Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Wednesday, 4th November 2009 Change Date Latest Issue

Top trio miss out as council is forced into Saturday meeting

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
08 September 2007
A BITTER row has broken out over a decision to hold an emergency meeting of the city council next Saturday - when the top three officials will be absent.
Labour and the Greens demanded the meeting to discuss the U-turn by the Liberal Democrat-SNP administration over its plans to close 22 schools and four community centres.

The date was chosen by Lib Dem Lord Provost George Grubb, but it has now em
erged council chief executive Tom Aitchison will miss the meeting because of his daughter's wedding. And director of corporate services Jim Inch and finance director Donald McGougan cannot be there either.

The Lib Dems and SNP are accusing Labour of wasting time by insisting on an emergency meeting when a normal full council meeting is planned days later.

But Labour has hit back at the administration for choosing a date when the senior officials are unavailable.

Former Lord Provost Eric Milligan said: "I am absolutely flummoxed. I've never known anything like it.

"To be summoned to a meeting on a Saturday is one thing, but then to find that the chief executive, director of corporate services and the finance director will be unable to attend is quite astonishing. The first thing the Lord Provost should have done was to make sure that the senior officers would be there."

Labour group leader Ewan Aitken said Mr Aitchison's reason for not being at the meeting was "more than legitimate", but said the administration could have called the meeting for any day after September 6.

"If they had any sense they would have had the meeting as soon as possible. Instead, they put it off and have now chosen an awkward time," he said.

He insisted Labour was right to call the meeting. "There is no clarity about what is happening with the schools," he said. "People are asking us 'Is this just a stay of execution?' and we don't know."

But Lib Dem leader Jenny Dawe said there was little choice about the date of the meeting.

She said: "They put in their request to John Sturt, the council secretary, and he got back to the Lord Provost and copied it to me, saying there were few potential dates.

"If Labour don't like the idea of meeting on a Saturday, they have only themselves to blame. They know what the council diary looks like. It's absolutely jammed with all sorts of committees, many of which involve people coming in from outside.

"And given we have a lot of councillors who work full-time and it is difficult to get time off, at the end of the day the least damaging seemed to be Saturday."

She said the other possible dates had been this Thursday - which would have meant cancelling two committees - Sunday or Holiday Monday.

Councillor Dawe added: "It is ridiculous they are doing this. There is a full meeting on the Thursday, but Labour refused to withdraw their request."

And SNP leader Steve Cardownie said Labour's insistence could not be justified.

He said: "This is a stupid decision by Labour. There is no need for it. They are just trying to make political capital out of it."

A council spokesman said

: "The availability of the room and other factors meant there were very limited options."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 September 2007 8:50 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Edinburgh school closures
 
1

Very Concerned Resident,

08/09/2007 11:20:12

Seems like a lot of fabricated anger to me from the new crowd - aren't an Opposition supposed to try and hold those in charge to account?

And it's a bit rich to complain the Council diary is "absolutely jammed with all sorts of committees" ... that wouldn't be all the committees that have just been resurrected since May 3rd would it??

2

Shabina,

Edinburgh 08/09/2007 11:21:21

Actually the real reason for the hystrionics is that Teeth Milligan and Bunty Backhander won't be able to make the Hearts match as their own colleague admits:

http://andrewburns.blogspot.com/2007/09/petty-or-professi...

The comment on the post is good as well:

"But on the other side, having an ever so slight chance of that vision in white, Bunty and the council's own in-house squatter, Teeth not turning up is probably just too good an opportunity to pass up.

Perhaps you could ask for spending at the Waterfront to be added to the agenda if they do find that all the "blue light taxis" are taken for the trip to Tynecastle and pub crawl afterwards."

3

JJ52,

08/09/2007 11:28:54

Labour call for an emergency meeting and moan when one is arranged. Why not wait until the planned meeting? It's clear they have still not gotten over missing out on power.

4

Eve,

Scotland 08/09/2007 11:51:26

Why are the given a weeks notice if they worked properly out in the community as leaders/ managers then they'd be called in at all hours on any day, when working with folk, who are disabled, homeless, old ect!!!!!

They should be greatfull that they've been given a weeks notice.

5

Padraig,

08/09/2007 12:18:54

Iam growing heartily sick of Labour still throwing their rattle out of the pram.

At first I thought it was just losing in the huff but it is starting to look like a way of life.

And this is the bunch that were running the Council a few months ago!

LibDems and SNP have their work cut out for them without this nfantile behaviour which only shows how inept the surviving Labour councillors are!

6

Paul Voltaire,

08/09/2007 12:41:08

The whole thing is all rather boring and pointless.

7

Chris.J,

08/09/2007 13:18:05

Give me strength... Is there anything about the new administration that the EEN won't whine about???

This is trivial nonsense coming from an ideologically bankrupt party. What's worse is this grubby little unionist rag STILL can't accept the result of the election and is giving them every opportunity to lie, distort the truth or whip up hysteria.

Still, the EEN is now so bad and blatent biased its actually turning into quite a funny parody of itself..... I for one can't wait for Foulkes' next personal narrative on his hallucinations - yesterdays was a just surreal....

