Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Wednesday, 9th December 2009 Change Date

Why we need to listen to voice of youth

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 November 2007

LUCY CUMMING and LILY ORAM

BEING young is amazing. Fact. Most people creeping up in the age department look back on their teenage years as some of the best of their lives. We have heard too many times "you're so lucky" and "if only I could go back and do that".

This is, of
course, the glory of hindsight. And why not look favourably back upon those years? The world and all its opportunities lie ahead of us; amongst them, the ability to be an independent generation.

But to do this we need recognition of our positive contributions to society instead of a constant focus on the negative aspects of youth culture. We need our voice to be taken seriously.

Writing for The Evening News has shown us that some adults are listening to this plea. Ongoing encouragement from parents and teachers to voice our opinions can sometimes be misleading when we are faced with others who view us with prejudice or dismiss our opinions.

When we are given opportunities to be published, it is usually in magazines aimed at our own age group. That is getting us absolutely nowhere.

The media are also to blame for their obsession with gang culture, antisocial behaviour and alcohol abuse. We regret that this exists in all age groups of our society. But it would be a less prominent issue if they focused on what young people are doing well. Let's try and put a stop to this ageism.

As members of our school Jazz Band, we were involved in playing a joint concert with Craigroyston School. We were surprised to find that we also asked to take part in a focus group where we met influential adults. They asked us our opinions on how we would like to be viewed by society and they actually listened to what we had to say.

Almost stuck for words, we managed to compile a few suggestions, including our own column in a top newspaper (looks like that went down well!). The evening was a taster of what we think would benefit all young people and we want the voice we have here, now, to not just be a one-off but to become if not a daily then a weekly voice.

We can see evidence that these age barriers are being broken down and can only hope that we are right. If this continues in the future, we know that the next generation to fill our shoes will benefit from the move towards equality. We are not a generation obsessed with fashion and celebrities. We, like adults, worry about current issues too. We are tomorrow's decision makers - trust us!

• Lucy Cumming and Lily Oram are pupils at St George's School for Girls




SIPHIWE MNGCOLWANI and CHRISTINA SOUTER


THE press are doing more harm than good in their portrayal of Scottish youth. What can now be seen as constant attack on us by media has become seriously damaging, not only to us but also to the perception of our local communities.

A negative picture is constantly being painted by the media. Whether they don't notice it or just don't care, they need to realise the part they play in destroying our morale. And remember, we are the future readers and listeners.

Thugs, gangs, hooligans, Asbo. You get the picture; the black hoodies, eyes hidden and a gritty black and white backdrop.

You can easily associate them with young people. But this is a distortion. It models a whole society after a tiny fraction of individuals in it. It is a shame that real lives of young people can be overshadowed by stereotypes.

Compare the stories plastered on pages every day and see how many of them are negative and sensationalised. Now think of the young people you actually know. The two don't add up. I can only associate the gap between the two as propaganda or just a culture of lazy journalism.

Why can't we look at the good actions as much as we publicise the bad stories? It's not because there is a shortage of good stories with no news value. At our school, Craigroyston High, you can find so many great achievements and talent. We have our own rock band, samba band, senior pupils who buddy juniors and volunteer at a special school. And that is just a few stories from only one school.

We can show our talents and good achievements by getting more good stories in the media. One place you find good news stories is local press like the North Edinburgh News. And earlier this week the Evening News had a story about a young actress from North Edinburgh. But these are exceptions that prove the rule. And there is no point putting a few token stories in local press alone. It doesn't reach enough people.

Let's make a big change. If young people had a more direct say in the media our voices could be heard and a real snapshot of our views could be vividly seen. Our image would be reflected with justice.

There is a way to do it. Would the press be willing to sign up to an agreement to balance coverage more fairly? This could be a historic young people's media charter. A drastic change may not be immediate, but every sentence in this column shows there is hope.

• Siphiwe Mngcolwani and Christina Souter are pupils at Craigroyston High School



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 November 2007 8:40 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Stephen Jardine
 
1

,

15/11/2007 12:24:58
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 1144836, Article id was mapped to record!
2

sceptic,

15/11/2007 13:42:15

The school's greatest achievements a rock band and a samba band. Says it all!

3

antifa,

15/11/2007 13:50:34

"The only way to restore order is to bring back the whip, stocks, guilotine, and hanging...in my day this worked."

How old are you? I think it's a while since we had children hanged - and I'm not sure we ever guilotined them.

"I have no criminal record and do not abuse orhers [sic] - unlike the youth of today."

So all young people have a criminal record, do they? Are you not generalising just a bit?

4

wattie>x 1,

15/11/2007 14:18:36

Watching the muck and infantile behaviour of so-called mature males and females both dish up on BBC and commercial TV as entertainment, can one wonder why the young behave in such a manner?

Bring back the whip, stocks, guillotine and hanging for whom? I would agree with you; if your barbaric remedy was to be used on the worst quality ever in the history of the disunited UK of the present sitting members of parliament. These are the people entirely to blame for the dismal present state of near - anarchy now existing in our " totalitarian" UK; and not the blame of our children who aremerely the by-products of New Labour's Champagne socialist "UTOPIA".

5

Paul Voltaire,

15/11/2007 14:44:32

How lazy of Jardie to sub-contract his column to some kids.

6

Foresight,

By the Water of Leith 15/11/2007 15:12:05

People of all ages have to earn respect by their efforts and behaviour - the youth of today cannot just demand it, albeit that they have had a bad start in life growing up in the days of New Labours Champagne Socialism and having to learn from Pinko School Teachers.

