Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Thursday, 15th May 2008 Change Date

Evening News / Sony Centre Reverse Auction

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Rich and poor gulf in Edinburgh 'smoking map'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 07 April 2008
ALMOST half of residents in some of Edinburgh's most deprived areas are addicted to cigarettes, compared to fewer than one-in-ten elsewhere in the city.
A new "smoking map" today highlights the huge gulf in smoking rates between Edinburgh's poorer and more affluent communities.

View "smoking map" of city

The r
eport, compiled by NHS Lothian, sparked calls for communities like Muirhouse and Niddrie to get more services to help people kick the habit.

Experts believe there are a number of reasons why smoking is more common in deprived areas, including boredom linked to unemployment and a lack of easy access to information on giving up.

High levels of smoking also go hand-in-hand with heavy drinking and drug abuse.

Sheila Duffy, chief executive of ASH Scotland, said: "The fact is, cigarettes are available on every street corner.

"We want smoking cessation services to be the same. Evidence-based advice and nicotine replacement therapy can quadruple your chance to quit.

"But these have to be readily available to people."

Today's report highlights Muirhouse as Edinburgh's smoking blackspot, where almost one-in-two residents are smokers. In comparison, fewer than one-in-ten in Murrayfield and Ravelston admit to the habit.

A total of 43.8 per cent of people in Greendykes and Niddrie Mains smoke, compared to just 10.3 per cent in Fairmilehead.

Prestonpans, Mayfield and Whitburn Central, have the highest level of smokers in East, Mid and West Lothian respectively.

Experts say that, while teenagers in affluent areas are just as likely to try smoking as those in deprived ones, they are far more likely to give up by the time they become adults.

And habits are often passed on from parents to children.

Councillor Allan Jackson, who represents the Forth ward, which includes Muirhouse, admitted he was shocked at the prevalence of smoking in his area.

"I used to smoke myself, but I stopped in 1984," he said. "Cigarettes don't do anyone any good, full stop, and anything that can be done to encourage people to stop, so much the better."

"If extra resources have to be targeted or diverted then so be it."

Helena Connelly, stop smoking co-ordinator at NHS Lothian, said the health board was committed to helping people give up.

"We have a team of stop smoking advisers who tailor support to meet individual needs.

"These include open access clinics, where people can call in without an appointment, in community centres, social clubs and local health centres.

"We have also trained several dozen community pharmacists to provide one-to-one stop smoking support. By the end of the month, 93 pharmacy outlets will be providing a nicotine replacement therapy service."

www.nhslothian.scot.nhs.uk
www.ashscotland.org.uk








The full article contains 468 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 April 2008 2:08 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Tobacco
 
1

Urban Guerrilla,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 12:04:09
Pompous nonsense. People smoke for the same reason as they drink or take drugs - to make their dreary lives a bit more bearable. Why shouldn't they?
2

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

07/04/2008 12:25:08
Come off it Gareth, this has been known for decades.
3

familymanwith2jobsandawifeworkingfulltime,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 12:50:51
The people in these areas are the only ones who can afford to smoke these days. If you are trying your damdest to get on in life, there is little left for cigarettes by the time you pay the mortgage, utility bills, council tax (or worse - local income tax)etc. etc.
4

Mr H 2u,

Embra 07/04/2008 12:59:47
No! The next thing they'll be telling us that poor people drink more, and have worse diets. Perhaps an investigation into whether it snows more in colder parts of the world might be in order.
5

Ian Ross,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 13:06:32
This report isn't worth the money it cost to produce. I am sure there are lots of things the money could have been better spent on. Can't we give smoking a rest - folk smoke because they want to. Comment No 3 - good for you, having 2 jobs etc. Pity you haven't got a life though.
6

AndrewS,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 13:53:10
Smokers and ignorance go together. Maybe reading too since the evidence that smoking is harmful to health has been written about for years,
7

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

07/04/2008 13:55:02
perhaps we should give number 3 a medal.

I have one job which i do in a quarter assed fashion .

