Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Wednesday, 9th December 2009 Change Date

Black backs Elliot to beat boos

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 February 2008
FORMER Hearts midfielder Kenny Black believes Calum Elliot can win over the club's supporters in the same way he did over two decades ago.
Elliot has come in for criticism in recent months from Jambos fans who have been left frustrated by under-par performances from their side.

However, caretaker boss Stephen Frail has publicly backed the youngster and called on those in the stand to
get right behind him in the remaining games of the season and Black is convinced that the striker can silence his doubters in the best way possible.

Black, now Airdrie manager, believes that the 20-year-old has suffered from an extra weight of pressure on his young shoulders because he is one of the only local boys in the Hearts line-up.

But he has no doubt that the striker has what it takes to make the grade in the SPL and said: "He was put out on loan to Motherwell last season and I think that maybe knocked him back a little bit in terms of confidence.

"There's no doubting the fact that he has huge potential though.

"He's not had much luck recently and he was sent off a few weeks ago, which didn't really help him because he was struggling to get into the starting line-up at that time.

"There are a few foreigners at Tynecastle right now so whenever a local young player comes in people at the club and in the stands are always willing him to do well.

"When that's the case you really need your own identity and when things are not going your way then it can be difficult and his performances have maybe not been what they could have.

"But I'm sure he'll get there."

If anyone should know how Elliot feels right now, it is Black, pictured below, as he also found himself singled out for criticism.

He was part of the side which lost the league on the final day of the 1985/86 season and in the Scottish Cup final which followed just a week later, and knows only too well how Elliot and co feel when frustrations boil over in the stands.

However he believes that the young striker can handle the pressure – and that he could even turn it into something of a positive.

"A similar thing happened with me when I was at Tynecastle," Black revealed. "I was there for five years and fans always have their favourites and because of the type of player I was, I always wanted to get on the ball.

"That meant that if we gave the ball away they sometimes took their frustrations out on me and you have got to work out a way of blanking that out. There are two ways that you can look at it. You can either let the boos get on top of you and you become nervous and retreat into your shell, or you can take it on the chin and let it make you more determined to go out and show people what you can do.

"If you're nervous then things can just go from bad to worse because you're always aware of the crowd maybe getting on your back.

"I was determined not to let it affect me and I think Calum can do the same. He has certainly got the work ethic and people know that he is giving 100 per cent for the club.

"If he can continue to work hard then the supporters will see that and hopefully he can get a few goals under his belt and get back to enjoying his football again."

While Black believes Elliot can overcome the difficulties he has faced so far this season, he also feels that Hearts have begun to resurrect their campaign.

The Jambos have won their last three games on the bounce and have kept three clean sheets in the process, a source of much pleasure for caretaker boss and former defender Frail.

"Hearts have certainly picked themselves up in the last few weeks," added Black.

"I looked at the league table towards the end of the year and I couldn't believe the position they were sitting in at the time.

"But they seem to have turned things around a bit, they've won their last three league games in a row and with that comes confidence. That will be good for the players and it will have them looking forward to games again and going into matches believing that they can win them.

"There's not a lot in it in terms of points and it is amazing how quickly things can turn round for you.

"If Hearts can just keep this run going then it is more than possible for them to completely turn it on its head within the space of just a few weeks."

Black believes that a key component in Hearts' turnaround has been the appointment of Frail as caretaker manager – and the decision to give him sole control over team matters during his time in charge. Since then Hearts have looked a different proposition altogether and Black is keen for Vladimir Romanov to offer Frail the position on a permanent basis at least until the end of the season.

He added: "I think that the sensible option is to offer the job to Stephen Frail, even if it is until the end of the season initially.

"He is a good man, he knows what he is talking about and the players obviously like him.

"When they were going through their really torrid spell he got the players going again and it's to such an extent that they all really want to be playing and going into training every day.

"That filters through to the supporters and before you know it you have a good buzz about the place again and a good atmosphere at the ground. The players really seem to be playing for the jersey again and that's how it should be."

Hearts travel to Parkhead this weekend knowing that a victory could see them into the top six, if results elsewhere go their way.

