Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Saturday, 7th November 2009 Change Date

Tory leader survives coup attempt by one vote - his own

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 29 April 2009
EDINBURGH'S Tory leader Iain Whyte has survived a coup attempt from within his own party – by voting for himself.
The Conservative's education spokesman Jeremy Balfour challenged Councillor Whyte for the leadership role at the party's AGM yesterday.

Councillor Whyte won a vote from the party's 11 city councillors 6-5, but both candidates were allowed to vote for themselves under the election rules.

The police board convener, who has led the Edinburgh branch of the party since 2002, saw off talk of a leadership contest last year but has been under pressure since the party slipped to fourth place in the last local elections.

Party insiders today told the Evening News that many councillors were unhappy with Cllr Whyte's leadership style and the party's under-performance in recent years.

Elected to the Murrayfield seat in 2005, Cllr Balfour is seen as one of the party's rising stars along with other relatively new councillors Jason Rust, Gordon Buchan and Cameron Rose.

Group chairman Allan Jackson today called for unity among party members, while Cllr Balfour said he now fully backed his group leader despite losing the vote.

However, one party insider, said: "People are unhappy with Iain's leadership style and that is why it was so close.

"We are clearly underperforming and the fact that he didn't get anything like a clear majority tells you everything.

"It needed a fresh approach but we are where we are and we will all need to get on with it."

Following its AGM, the party has created a new weekly "policy" team – which will include councillors Balfour and Whyte – that will determine its short and long-term political strategies.

Cllr Whyte said: "Jeremy and I are on friendly terms and I believe I have his full support, this was not anything personal.

"We now have to concentrate on the matter in hand and increasing our visibility across the city.

"The Conservative group is full of ideas as to how our city could be run better.

"We also have a strong team of leaders in many fields who could show the current council administration a thing or two about how you take on an issue and persuade the public of your case.

"We are going to develop that team in the coming weeks and months to show the administration's failings and prove how we could have a more efficient and effective council in these difficult financial times."

Councillor Balfour said: "There was an election contest but Councillor Whyte and the party knows he has my full backing."

The latest development for the city's Tory party is a far cry from its heyday in the 1980s. In the 1982 Lothian elections, Labour and the Tories won exactly the same number of seats and the Tories, led by the late Brian Meek, formed a coalition with Donald Gorrie's Liberals to run the council.

But Labour won again in 1986 and kept control at the City Chambers until 2007 when the Lib Dem/SNP administration took over.

Cllr Jackson added: "It is now time for the group to use the talents of all our members to increase support for the Conservatives."


The full article contains 533 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 11:58:47
Jeremy Balfour is a right-wing evangelical Christian who seeks to impose his religious views on others. That the Tories were one vote away from electing him leader says a great deal about the supposedly "nice" Cameron Tories.
2

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 29/04/2009 12:12:10
Ian Whyte only a face a mother could love,bet he never got her vote.
3

familymanwith2jobsandawifeworkingfulltime,

Edinburgh 29/04/2009 12:38:35
I am a Tory man, but this Iain Whyte is a dangerous individual, with no thought for anything bar his own political beliefs. I have had dealings with him previously and the only thing I can say about the man is its people like him who start wars.
4

Utar Refson,

Embra 29/04/2009 12:40:30
Duncan: If you knew *anything* about Evangelical Christianity rather than relying on prejudice, you'd know that persuasion rather than imposition is central to the belief system. Knowing Jeremy as I do, he's an asset to the Corstorphine/Murrayfield constuency.
5

Christopher André Breton Morris ,

29/04/2009 12:55:26
Has this man been in a fire ? Luckily he has the voice of an Angel.
6

scotsol,

Edinburgh 29/04/2009 13:13:50
#4 - And does Balfour try to "persuade" other councillors not to vote for equal opportunity measures for, eg, the gay community and single parents?
7

Wullie Smith ,

Embra 29/04/2009 13:20:22
Iain Whyte has cost the Conservatives dearly in this City , I and a considerable number of other " natural tory voters " have stopped voting Conservative following his support for the Tram Scheme , which I gather is not backed by most of the other councillors , and indeed trams are publically slated by David McLetchie .
For the moment the party must limp on it seems with this lame duck , out of touch with his voters , "leader "


As long as Whyte continues to force the local conservative councillors to support the trams I and others will stay at home on polling days ( couldn't bring ourselves to vote SNP even tho they're the only party to oppose the trams .
8