It pays remarkably well , extremely well. I laugh at people on the apprentice selling their soul for 60k after tax.
8

Embra boy,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 14:07:08
#7 Do you work from home, or from a massage parlour?
9

Johnny Yen,

07/04/2008 14:11:09
Darwin would be proud. Its natural selection at its best.
10

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

07/04/2008 14:16:08
I have a massage parlour in one of my many homes.
11

blackley,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 15:03:47
I could have told them all that and thrown in some convincing stats too.
Obviously we need to get people in the better areas to smoke more so things can be fairer.
12

Darren :-),

Edin city but on ma way to ibrox 07/04/2008 15:10:41
Gereth rose - the worst journo award goes to him!
13

TheTerminator,

07/04/2008 15:26:20
http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/business/pqa/wa-07/wa0719.htm#27 ...... This is how much the Anti-Smoking vendetta is costing the taxpayer.
14

cheeses_of_nazareth,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 17:43:14
Does 'almost half' mean the same as 'less than half'?
15

Bill Crombie,

07/04/2008 18:27:23
More studies on socialogical patterns from the university of the bleedy obvious. This constant attack on smokers is becoming, to say the least, tedious in the extreme. It smacks of people, like Shiela McDuff, trying to justify their £50k plus plus salary to further wage war and persecution against a sizeable minority. Come the revolution, her sort will be shown the door along with all the other unelected, unaccountable quangoes and jobsworths draining the UK of its tax dollar (pounds really, but it sounds better)
16

happyhibbie,

The Inch, Edinburgh 07/04/2008 19:20:15
Used to smoke like a chimney and still drink like a fish.

The killjoys priced me out of the smoking market and I'm sure they're going to have a good try at doing the same with the bevy.

If they succeed I'm sure I'll find some cheaper replacement for these wonderful vices to stop me becoming as miserable as these lousy legislators.
17

DeniseX,

London 07/04/2008 19:34:46
Sheila Duffy, chief executive of ASH Scotland, said: "The fact is, cigarettes are available on every street corner'. Another exaggeration by ASH.

"We want smoking cessation services to be the same. Evidence-based advice and nicotine replacement therapy can quadruple your chance to quit'. Another advertisement by ASH for pharmaceutical companies that fund them.
18

Paloma negra,

07/04/2008 19:41:41
Britain is the most expensive country in Europe to smoke ... the greedy government takes so much tax (which makes up the bulk of the price of a packet)
19

TheTerminator,

07/04/2008 19:44:25
ASH Scotland and the smoking cessation organisations are parasites living off taxpayers money.
20

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 20:25:24
SMOKING MAP!!, HOW RIDICULOUS!!!

How about the Next Map!..'FATTY MAP'!,?

How about the Next Map!..'ALCHOL MAP'!,?

How about the Next Map!..'YOU GOT A HORRIBLE FACE MAP'!?

'AYE' Its 'Noddy-Town'..right enough!.. :-DDDDDDDD
21

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 20:32:06
re:

How about the Next Map!..'ALCOHOL MAP'!,?
22

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 20:37:58
Your eyes they follow my every move
You make me nervous can't you see I'm not in love with you
I touch your label you take it as the opposite
I tried to tell you
I see no future in this
No future in this

We dance together you got me for tonight
Forget we ever made it in daylight
I only told you, you got it all mapped out
It's too much too soon
Let's dance just for tonight

We dance together you got me for tonight
Forget we ever made it in daylight
I only told you, you got it all mapped out
You got it all mapped out
You got it all mapped out
23

AndrewS,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 20:55:14
#19 Is somebody forcing you to stay here ? In a few years you'll be a drain on the NHS with ling and liver disease, so go to anothewr country with the resources to look after you or the good sense to kill you off quickly.
24

Finbarr Saunders,

07/04/2008 21:01:34
#21 - Charles Linskaill- "How about the Next Map!..'FATTY MAP'!,?

How about the Next Map!..'ALCHOL MAP'!,?

How about the Next Map!..'YOU GOT A HORRIBLE FACE MAP'!?"

They've already produced them. They're the same as the smoking map.
25

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 21:08:13
Finbarr Saunders @#25,

Very good ;-) , I liked that one!

