really hoping Lydell's will start flogging a cut price Morris Dancing outfit so I can wear it on nights out too - for too long have I been deprived of a national dress because the Beefeaters and Morris dancers want the monopoly all to themselves.

Leprechaun anyone?
17

JulesF,

16/01/2008 15:10:55
All you need to go morris dancing is a handkerchief, a pair of shorts and a balloon, hardly the same league as a kilt !
18

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

16/01/2008 15:31:00
16. Lydells must be the english version of Lidl it sounds quite upmarket

;)
19

alex patersons English teacher,

16/01/2008 15:43:45
18.
thats a a black dermarcation against you.
20

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

16/01/2008 15:44:31
19 You be quiet.
21

my opinion,

Edinburgh 16/01/2008 15:46:19
You get what you pay for at the end of the day.
So for £20 you will get tat,cheap and nasty,trash do I need to go on !
Some of the kilts are not even proper tatans,just cause the colours look good ! How bad is that !
It would only be cheapo neds buying this tat anyway.
22

Black Five,

edinburgh 16/01/2008 16:07:59
21 you`ve just said what I was going to say to.What the heck can you expect for that price?A load of tat.Better sticking your £20 on the fav.First race any track.
23

Couch Correspondent,

Livingroom 16/01/2008 16:18:13
Whats wrong with choice? Doen't matter if it is cheap tat, people know what they are paying for - if it's in demand it'll sell.
24

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

16/01/2008 16:34:52
"- if it's in demand it'll sell."

Well fiddle me sideways, you've just won The Adam Smith award for 2008.
25

Gothic Rose,

16/01/2008 16:36:35
16,18,19&20# HYSTERICAL!:)xxx
26

Franck,

16/01/2008 16:44:44
BrettGallacher #9

If you dressed a bear up and called it Mohammed you would definately get jailed!!
27

11,

Tranent 16/01/2008 16:59:15
I agree with #5.

Kilts are a specific type of traditionally made garment and there should be more regulation of what can be called a kilt and what (i.e Gold Bro's tat) cannot. The same kind of regulation applies to traditional crockery and certain types of artwork, and genuine kilts are artwork and should be protected as such.
28

Duncan in Edinburgh,

16/01/2008 17:39:46
#26 But you would at least be making a prophet.
29

Proximo,

16/01/2008 17:42:40
So is that the correct job title for one who just measures the kilts - an Assistant Belen?
30

Who let the dogs out?,

edin 16/01/2008 18:32:12
I think this is a good thing, what kinda tourist is going to spend £1000 on a full kilt?

people wearing a kilt to a wedding are still going to go to tradional places.

and how can they charge £1000 for a full kitted out kilt

you can prob buy 2 gucci suits for that price
31

Jingsitsme,

EDINBURGH 16/01/2008 18:36:00
#2 Hamish - Agree totally

Just a publicity stunt from the gold brothers yet again!!! They don't have use the system.

It's dreadful to see their shops with all the tat of the day in it and its so called scottishness. They wouldn't know what being scottish is.
32

Who let the dogs out?,

16/01/2008 18:36:35
oh i have been informed that, the reason these tradional kiltmakers charge a fortune is because they are knitted by blind nuns from orkney
33

Jingsitsme,

EDINBURGH 16/01/2008 19:12:16
#32 you have your facts wrong. pay peanuts and you get peanuts.

Scottish kilts have value and your comments are stupid.

I stand by what I said in 31!
34

Jeannie with the lightbrown hair,

Glasgow (but a Currie lassie at heart) 16/01/2008 19:29:31
Oops no4! Never mind about cheap ilts - what about the 'i' before 'e' rule EXCEPT after 'c'! ut! Tut!
35

is it me?,

16/01/2008 20:31:08
Oops no 34. What about the 'k' before 'ilts'. Tut.
36

joppa jock,

Huntingdon 16/01/2008 20:48:56
#3 Is absolutely right. Burns was dead for over 200 years before kilts became popular in the lowlands and they have nothing to do with the heritage of the vast majority of Scots. Before 1970 only the landed gentry got married in kilts, the hoi poloi were in suits or claw-hammer coats. However, for a man a kilt can be a good investment nowadays as it the accepted wear at virtually all dress functions. I'm not sure that one of the cheapos would be long lasting, plus the kilt is only the start of the outfit, you still have to jacket, shoes, socks, sporan, wee bread knife, etc..
37

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 16/01/2008 22:17:32
DOES.GOLD.BROTHERS.SELL.TEDDY.BEARS.TO.FROM.CHINA
38

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 16/01/2008 22:18:05
*Please enter your comment*
39

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 16/01/2008 22:26:17
*Please enter your comment*
40

Geronimo (1829–1909) wiz there on 26 April 1902,

16/01/2008 23:17:26
why is it cheaper to buy a kilt than it is to pay at the gate at an SPL match?
41

urban poacher,

Edinburgh 17/01/2008 00:05:29
is it going to be acceptable to wear the kilt on the trams they pass LIDL in Leith.
42

,

17/01/2008 00:34:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
43

Duncan in Edinburgh,

17/01/2008 08:48:57
#42 Good question! I suspect the councillor in question took a dislike to the idiots making silly remarks about him. Still, it's interesting to see what seems to be more stories getting this treatment from Johnston Press in comparison to what used to happen under the mad Barclays. But individual message deletions are more rare. Och well, it's their ball and they decide who gets to play with it...
44

earnabob,

17/01/2008 11:35:57
For all of you that think tartan equals clan read this

http://www.scotshistoryonline.co.uk/tartan-history.html

The modern kilt style and patterns were all made up after the subjugation of our heritage and not in any way based on tradition.

Wear a kilt if you must but stop harping on about your heritage.
If you want to wear traditional scottish dress check which part of it your family is from - see what plants that grow in the area can be used for dye and have a lovely big blanket of tartan made to those colours then get lessons in how to turn it into a kilt by folding it up correctly.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Do you think selling kilts for £19.99 is undermining our national identity
Yes, they are cheap and nasty looking
Perhaps, but if people don’t want them they won’t sell
No, and if they sell well they will boost national identity

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.