8

Merouane,

Edinburgh 08/09/2007 13:42:03

#8. The EEN will keep on whining until either Labour are back in control of the council or the editor is replaced. Hopefully it will be the latter.

9

Duncan in Edinburgh,

08/09/2007 14:06:03

#8 Someone can't accept the result of the election? You mean the local council election in Edinburgh? The one that the SNP lost? The one in which Labour got more seats that the SNP? That election result?

There are certainly people in denial, but it's not the "unionists". Dear me.

10

Chris.J,

08/09/2007 14:18:54

#10 Yes, that's the one - the one where Labour lost control of the council after everybody got sick of them screwing things up. Talk about me being in denial!! Typical Labour hypocrit.

Still, you'll be content in the knowledge that their decisions and influence will linger for years.

Like a bad smell.

And no doubt you and the EEN sycophants will have total amnesia about who caused this mess in the first place...... School closure debate anyone?

11

Piltonjambo,

Edinburgh 08/09/2007 15:13:57

The date was chosen by Lib Dem Lord Provost George Grubb, but it has now emerged council chief executive Tom Aitchison will miss the meeting because of his daughter's wedding. And director of corporate services Jim Inch and finance director Donald McGougan cannot be there either

Eh .... Just what part of date selection did ANYONE else (outwith the administration) have a hand in here ...
no doubt you and the anti Labour sycophants will have total amnesia about who caused this mess in the first place ......
just a thought but ... what will it take from you to admit that those in charge have completely ballsed up AGAIN ...
without trying to pass the blame on to somebody else? ... a simple meeting with ALL of the relevant people in attendance is what was required here.

12

Senga Jean,

Edinburgh 08/09/2007 15:43:53

Are'nt Labour fun now they are in opposition. Land mines and ambushes and political posturing that would win a Festival Fringe award. Let's call it the FFoulkes Folly Flourish in memory of that well kent comedian.

13

Pen pusher,

08/09/2007 16:11:12

#4 - 'Why are the given a weeks notice...'

Because it's a legal requirement.

14

Doh,

08/09/2007 16:18:14

It will be good the Council to meet.

Labour can explain why in their manifesto they promised to cut £12 million from the Education budget (presumably without closing any schools).

Now would be a good time for them to reveal how they were planning to do that, I think the new administration would be most interested.


Oh - and if the "non-political" SNP supportere from Stockbridge is reading -

apparantly it was the SNP Councillor David Becket that asked for Stockbridge Primary School to be added to the list of schools under consultation.

Ask him to deny it.

15

HBOS Sucks,

Edinburgh 08/09/2007 16:48:42

Doh #15,
What manifesto? I hope you're not making things up! I read the Labour (and LibDem and SNP) manifestos before the election (OK, I know it's sad, but none of the bumpf that the parties were sending me were actually telling me anything, so I looked for myself). There is (not surprisingly) NOTHING in the Labour manifesto about making cuts (actually, there's not much of anything really).

If anyone wants to check, look at
http://www.leithwalkward.org.uk/EdinburghOneCityOurCity.pdf

Doh, what are you getting at?

16

Shabina,

Edinburgh 08/09/2007 19:47:35

"And director of corporate services Jim Inch and finance director Donald McGougan cannot be there either. "

Obviously they are going to the wedding as well.

17

Eve,

Scotland 08/09/2007 22:31:47

#14. Pen pusher: A legal requirement for some and not all.

I'm aware that in the community in some aspects and areas of it call emergency meeting within 24hours of relaising that they need them.

Why can't the concelers be treated the same way!!!

18

Doh,

09/09/2007 17:06:15

#16 HBOS

I have been told that Labour's proposed budget for 2007 included a cut £12M in the education budget - presumably one of the reasons they felt comfortabel with such a low council tax rise (during an election year).

This is why I am so annoyed with the Labour party on this issue - although I accept they are just making hay when the sun shines. The Evening News has no excuse for not making this point clear to the public.

I'll try and find a link to Labour's 2007 budget - to try and verify what I have been told.

19

Duncan in Edinburgh,

10/09/2007 07:33:06

#19 And you'll fail, of course, but that doesn't matter since you have already thrown the mud, so your job is done.

Pathetic.

20

Doh,

10/09/2007 08:51:59

#21 Duncan

You claim not be a Labour supporter,
Yet in every post you defend them to the hilt.
Are you sure you are telling the truth?

Just like the way Labour lied and misled over Iraq.

If you have a copy of the Labour budget then please forward it to me - I am willing to be corrected - and will happily apologise for my mistake. Unlike Tony Bliar.

21

Duncan in Edinburgh,

10/09/2007 10:20:57

#22 So your modus operandii is to make an unsupported claim, and then wait for others to disprove it before you withdraw it? Tell me, do you have any scruples whatsoever? Why should anyone listen to anything you say if that is your attitude?

You, who have made a totally unsubstantiated claim about the previous administration's plans, are now accusing me of lying. Pathetic.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.