'Good Wit'
26

David from New Mills,

Contourless Pleasantville, U.K. 07/04/2008 21:32:11
#26, Charles Linskaill,Edinburgh.
If CL enjoyed that, how about the Edinburgh idiot map? Could be illuminating.
27

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 21:42:37
David from New Mills, @#27,

That's one I didn't think of, 'Very Good'!

That would be the,...'D'oh-D'oh-D'Oh',.. Map! :-D
28

David from New Mills,

Bright and sparkling Pleasantville, U.K.. 07/04/2008 21:46:32
#28,Charles Linskaill,Edinburgh.
Would Charles care to the honours, and colour it in?
29

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 21:52:33
David from New Mills, #29,,

Lend me your crayon's!
30

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 21:53:21
Oops!.... 'PLEASE'
31

David from New Mills,

Colourful Pleasantville, U.K 07/04/2008 21:56:34
#30, artistic Charles Linskaill,Edinburgh.
Sorry, but Charles has to find his own canvas, drawing materials and loopy characters. Shouldn't be too difficult?
32

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 22:19:12
#32,

"Charles has to find his own canvas, drawing materials and loopy characters"

D'oh! how do I do that,?

The only 'Loop-de-Lop' I know is on these threads everyday, pestering me, is,,,

His Name,?........'Boy Wonder'!
























33

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 22:22:51
That Space was NOT meant to happen,.. 'Honest'!!

Maybe the EEN was getting ambitious and saved it for,

'THE MAP'!!
34

David from New Mills,

Sane Pleasantville, U.K. 07/04/2008 22:30:16
#33/34,Charles Linskaill,Edinburgh.
CL needn't bother. I think we all get the picture only too clearly.
35

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 22:35:17
Well suit yourself David!, but the offer was there!

:-D
36

David from New Mills,

Pleasantville, U.K. 07/04/2008 22:52:16
#36,Charles Linskaill,Edinburgh.
So, where was the offer? CL can't keep his keyboard skills in order, let alone his palette.
37

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 22:54:44
Think, for Gods think! Do not give credence to this bunkum a life is as full as YOU make it - doesn't matter if you smoke or drink just enjoy your time on this planet! Alexander the great made a difference before the age of 35 and Charlton Heston made a difference at 84 - think not of how long you will live - think only only of how you can make a difference .... live long and prosper, people - let not your politicians dictate your lifestyle if you are are happy with what you do ....

If you smoke you will probably cut your life short -- but you have have maybe enjoyed it, for small mercies, a little better than the PC/killjoy brigade !!! -- Isn't that a better epitaph than a long miserable life ??

Oh, how we danced, murmuring low for a kingship so high .... just enjoy life don't get too caught up in the $h1t that the government tells ... they are liars, obstructors and fools ...
38

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/04/2008 23:03:20
David @#37,..'The cheeky Monkey'!..but thats ok!

Voldemort @#38,..'Well-Said'!
39

Singlepoint,

Fife 07/04/2008 23:19:45
As regards health, smoking damages it and that’s a fact and would be a fact independently of NHS Lothian or ASH or any other bizzy. When the multi-trinket, max-factored, subversive Sheila Duffy of ASH says this, “The fact is, cigarettes are available on every street corner … and habits are often passed on from parents to children”, she means ‘those low-life nicotine druggies are child-abusers and need punished’. There is always some or other demonization: some or other dehumanisation; that precedes the taking away of a right. Currently, the move via SNP minister, Christine Grahame, is to licence the sale of tobacco products of course under the guise of protecting children and she foolishly states so at the same time as she is aware that the long licensing of alcohol has not stopped and does not at all stop underage drinking and per se never will. Revealingly, ASH also says this, “It’s important we don’t take our foot off the accelerator”, which is to say, the move is to by hook or by crook ban smokers from having the choice which thing is not democracy but tyranny. When it is done the any current little corporals will come for something else and eventually they’ll come for you. The astonishing aspect is that that those women should be ashamed of themselves not least because they would not have the vote but for such as Emmeline who suffered much to gain them that right, which is to say, she would not have fought to remove any right, which is to say, people who have been long discriminated against would not on becoming free then start discriminating. Similarly, those women are highly educated, and indeed from a time when a degree meant what it said, but yet they would not know how to cut a hole in an A4 sheet of paper big enough for a horse to walk right through and nor would they know how they would be able to open a tin of beans with a £10 pound note, which, latterly, would be answered by the average poor housewife in the average poor neighbourhood. The form
40