Those that have the vote should exercise it positively to change society for the better, part of which should be however to sort out those of their own age group who give their whole generation a bad name.

7

SNPfighter101,

far ago and long away 15/11/2007 16:14:45

I think it is the parents job to be teaching young people about the collective voice of the people. About how they can make changes for the better if that is what they want to do.

The fight for an Independent Scotland is passing to the next generation if we don't teach them about the peoples voice in media we will never hear their opinion

8

ShortLady,

Livingston 15/11/2007 20:11:52

Oh for goodness sake! As terrified as any adult is of a group of 'youths' (how about human beings?), think of the terrifying effect it has on the vast majority of the law abiding, mature, civilised young people we have in this country.

I am slightly fortunate in a way to look a lot younger than I am. I'm not very tall. Therefore whenever I am in a shop I am stalked by security staff, when I have never stolen a thing in my life. This is just one prejudice (we adults steal too you know, and are better at it). Yes there are violent idiots and criminals. You get them in every age bracket. Every generation has been moaned about by older generations. Believe me, your grandparents probably thought your generation was going to hell. And although I was a teenager not so long ago, even I was shocked then and still am now by the things some young people get up to.

But to tar them all with the same brush? I think giving young people a column (and having them request it) is a mature decision on both sides and if you would bother to get off your high horses and take in what the general 'youth' are trying to tell you, you would perhaps relax in the knowledge that they're not 'all beyond helping' and are actually decent human beings.

I also work with and therefore learn from many young people who surprise me every day with their ideas and principles, even if they do laugh at the odd fart joke. I find most of them to be kind, decent, funny and very intelligent. There are always kids who cause trouble, yes. These kids are the ones who need our attention and intervention the most. They need help and yes of course, punishment.

But here's a thought:

Instead of sitting on your arse complaining about youth violence yadda yadda yadda, tell me, what have YOU actually done to try and combat the reasons these kids are behaving this way? Have you considered volunteering, reaching out, working alongside them, changing things? Have you donated money or time to ch

9

,

15/11/2007 20:49:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 1146250, Article id was mapped to record!
10

Katharine,

Edinburgh 15/11/2007 23:36:47

I'm not sure that some of the previous commenters have read the columns written by these young people. If they had, they would see that they are intelligent, articulate people who are concerned about the way they and others are being viewed and treated and are actively doing something to change that. They deserve our respect, not bitter tirades from people with nothing good to say.

Few open-minded rational people would dream of making such negative, sweeping generalizations about any other group within our society - how are 'young people' any different?

11

Tomaggs,

Fife 16/11/2007 00:15:15

I hope those girls do not read thesre comments - if they do, it will be confirmed to them that adults do not listen to young people.

#3 "The school's greatest achievements a rock band and a samba band. Says it all!"

the rest read thus:
'senior pupils who buddy juniors and volunteer at a special school.

Please - give credit where it is due!

As the girls say, alcohol abuse and anti social behaviour exists across all age groups. Do you seriously think that the law abiding, decent young people like being tarred with the same brush as the minority who constantly hit the headlines with their beahaviour? Would you?

I was very impressed by the writings of these girls and couldn't agree more with their sentiment that most of the media coverage concerns negative behaviour and issues, while the positive actions of decent young people often go unreported.

I would like to join the girls in reminding readers that they represent the future decision makers.

While I agree that the anti social behaviour of the minority needs to be addressed, I would ask some commenters to remember that not ALL young people are a waste of space. After all, would decent adults wish to be told that they are no better than the anti social adults who inhabit this planet?

#13 Katharine - I couldn't agree more, well said

12

Tomaggs,

Fife 16/11/2007 00:21:00

#4 and #11
I forgot to say, "well said to you" as well.

It would be nice if good comments outnumbered the crap ones on this thread.

13

Tomaggs,

Fife 16/11/2007 10:10:57

#16
The Sottish Youth Parliament is still going strong.

http://www.scottishyouthparliament.org.uk/Home.htm

#17 For lots of today's young people, working alongside older people is the making of them as they learn the work ethic, responsibilities and how to behave in an adult world and they cant' do the Buckie every night thing as they have to get up for work.
I have seen many young people change for the better, even with a part time, after school job.

Sadly, many do not get that opportunity.

It is also depressing to work with young people who could mend their ways but belong to families who accept and support their bad behaviour.

14

Shave,

Edinburgh 16/11/2007 11:05:44

Young people are the greatest users of state services, yet have no vote.

They are constantly pilloried by the media yet get little representation in it.

They are threatened with "the whip, stocks, guilotine, and hanging" yet they are the age group most at risk from violent crime.

Then we have the cheek to demand that they respect their elders.

15

Stephen T.,

17/11/2007 00:07:09

The culture of "adolescence" (young adults) began to be dismantled in the 50's by the culture of "teenagers" - thanks to our social engineers. I think the word "teenager" was coined in the 50's and was idolized (amongst other promoters) by the movie "Rebel without a cause". That was entering into the "slippery slope".The change in culture got increasingly worse in the 60's, 70's and 80's now to the point of chaos. Our "young adults" have been short-changed by our Social Engineers - and it is high time those responsible in Education and other responsible fields reverse the "propaganda" and destruction. Young people have a refreshing natural idealism that must be recovered, nurtured and healed. Remember - many very young men and women protected us in the wars of 1914 and 1939 and many, many others. Young heros throughout history has shaped our world as we know it. Go back to your history books; take a good look at what youth is capable of and accomplished; then let us get back to our senses in restoring harmony and peace of the good old "natural law" based on true human dignity. Three cheers to our young people!


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.