The Glasgow side have already been defeated by Hearts on their home patch and Black wouldn't be surprised if Andrius Velicka, who scored twice that day, hits the back of the net again on Saturday.

"He clearly knows where the goal is and he's done really well for Hearts so far this season whenever he has played.

"He's really endeared himself to the supporters with his goals and with his attitude because he really just goes out there and gets on with it.

"Hearts have already won at Parkhead this season and Velicka has already scored there this season too so there's no reason why they can't go there and do the same again this time." Black's Airdrie side are riding high in the Second Division this season, sitting in second place behind leaders Ross County.

They face Brechin in the league this weekend and he's hoping for a victory that would keep them on course for something to celebrate this time round after narrowly missing out on the play-offs last season.

He added: "We're in second place right now, despite a really inconsistent start to the season.

"There were games that we were losing in the latter stages but we have managed to cut that out and we are reaping the benefits.

"The three teams at the top are the three full-time teams so I think it has probably panned out the way that most people would have imagined so far, but hopefully we will be in a different order come the final day of the season.

"We were really disappointed with the way that it finished up last season with the play-offs but we've won 11 of our last 13 games and hopefully we can keep that up. We play Ross County in a few weeks' time and that really will be the big one for us.

"They are the form team in the league right now and they have a bigger squad than us but we want it just as much as them and the boys are working really hard in training and in games for us.

"All we can do though is take it one game at a time, keep our heads down and working hard and hopefully it will pay off for us come the end of the season."

A VITAL COG IN THE DOUBLE ASSAULT ON GLORY IN 1985-86
KENNY BLACK played more than 250 matches for the Jambos in a little under five years at Tynecastle.

The former midfielder made his first appearance for the club in July 1984 and was a first-team regular until he was sold to Portsmouth for £350,000 in 1989. He played alongside the likes of John Roberston, Gary Mackay, Walter Kidd and Henry Smith and was an integral part of the team that came within a whisker of winning a league and Scottish Cup double in the 1985/86 season.

The Jambos needed only a point away to Dundee on the final match of the season to pip Celtic to the title but agonisingly lost two goals in the final seven minutes to lose out.

Just a week later a shattered Hearts squad were beaten 3-0 in the Scottish Cup final by Aberdeen to end one of the most exciting seasons in their history with nothing to show for their efforts.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 14 February 2008 11:18 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Heart of Midlothian FC
 
1

,

14/02/2008 11:59:58
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Gorgie Forever,

14/02/2008 12:14:37
I'd never boo the guy but I can't stand his sulking attitude and his total lack of effort most of the time. He couldn't finish his dinner and heads the ball like Goncalves. I think alot of the booing is frustration at his continual selection when surely someone else would be worth a try.
3

Chas Niceass,

14/02/2008 12:18:16
No Valentines card for Colleen then, Sadistic Witch!!!!!
Elliot does have something but he needs to show it soon, Frails been good to him, Calum should repay him at least.
4

Kerry,

EDINBURGH 14/02/2008 12:19:24
Good point Gorgie ! However I also heard that there were allegedly some very personal comments made to Calum on Saturday which isn't on. It's not going to help him and it's not his fault he's being picked. IMO Miko has improved slightly since the a section of fans started backing him in retaliation of booing from rival fans over his Scotland antics.

Some people seem to forget that the players can hear their bile in amongst all the other racket. We shouldn't be booing our own players :(

5

Anglo Jambo,

Chorley 14/02/2008 12:19:58
So the fans are to sit back and encourage Elliot although he is playing crap. When he plays we are in effect a man short, so we all shout together hard lines Calum you missed a sitter but better luck next time. That's it play him against Celtic and all Hearts fans sing Calum, Calum give us a goal. Get lost Black and Frail, his behaviour in getting sent off was a disgrace but it did improve the team. At moment he is not good enough for first team so let him show us if he has what it takes by banging in goals in reserves and then give him another chance. It is not up to the fans but up to Elliot.
6

InsideOutside,

Scotland's Capital 14/02/2008 12:21:15
#2,

I will never boo a player in maroon BUT....