Singlepoint,

Fife 07/04/2008 23:20:20
The former would most easily be answered by such as artists/designers which talents are of course more found in those from a ‘working class’ background. They would also not know many other rational, ordinary matters that ordinary people easily understand. It is all to say that despite the any learning, the idiot forever appears and or forever rules one way or the other in one form or the other.
41

D Fiasco,

Walkerburn 08/04/2008 09:15:59
It's the same old story - go to so-called 'rich' areas and you'll see nice cafes, fancy restaurants and shopping concourses. Go to a comparable 'poor' area and all you'll see are seedy newsagents and off-licence shops. To combat this, we must look at regeneration and new addictions, not existing - children begin smoking at a very early age these days (I've seen some as young as 10) - remove the accesibility, enforce the law and provide something for children to do other than get drunk and smoke and you will see a change for the better. This is the joint responsibility of us all - rich or poor.
42

Big Eddie,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 11:51:24
There's a staggering level of complacency being displayed here: Yeah, we know that poor people smoke more and are more unhealthy and die younger ... so what?

Scotland's record of ill health, of which smoking is a very significant contributory factor, is a millstone round the nation's neck. It damages our economy, our society and our environment. Crucially, it erodes our sense of national well-being, our confidence in ourselves.

People must have the right to smoke, to drink, to eat fatty food. But we need to work out why people choose to indulge so excessively in such self-destructive habits, why they have such a fatalistic outlook, why there is so little confidence among poor communities.

Simply accepting the situation - as most of the posters above seem to - does no-one any favours at all. If we want Scotland to be a successful, forward looking, healthy nation, we can't bury our heads in the sand and say: Who cares?
43

Stef,

Bandera, Tx, formerly Edinburgh. 12/04/2008 03:08:51
#27 David,
If we were to create an idiot map of Newmills I can think of one hot spot off the temperature scale. Sheila Duffy and her breed would blow up any thermometer. She and her corrupt crew have burned up the values of all sense and decency and anything she says, simply dismissed as just more of the ASH conspiracy, useless and worthless beings lining their own pockets whilst they produce and generate hatred and disharmony.
44

Stef,

Bandera, Tx, formerly Edinburgh. 12/04/2008 03:15:30
I ask all to dismiss this article as unadulterated rubbish and just another example of the dirty ASH conspiracy.
Vote out Fuhrer Brown and all his low life followers at the first opportunity and re-introduce tolerance and freedom of choice. This is an evil regime.
45

Stef,

Bandera, Tx, formerly Edinburgh. 12/04/2008 03:20:54
#20 The Terminator
1000% SPOT ON, you could not be more correct or precise.
Get rid of these worthless ASH parasites.
46

David from New Mills,

Cosy Pleasantville, U.K. 12/04/2008 12:07:52
#44,stef, no longer of Edinburgh..
Happy map plotting to Stefano. How's his hatred and disharmony doing in the hot Texas sun? Try soaking up another Bud!
47

David from New Mills,

Enfranchised Pleasantville, U.K. 12/04/2008 12:09:38
#45,stef, no longer of Edinburgh.
So has stef no postal vote, then?
48

Stef,

Bandera, Tx, formerly Edinburgh. 13/04/2008 00:52:22
#48 David,
You will be most pleased to hear that I shall be returning to Edinburgh very soon, I might do a stop at Peasantville and enjoy a sweet cigarette in all of the three pubs in your sweet wee hamlet, if indeed they still remain, I am sure they will be pleased to accept all my unspent $$$$$$'s, certainly they can not rely or likely to survive on your custom.
49

David from New Mills,

Sweet Pleasantville, U.K. 13/04/2008 11:30:08
#49, Stef the Terrible.
I'm really quite indifferent to wee stef's movements, but I'm sure the good citizens of Edinburgh appreciate the warning. In the meantime, I shall keep my nose and ears peeled for any sign of danger on the home front.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.