Spock,

Edinburgh 29/04/2009 13:23:53
Ian Whyte being voted in again is indeed a sad day for the Edinburgh Tories. Those who voted for him need to stop considering their own inflated egos and start getting some work done.
9

,

29/04/2009 13:25:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

Holyrood Watcher,

Edinburgh 29/04/2009 13:31:11
Surely Balfour voted for himself also so the result would have still went in favour of Whyte had the two candidates not been allowed to vote. What a silly piece.
11

NorT,

Edinburgh 29/04/2009 13:32:17
#3 and #8 I totally agree with you. Having been involved on a couple of committees (non political)where he was a member I would not trust him as far as I could throw him. He would stab you in the back in his own self interest. The Tory's don't get my vote as long as he is in charge.
12

Bill MacD,

29/04/2009 13:34:48
He's a hatemongering bigot. Keep fundamentalists out of politics with their evil efforts to impose their ideology on everyone else. These christian fantatics are dangerous to a free society.
13

I love to eat Sellotape,

29/04/2009 14:10:50
If you look carefully at his picture, you'll notice that his cheeks puff out quite a bit. That's because he stores nuts and berries in there, which he regurgitates to his children when he gets home. Quite clever, for a Tory.
14

elayne,

29/04/2009 14:12:20
#13,he looks more like one of those puffer fish
15

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 14:20:40
#4 I don't need to generalise about evangelical Christianity to know how Jeremy Balfour operates. I have met with him on several occasions, fought with him in several parliamentary battles, and dealt with the aftermath of the lying, shameless propaganda he has spread on behalf of "Christian" organisations more often than I care to remember.

He's an asset to anyone who wants to oppress gay people, or subvert parliamentary process by injecting falsehoods into committee evidence. A real asset.
16

Foo,

29/04/2009 14:27:44
12 Bill MacD

Quick question. Do you also hate Muslims in the same way you hate Christians?
17

Cheradenine,

Edinburgh 29/04/2009 15:01:27
#12 But as dangerous as excluding a massive section of society from the democratic process?

18

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 29/04/2009 15:15:52
Strewth,have you seen the full photo,he must have his own cobbler,my God never seen feet so big,nah must be camera enhanched.
19

Leila,

Edinburgh 29/04/2009 15:16:44
The Conservative group on the Council keeps such a low profile as to be almost invisible. They don't seem to even want to raise their profile which is inexplicable when the popularity of Conservative party nationally is increasing.

They could have joined forces with the SNP and opposed the tram scheme or at least insisted on a more rigorous examination of its business case, but their enforced support for the trams despite individual councillors expressing doubts or even opposition to the scheme is astonishing.
20

Hearts Daft,

Musselburgh 29/04/2009 16:07:24
The Tories are increasingly irrelevant in Scotland and will continue to decline as they are perceived as an anti - Scottish party who have little to offer modern Scotland.
21

calum,

29/04/2009 16:42:55
Duncan in Edinburgh - Are you sure that your view on religion is not tinged with bias? You have posted a number of anti-religious posts over the last while which seem to generalise about those who have religious beliefs. I have a number of friends who have found their faith to be a great comfort to them when they are in times of stress or anxiety.
I am not religious myself but one would almsot think that you were theophobic.
As for Iain Whyte, at least he is a better Convenor of the Police Board that the last ones - Hinds and Milligan. Particularly Milligan who was only in it for what he could gain personally. The sight of him being piped all over Paris 2 years ago for 4 days by the Police Pipe Band was boakworthy.
Personaaly, I believe Kate MacKenzie is the best of the Tory Councillors, at least she sticks to principles.
22

Incandescent,

29/04/2009 17:33:34
#15 Duncan

So now you're giving evidence before parliamentary committees? Oh, this is absolutely priceless.
23

Incandescent,

29/04/2009 17:33:52
#16 Foo

Bill McD is Jenny.
24

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 17:36:53
#21 I posted specifically about Jeremy Balfour. If Christians don't want to be associated with right-wing fundamentalism they should vociferously oppose it. Instead, Christian leaders either support it, or say nothing. I'll give credit where it's due - the Church of Scotland has a number of prominent leaders who have been vocal in their criticism of right-wing fundamentalism, and the Episcopalians also have some leaders who have been clear about their opposition to those ideals. But many other Christian leaders are either explicitly or implicitly complicit in right-wing hate speech and lies and distortions in the name of their god.