HEARTS, HE IS NOT FECKING GOOD ENOUGH FOR US!!!!

I have absolutely had it with Frail and now ex-players coming out to defend a bloke who does not cut the mustard. He is not an SPL player, full stop. He has had a multitude of opportunities and the time is up. It's time to give someone else a chance. I wish Makela had been given as many chances as Elliot.

TO REITERATE - HE IS NOT GOOD ENOUGH.

7

J80MBo,

14/02/2008 12:26:04
#2

'total lack of effort'?

i'm not a fan of the guy but dont think can say the effort isnt there... for me he puts to much effort in, he runs around like a headless chicken at times.


As for the fans that booed him coming on against gretna...their an absollute disgrace. these fans have more to prove to the club than elliot does!!!
8

Kerry,

EDINBURGH 14/02/2008 12:27:22
#6 I do unfortnately have to agree he was one of my favourite players at one point but has completely lost it and should be shipped out in the summer along with a number of others.
9

10-2,

14/02/2008 12:28:05
Agreed #7

Lack of effort was a stupid example regarding one of Elliots downfalls.
10

Robert Bonaly,

East Lothian 14/02/2008 12:31:56
Why does Elliot get so much press by the likes of Frail etc.I find it totally baffling to say the least that so much attention is heaped on him. Seems like if they continue to hype him up, somehow he will achieve a similar level of performance - the pschology of a cave man to be quite honest !!!The guy is rubbish, trash, rank rotten - end off, so let's all accept that and move on to far more interesting issues !!!
11

10-2,

14/02/2008 12:34:16
I too do not think Elliot should be given the chances he is currently getting and agree he should be put in the reserves to find his confidence again, then we give him another shot. He would not be anywhere near my first team at this moment in time.

As has been said though, its not his fault he gets put on the park, and booing him on the way on is disgraceful behavior that helps no-one.
12

Lion-O "Lord Of The ThunderCats,

14/02/2008 12:35:42
I find it strange the Hearts fans attitude to Elliott compared to hoe Hibs fans treat their youngsters.

Elliott has made it as a professional footballer - an achievement that the vast majority of Hearts fans have not been able to do. Frail works with the kid every day and says he is a good player - yet the Hearts fans know better it seems.

If Elliott is THAT bad then how come he keeps on getting selected for the Scotland U-21's alongside Fletcher? Surely if Elliott was actually rubbish then he would be nowhere near the U-21 team, especially as McCormack is eligible for that team?

Looks like all the professional coaches are plain wrong and the fans know best!!

13

Gorgie Forever,

14/02/2008 12:40:15
#7,9

Maybe I didn't make that point well. I should have said that when he loses the ball he will occassionaly lose the head and almost always hang his head and skulk about. And if he does run about, its rarely in any kind of defence capacity either. Not looking for him to be tackling back all the time but he isn't a team player.

#7 agree that he isn't good enough, can't really say any more.

#9 Stupid? Poorly phrased perhaps but stupid I think not.
14

Chas Niceass,

14/02/2008 12:41:43
I cant agree Elliot is rubbish, sorry. He is quite clearly not playing well. Booing him is a bit off I have to say, but I would agree he's not doing anything to justify a game. Sometimes they need a run though, judging by this forum no one is going to allow him that, nor do I believe Hearts can really afford to right now.
For my money he had a right good game in the CIS QF at Celtic.
I said yesterday 3 games stick in my head where he showed great ability and skill, sadly all 2 years back, Celtic Ne'ers Day Hibs 2 weeks on and Dons in SC demolition job, remember the run and cross for Pospisils finish?
He cant live on those 2/3 months though and he needs to start proving he has ability, does seem attitude is questionable, but he's begining to appear as a scapegoat, witch hunts against our own players are embarrassing for my money, even if he has been rank.
Miko is the one I dont personally rate, I get frustrated at him, but I'd gladly applaud him if he did something right, I dont think Elliot is going to get any praise no matter what, thats a pity.
Like I say though, its down to him to change that, only goals will satisfy the lynch mob me thinks.
15

