Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Monday, 13th October 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Lib Dem leader calls on SNP for help to dump council tax



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 01 March 2008
LIBERAL Democrat leader Nicol Stephen today called on the SNP government to work with him to dump the council tax.
The Lib Dems are the only other major party at Holyrood that supports introducing a local income tax and their support would be crucial to getting it approved by the Scottish Parliament.

But Mr Steven says his party has so far had no approach from
ministers. He challenged Alex Salmond: "If you seriously want to do this, pick up the phone."

Mr Salmond has said the government would publish a consultation paper on local income tax "very soon".

Supporters of a local income tax claim it would leave the majority of Scots better off, but opponents say many couples where both partners are working would end up paying more.

The SNP and Liberal Democrats differ on how the tax would work. The SNP wants the tax level set centrally and has calculated it would be around 3p extra across the country. The Lib Dems say each local authority should be left to set its own tax level.

But a Lib Dem source said the differences were "not necessarily insurmountable". Mr Steven was also using his speech at the Scottish Liberal Democrat Conference in Aviemore to announce that he is recalling the Steel Commission – the party's internal review on more powers for Holyrood – following the "confusion" created over the issue by Gordon Brown.

Mr Brown first appeared to undermine Scottish Labour leader Wendy Alexander's initiative to set up a cross-party Scottish Constitutional Commission to consider further devolution by wanting it to be downgraded to a "review" or a "working group".

Then he backed more power for Holyrood but said other powers could be taken back by Westminster. Mr Steven was due to tell delegates at Aviemore: "Gordon Brown rambling about removing powers does not help. This new challenge needs leadership and direction, not distraction."

The commission has already agreed Holyrood should have more tax powers, but now Sir David and his colleagues will be asked to come up with more definite proposals about exactly which taxes should be transferred to the Scottish Parliament.

Meanwhile, former Edinburgh councillor Sue Tritton complained controversial motions had been kept off the agenda. One which she and others had put forward, urging a rethink on the party's outright opposition to nuclear power had not been selected for discussion.

She said: "We were told it was not being allowed because the issue had been debated within the last two years – but a lot has changed in the last two years."

A party spokesman said the issues debated were all on areas where the party needed to develop its policy.





The full article contains 455 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 March 2008 10:37 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Council tax
 
1

Hamish Scott,

01/03/2008 13:41:57
Is Nicol Stephen taking the proverbial? He refused to even discuss a coalition with the SNP after the May elections and now he wants Alex Salmond to discuss joint policy making.
2

alex paterson,

embra 01/03/2008 14:16:05
Nicol Stephen should have a red nose, a bowler hat and baggy trousers,and it would be for his work,as a circus clown.
3

walter,

01/03/2008 14:20:49
I would rather a household income tax, that way the income coming into the house no matter where it comes from or who is bringing it in (as long as they are between the age of 16 or 19 if in full time education and 65) will be calculated.
1p in every pound over a set amount and all pay.
Those over 65 will be calculated differently.

4

I'mallymax,

Orwell's diary. 01/03/2008 16:59:08
This is the McLib's trying to do a Bliar and run up the SNP flag; everybody knows this ploy now. Just because you copy a popular policy doesn't mean you agree with it, or know how to implement it! How long before the McLib's introduce a grading system on a local rates system that is just as unfair as the council tax system?

Nicoll Stephen, what a plonker. Get your own policies; you don't understand what the Scottish people want so you try and steal our Scottish government's policies!

Support and Vote SNP for a better,
fairer independent Scotland.
5

Jwil,

01/03/2008 17:13:32
"LIBERAL Democrat leader Nicol Stephen today called on the SNP government to work with him to dump the council tax."

An unbelievable statement from Nicol Stephen. After opting-out for nearly a year he wants to jump back on the bandwagon. If he wants to join forces with the SNP on this he should be going to Alex Salmond to ask him if its ok; not 'inviting the SNP' to join him. He will then claim the credit for it as 'his' initiative when the SNP have been working on it since they came into power.

I think Clegg must be stirring things up with the Scottish Liberals!

I can't wait to hear the SNP reaction to this. Perhaps it will come at FM's questions this coming week.

THe title to this article is nearer the truth.

"Lib Dem leader calls on SNP for help"


6

Moscow Central 42,

01/03/2008 18:15:32

2 alex paterson

I think that is a bit unfair to circus clowns. After all it could be argued that they make a much more valuable contribution to society than Nicol Stephen and the Scottish Liberal Democrats.
7

Amparo de Glasgow,

01/03/2008 19:52:57
I actually like Nick Clegg.
He is an intelligent bloke.

He speaks 5 languages !!!!
This is amazing
... unlike most of the Tartan Tory
... hoochter Teuchter
... racist eejits who frequent oan these here strands
... wae aw there styooo-pit
... "Braveheart" pish-cat
... keech-van-der-Reeech


Like me ...
... Clegg is an atheist.

He speaks Spanish (as well as being married to one)
Muy bien Nick.

Un hombre ingles intelligente ...
Maravillosa
8

Rossmcl,

01/03/2008 20:57:31
Time for a few facts of life for the cybernats. I know you don't like facing reality but the SNP is a MINORITY administration. That means they can't get anything done without help from another party. Hence their pact with the Greens, and hence they needed Tory support to get their budget through and LibDem support on the student funding vote last week. They NEED help from other parties. OK? Read the article again in that context and you will see there is actually an opportunity here. Or are you more interested in hurling pointless abuse around than you are in actully implementing your party's policies?
9

Amparo de Glasgow,

01/03/2008 21:05:21
#8
Rossmcl ...

Ach
... jings
... crivvens
... help ma stereotypical
... Tartan Tory (called Boab)

wee Eck and
... Sturgeon-bot Stepford Wife Version 4.001
... huvnae goat a 'Scooby'

... Shut doon Uncle Tom's Cabin.

Hollyrood ...
... was the biggest scam
... Blair ever hood-winked us Scottish with.
10

Julian,

EDINBURGH 02/03/2008 00:19:21
#4 I'mallymax

I'm slightly confused but I'll give you a chance to esplain yourself. What policy is Nicol Stephen trying to steal from the SNP? Surely you don't mean local income tax as this has been Lib Dem policy for 20 years.
11

Joe M.,

Edinburgh 02/03/2008 02:55:58
He can start by getting his UK boss to talk to Gordon Brown about Labour's anti democratic plans to lop 450M of the Scottish budget. That's if there is any truth to that 'story' or whether the Scotland on Sunday has just made it up (it wouldn't be the first time).

what about the concept of the Sovereignty of the Scottish people? Do the Lib Dems support that? Is the Claim of Right a distant memory? It certainly sounds like it when they act to deny the people a democratic vote on independence.
12

Joe M.,

Edinburgh 02/03/2008 03:00:34
#4

Both the SNP and Lib Dems have supported LIT for years. The LD's used to also support the Scottish peoples rights to self determination but now they have new found shiny unionist 'principles' which can be summed up by the motto 'London knows best'.
13

Joe M.,

Edinburgh 02/03/2008 03:05:38
Come on Lib Dems do you support this attack on the Scots rights to choose their own policies and Government?

http://news.scotsman.com/counciltax/Salmond-tax-plan-in-tatters.3834253.jp

The fact is the UK Government is basically anti Scottish and if you line up with them then guess what, you'll be tied to the same dead weight which pulled the Tories into electoral oblivion during the Thatcher years. Reject the basic right of Scots to rule Scotland and they'll reject you - at the ballot box.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.