On this issue I attacked Jeremy Balfour personally, because I have personal experience of him. That's no generalisation.
25

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 17:37:59
#22 I have done, yes. I was involved in gay rights campaigns for many years. Is there something about that you find surprising, or are you just continuing to bait me for fun?
26

Incandescent,

29/04/2009 17:39:22
#25 Which committee?
27

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 29/04/2009 18:34:43
Duncan, I have absolutely no interest in your petulant foot-stamping; if you have nothing to add to the thread, why don't you Troll off to another one somewhere else. Like #7, Wullie, I consider myself a natural Conservative voter but, with 8 & 11, I agree the present rag-tag collection (except Kate McK) are a disgrace. Jason Rust, who pretends to represent me, refuses even to answer e-mails.
28

calum,

29/04/2009 18:54:03
#24 - Some Faiths are opposed to homosexuality and you have spoken out against them. I don't know Jeremy Balfour but you suggest that he is extreme in his views. Whether that is his style or his religious convictions I can only speculate but you most certainly have generalised about religion in the past.
In gay rights campaigns, for example, Tim Hopkins (who I have met on many occasions) comes across as a reasonable, articulate and educated man and his views on the issues seem worth listening to. However, in some posts on the subject, you have advocated positive discrimination, carrying on the war etc. etc. which some people might also view as extreme.
"Extreme" only depend on where you stand - I would suggest that Duncan and Jeremy might be at the far flung ends of "extreme".
TTFN, other things to do.
29

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 18:55:49
#26 The equal opportunities committee. Does it matter? I'm not going to be dragged into a long personal discussion about it. The point is I have first hand experience of Jeremy Balfour, and he would drag the Tories backward were he elected their leader in the city.
30

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 18:59:05
#28 Tim is a far better man than I, that is something I am happy to agree.

Whether I'm an extremist myself is questionable; I know of many more extreme people in the gay rights arena.

I think you're judging me personally on the basis of my postings here, which is pretty dubious, since this is the internet, where people don't behave as they do in real life.
31

calum,

29/04/2009 19:07:52
#30 - Tim has done more to take gay issues to the wider influencing community and into the daylight than anyone else I know and I judge him on what I have seen.
I don't know you other than through here - unless Duncan in Edinburgh is not your real name - so that is all there is to judge you on. And some people would judge you as extreme, like it or not. As you are well aware from your Diversity issues, whether YOU think you are extreme or not is not that important, it is how you are are perceived that is the yardstick and you are perceived to be extreme.
End of.
32

Howard Moon,

29/04/2009 19:16:35
I'm surprised that someone who has 'met with him on several occasions, fought with him in several parliamentary battles' feels the need to anonymously attack him on a newspaper forum.

Sad to see Whyte remain in charge. As others have posted, his leadership has been inept and his group's continued (albeit virtually silent) support for the trams is just about the most baffling political stance I have ever seen taken. I have never heard one tory councillor explain why they do, they just shrug and change the subject. Would love a proper journalist to get to the bottom of it.

This should be a fantastic time to be a tory in Edinburgh - even the old Labour diehards seem to have given up the fight (and their party) as a dead loss, plenty of folk are still worried about the potential consequences of independence and the Lib Dems have proven just as useless in the chambers as anyone could have feared. And yet they are going absolutely nowhere. Not sure about Balfour as leader (would have thought Buchan or Rose would do a better job) but at least he had the guts to stand up and try and do something about it.
33

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 19:16:50
#31 "End of."? Is that meant to stop me replying?

I'm perceived to be extreme *by you*. That's okay, I can live with that. I'm perceived to be a whole range of other things on here too: a "Quisling", a "scoundrel", a "traitor", a garden centre web designer, an employee of Boroughmuir High School, the list goes on...
34

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 19:18:45
#32 I attacked him because I think he's wheedling his way into mainstream politics, and people should be aware that when they vote Tory they are voting for an anti-gay religious extremist. I hope it would make some people think twice.
35

calum,

29/04/2009 19:28:36
#33- "End of" means finished, better things to do. You go and reply to your heart's content, if you perceive that to be OK.
36

Duncan in Edinburgh,

29/04/2009 20:01:12
#35 :-) Bless.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.