Anglo Jambo,

Chorley 14/02/2008 12:46:10
12*

The fans don't profess to be coaches and if Scotland under 21 boss wants to pick him then it is up to him. Fans can judge by performance on the pitch for Hearts and he has been bad. You don't need to be a coach to see if a player plays badly or not. It is for the coach to knock player into shape.
16

tomias,

Edinburgh 14/02/2008 12:46:42
Racist head line
17

itsnomarooned,

14/02/2008 12:53:35
It's pretty clear that Elliot completely lacks confidence at the moment. The Catch 22 here is that he's hardly likely to gain confidence if he feels unwanted by the fans when he steps on the pitch. I'm not convinced that he is good enough but rather than bung him in the reserves he needs a proper loan deal where he can be guaranteed a start each week. This would most likely be in the 1st Division - not that it did Mole any good! If that doesn't work then it's cut our losses time and advise him to leave.
18

Life long jambo,

Edinburgh 14/02/2008 12:54:03
I don't think Elliot is as bad as some fans make out. Get of his back for a bit - it might help. The game at Motherwell earlier in the season proved to me, at least, he has something. He led the line very well on his own with some clever runs for other players. He just needs to score some goals. I agree with comments #12 and #14.
19

Old Reekies Big Team,

14/02/2008 12:58:49
Has Elliot got a drink problem now?
20

Graham Rix ate my hamster,

14/02/2008 13:03:52
Dont think Kenny Black has the legs for SPL football these days.
21

JC_No7,

14/02/2008 13:14:57
Why Elliot and not Ksanavicius, is it because he looks like John Colquhoun? He has played as a withdrawn strker for practicaly the whole season and scored 1 goal! He's started 18 games and come on as a sub in 5 but everyone moans that Elliot doesn't score goals!!

Its crazy.

I'm not trying to start a vendetta against him as i don't think we should be booing anybody but i bet he starts against Cletic, misses a chance or doesn't pass when someone is free in the box.

Prove me wrong wee man!
22

Jambo83,

West Lothian 14/02/2008 13:23:01
#21 But wee Audrey sets up goals. Our 2nd goal on Saturday came from a lovely pass from the wee man and Velicka was fouled for the penalty.

Elliot has been given his chance and failed to impress in my opinion. He shouldn't be given a start until he starts banging in goals for the reserves in my opinion.

I have got nothing against the boy but we need our best XI on the park to finish as high as possible and Elliot does not come in to that category.
23

i wanna be like John Colquhoun,

14/02/2008 13:27:58
elliot shows a complete lack of effort and might fool you into thinking he is doing something but his idea of closing a man down is jog lightly toward them for two steps and stop. his attitude and body language stink!

in total agreement that makela should have been given half the chances elliot has.

and this loan out to motherwell stuff didnt help him...it was meant to so that either down to his attitude or he is just not good enough.

BOTH in my opinion.

why shouldnt we boo our own players??? this to me is just as stupid as you shouldnt leave early.

i pay my season ticket money therefore can leave when i want...eg when we are 4-0 to dundee utd at home i dont want to stay and watch that...and if anyone thinks that in by staying to the end they support hearts more than me they are well off the mark.

same with booing...i dont tend to do it but what else should you do...elliot has had enough chances to prove himself and continually plays c**P! every time!

this wrap in in cotton wool, tell him he is great, dont boo him.

saw him shopping yesterday and it took a lot of restraint not to boo him on the street.

he needs to wake up if he is good enough and as black says shut out the boos and prove us we are wrong.

until then BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO to elliot!!!!
24

Geronimo (1829–1909) wiz there on 26 April 1902,

14/02/2008 13:33:32
What is Kenny black doing?

The fans see Elliot's efforts and lack of goals so no amount of promoting to the media and young player awards will make him a fans favourite unless he delivers.

He's the only local boy in the line-up, give me strength; if anything, he's probably had a lot more slack cut to him because of that.

Being a 'local boy' hasn't helped him find the baack of the net.

I enjoyed watching Kenny Black play, he was a player that liked to move forward with the ball at his feet, unlike bambi dancing on ice.

I thought Kenny Black was only booed though because he allegedly liked the bevvy a bit too much and after he turned up to an awards bash in a right royal state he got a bit of stick from the fans.
25

Arnie,

Newington 14/02/2008 13:45:56
If we are two goals up with ten minutes left he can come on and not before.
26

Salvatori,

14/02/2008 13:49:54
Jeez EEN, talk about wringing this particular topic to death ... no amount of telling us he's good, he'll come good, or is an outstanding prospect, will at this point in time convince us that he actually is.

With a passing resemblance to Screech from "Saved by the Bell" he has an ego the size of Edinburgh castle.

http://www.askmen.com/fashion/austin_150/183c_fashion_style.html
27

scorchio,

West of the Pecos 14/02/2008 13:55:57
Kenny, goanny no dae that!
I watch Elliot every time he "plays" for Hearts and he is gash.
His lack of confidence is superceeded by his lack of ability. I would be delighted to ship him along the M8 to Airdrie for a tray of Pies.
So to summarise...
Elliot is gash
Kenny Black is talking pesh
28

JohnnyB,

14/02/2008 14:50:42
Christ, what's going on with the Scotsman, is Callum Elliot's father the Editor??????????

Look, it's simple. He's crap and he shouldn't be anywhere near the first team. Sad to say this but look at the local strikers the cabbage have produced in recent years, and we havd Callum "bloody" Elliot enough said!!
29

GrahamL,

14/02/2008 14:59:41
#23 Ask yourself this question. Has any player ever played better as a result of being booed by his own fans?
When you boo Elliot you're telling him you don't think he's good enough, and you don't want him there. You may have other justifications, you can tell yourself it's his attitude you're booing. But he won't hear that. He'll just hear the boos. That's got to be one of the most demoralising things that can happen to any footballer, especially a striker whose entire game is based on confidence
You just find it easier to boo a player who's off form that to stand up and support him, it's childish and selfish. You don't care how it makes him feel, it makes you feel better and to hang with the impact on the team.
30

Skiver,

14/02/2008 15:17:01
You only have to look at how bad Bednar had become under the bizarre coaching structure and how well he is playing now.

Could it just be that Elliot (touted for the first team, then out on loan, then back in the reserves...) needs time to get his confidence back?

Ok fans are entitled to their opinion if they pay their money, but he does seem to have been made a scapegoat.

It was quite embarrassing to see Hearts fans getting ripped into Steven Hughes when there was the possibility of signing him in the summer "not good enough for us" etc etc

Hughes has been a revelation for Motherwell and has bossed the Hearts midfield on at least one occasion, but he wouldn't have been good enough to play for Hearts?

Could it be some are letting their dislike of a player cloud their judgement...
31

festerlehearts,

embra 14/02/2008 15:20:27
kenny black totaly different player at least you put some effort into your game as for elliot not upto the scratch i would love to be proven wrong as i have been in the past steve baggio fulton comes to mind he turned it round ,when a player gets to the point when he starts to enjoy playing football and the fans get behind you, when the player wins them over it must be one of the best feelings in the world, i would like to wish callum all the best looks like he will have to work harder than before if he really wants it go on prove you can do it
32

Dublin.Hibs,

14/02/2008 15:26:52
that is why E LL I OT (in my best ET voice) is getting done in he's an alky.....but frail is backing him to beat the booze!!!
33

GrahamL,

14/02/2008 15:42:36
#34 You might be on to something with the ET thing. No-one had any faith in Eh-leeee-oooottt in that film but he came good once he got his funny looking, wrinkly sidekick. Maybe thats what Calum needs!


Is Davie Dodds still playing??
34

Chas Niceass,

14/02/2008 15:54:01
Show em Calum son, we know you can do it, beat the booze and boo's.
35

Dublin.Hibs,

14/02/2008 15:57:54
if hearts are looking for something wee and wrinkly




















what aboot ma granny
36

True Jambo,

14/02/2008 16:00:38
He's never a footballer but he has still managed to score for us in the past.

Scored v hibs in the 4-1 win
Scored against falkirk in the 5-0 win.

May have scored others.
37

J J MAROONER,

KIRKCALDY 14/02/2008 16:00:50
34#

I see Hibs have been given 8000 tickets for the cup replay against Rangers - better grab one quick they are sure to be in short supply.
38

Dublin.Hibs,

14/02/2008 16:04:31
come on missionary man,

why do you have to be nasty, i will be grabbing one of them thank you very much, only a short journey away but will probably stay in weegieville for the night, only thing that puts me off!!
39

Chas Niceass,

14/02/2008 16:04:47
#37 What was the crowd at Easter Road last night, who won yesterdays comp?
40

i wanna be like John Colquhoun,

14/02/2008 16:08:19
#29 i don't think so mate. dont tell me why i would boo someone that is totally garbage. reason is they are not good enough to play for hearts. at the end of the day we pay the guys wages. and off form????
for two years!!!...thats not "off form"...cant get a game for motherwell...doesnt show any effort.

if his confidence is that shaky then perhaps being a footballer isnt the best job for him. how about being an "ability" player??????

and just so you know i don't actually boo him..i left when he came on v gretna and would do so again. dont want to watch him pretend to run about etc
its like being a man down. i dont find leaving or booing our players easy at all so save your pschology lessons!!
41

Chas Niceass,

14/02/2008 16:16:34
#42 I agree with 29, its my opinion thats self defeating.
As I said in a previous post, the boy played well against Celtic in the QF and still got slated, its unfortunate, no matter what, he will never please some.
I feel Miko is worse than being a man down, it gets the ref against us as well, but I'd still be willing to be proved wrong and maybe lately I have.
42

GrahamL,

14/02/2008 16:21:43
#42 Apologies, I was obviously reading too much into your original post at 23.

When you said "his attitude and body language stink!" I thought you had a problem with his attitude.
And then when you said "BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO to elliot!!!!" I thought you booed him.
Again, I apologise if I misinterpreted any of it.
43

i wanna be like John Colquhoun,

14/02/2008 16:34:32
i think he looks as if he cant be bothered, head down, waving arms etc when things dont go for him..and do think thats a poor attitude for him.

was responding to your "its easy for me to boo him"

"You just find it easier to boo a player who's off form that to stand up and support him, it's childish and selfish. You don't care how it makes him feel, it makes you feel better and to hang with the impact on the team." which is total rubbish!!!

elliots impact on the team is damaging enough!

neilson isnt good enough but he gets stuck in and looks like he gives 100%...thats why he doesnt get booed.

elliot acts like he is a world beater and doesnt look interested hence fans see that and boo him for it.
only he can stop that....if he is good enough.

i personally didnt boo him as i agree...boo the team at the end (if your still there) if your not happy but dont boo a guy coming on the park no matter who it is. i can understand why people do though.

take miko, he was getting booed and stick cause he was playing guff. seems to have knuckled down and put in a few good games. fans are starting to lay off him.

frail and black etc need to stop wrapping elliot in cotton wool and tell him to get over it.

how do you stop fans booing? score goals etc.

problem is elliott doesnt have the ability to get himself out of this.
44

i wanna be like John Colquhoun,

14/02/2008 16:43:19
in fact he doesnt even have to score goals....just look as if he wants to be there.....
45

Chas Niceass,

14/02/2008 16:45:18
#45 Fair enough thats your opinion, but I'd side with Frail, he does have the ability but something else has gone wrong, perhaps confidence, perhaps attitude, I dont know, but he's not playing well, I know for a fact 2 years ago as an 18year old he defintely did have the ability so much so that even Celtic fans I know actually felt he was a threat.
Sad that Hearts fans want to knock our own, there are enough out there ready to do it without becoming an enemy within.
I would agree Elliot is running out of time, but as I also mentioned earlier, nobody is willing to give him any time, Catch 22 for Calum.
46

what a chancer,

abdn 14/02/2008 16:50:34
Put the ball in the net more often and then he can leave and further his career,if he does not do this then he is on a downward slide out of football league.
47

Uncle Tam,

Loanhead 14/02/2008 16:51:00
Hearts fans don't change much down the years. I remember Twinkletoes himself being booed at Tynecastle and he (Jimmy Wardhaugh that is) was one of the true greats. The booing didn't help him recover his form just as it won't help Calum Elliot.
48

GrahamL,

14/02/2008 16:53:34
#45 So what you're wanting, speaking on behalf of those booing but not as a booer, is for Elliot to come on the pitch - to a round of boos - and then go ahead and play well enough in that 15 minutes to stop the booing. Or, as for Miko, to consistently play well enough - over the course of a few months - to stop the booing. Yeah, that might work.

Alternatively, those booing him are deliberately impeding his performance. That's purely selfish behaviour, the player suffers, the team suffers. And that's not even considering the impact that booing Elliot may have on the other players on the park, once they see how fickel and spiteful the supporters are.

Final thought for you, next time you see Calum out shopping, instead of resisting the urge to boo him in the street. Walk up to him, shake his hand, and wish him luck for the next match. Surely even you can see how that would give him a bit of a boost, he is a human being after all.
49

i wanna be like John Colquhoun,

14/02/2008 16:56:35
#47 i want elliot to be good!! i dont want the guy to fail...i dont think any hearts fans do. dont want anybody who pulls on a maroon top to be knocked or booed. i think he has had plenty chances to show what he can do and seems to be resigned to the fact "oh things arent going for me" etc. he gives off that impression. i agree two years ago he played great. but he went to motherwell where he should have shown us what he was made of. he didnt. got to take your chances as makela eg has not kicked a ball since scoring a hat-trick and then netting v barca...has elliot done anything to merit a chance over makela??
BUT just cause he is wearing maroon doesnt mean he cant be slated...i dont personally but i think we have more right than anybody to boo our players and would not condem anybody who does.
50

i wanna be like John Colquhoun,

14/02/2008 17:02:10
#50 i was never going to boo the guy in the street.
but he looked like he couldnt be a**ed shopping!

i think he needs to show more desire when on the pitch and look like he wants to be there.

i dont want anything from elliot except 100% and showing an interest. looks like he doesnt. thats probably not the case but he is NOT helping himself. i personally dont think he is good enough ability wise but he could stop the head down feeling sorry for himself attitude.

that might go a fair bit to stop the booing?
51

what a chancer,

abdn 14/02/2008 17:03:41
If your out of form sit out till your ready, if the managers desperate then he will play you because he needs a glimmer of hope that just might happen ,its like a lottery ticket ,might as well buy a tin of pepsi and a bag of crisps least you will get something of value for money.
52

GrahamL,

14/02/2008 17:18:49
#52 Again, when you said "saw him shopping yesterday and it took a lot of restraint not to boo him on the street." I thought you meant you cam close to booing him on the street. I really have to stop taking you so literally!
Anyway, if you believe that him "stopping feeling sorry for himself" will help stop the booing, would you not think that stopping booing him might lift his spirits a bit? As #47 says, something of a catch 22!
53

Geronimo (1829–1909) wiz there on 26 April 1902,

14/02/2008 22:08:21
if falkirk's manager met Elliot and Beni-useless - would that be yogi and boo-boo?
54

Geronimo (1829–1909) wiz there on 26 April 1902,

14/02/2008 22:09:54
#55 i know that was grim, I'm still in shock from seeing the sheepies actually having a go, I thought for sure they would cower in a 4-5-1 and hope for the set piece that would never come.

...need sleep.
55

Plantagenet,

14/02/2008 22:15:52
49. Uncle Tam, I can remember Jimmy Wardhaugh being booed by a minority of fans at Tynecastle, in those unenlightened times Twinkletoes could have played brilliantly, scored a hat trick and still be booed by them, his crime? his Roman Catholic religion. I can remember as a teenager at work, older colleagues ignoring his immense talent and despising him for being the 'Tim in a maroon jersey'.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.