Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Wednesday, 4th November 2009 Change Date Latest Issue

Parents give sweet-ban head a taste of support

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
24 February 2007
PARENTS have come out in force to back a headteacher who banned children eating sweets and chocolate in his primary school.
Leith Primary head Alasdair Friend introduced the new rules at the start of the week, but was forced to back down after angry parents complained to education chiefs.

They claimed the ruling was taking away their right to give their children "trea
ts".

But now a number of parents have come forward to give their support to the ban and to Mr Friend.

Evening News readers also joined the healthy-eating debate, with almost 200 posting comments on the online message board - many of them supporting Mr Friend's actions.

Kate Marks, 45, from Claremont Park, Leith, has a five-year-old daughter Ellie at Leith Primary School, and son Harvey, three, who next year will attend Leith nursery.

She also helps organise the annual Parents Like Us healthy living festival for children under-six in Leith in May.

Ellie has had to have all her baby teeth removed after they had become black by the age of four.

Her mother blames a combination of sweets and orange juice and antibiotics given to her daughter as a baby to cure an eye infection, which she believes damaged the enamel.

Mrs Marks said it was easier to keep her daughter satisfied with healthy food in school if other children are not eating sweets.

She said: "If my child sees sweets she wants them. It's the most basic form of peer pressure. "My daughter had a few sweet things as a child, but not a lot. And she drank quite a lot of fresh orange juice, which I later found out is one of the worst things they can have for teeth."

Angus Miller, from Leith Links, has a seven-year-old son, Duncan, at the school and his four-year-old daughter Jessica is at nursery.

He believes the ban was one of a number of "positive changes" Mr Friend has made at the school.

However, he believes some flexibility is needed to make healthy eating work in the school.

The 37-year-old said: "An awful lot of parents actually support what the school is trying to do.

"We don't want our kids to be eating something that's bad for them all the time.

"I do think that maybe things should have been made a bit clearer as to what was allowed and what wasn't.

"Mr Friend has now said in his newsletter that this is voluntary, and that the school would be encouraging healthy eating. I know parents would like to see this and would like to work with the school to make it successful."

Mr Friend's ban was strongly criticised by mum Janet McWhirter, who claimed chocolate bars were confiscated from her two sons, aged five and eight, by teachers.

The ban was lifted when city council chiefs told the headteacher that he has no authority to dictate what children have in their packed lunch.

The school plans to open up a healthy eating tuck shop after Easter.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 24 February 2007 10:18 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Teaching , Children's Diet
 
1

alex paterson,

embra 24/02/2007 13:07:14

Kids today,Life is one big treat.

2

MummyWease,

24/02/2007 14:01:03

Glad to hear that there are some parents who back the head in his decision. Maybe The news should have got a more balanced opinion in the first place about it all.

3

Isabel,

24/02/2007 14:05:16

It would be nice to see Mr Friend given 100% support but, with people like Janet McWhirter around, it probably won't happen. She would be the bad apple in the barrel.

4

Buckstone Beth,

Edinburgh 24/02/2007 16:03:29

There was a ban on sweets and chocolate bars over 20 years ago at Buckstone Primary School. However then parents were told to give children crisps to eat instead.
Now that crisps are considered high in fat I suppose it will be only fruit and dried fruit that are allowed.

5

dollydaydream,

leith 24/02/2007 16:58:38

Good to see the other parents puttin their side of the story to the news also !!!Maybe Mrs McWhirter will now stop parading round the playgound tryin to think what next to moan about and let the school carry on teaching her kids !

6

simply the best....,

edinburgh 24/02/2007 17:17:08

exactly teachers are paid to teach our kids, not tell us what they can and cant have.

7

Apple Jack,

24/02/2007 18:29:07

Why? N0 6, Does learning about good nutrition and healthy eating not count as teaching.

8

weeone,

edinburgh 24/02/2007 20:30:45

@7 yes totally but they can teach them about it , but cant take it away from them when the mother gave it to them.

9

Goldfish,

Edinburgh 25/02/2007 09:52:00

I would be very interested to hear how Mrs Mcwhirter has reacted to all the negative publicity she has brought on herself and, much more concerningly, on her children. Has she realised just how her self-seeking actions have impacted on her boys. Being fat is a huge cause of bullying and having her own and her child's obesity discussed online must surely have given her some thought. Is she sorry? Has she reassessed her diet and that of her children? If not then you really have to have concerns round her ability to be a parent - let alone that her rights as a parent have been breached

10

rab, glasgow,

25/02/2007 11:06:22

Total waste of time the kids will just eat their sweets on the way to school and on the way back from school,also are they going to install a sweetie detector?

11

One-man-bucket's older twin,

25/02/2007 16:19:46

Noticed at least one of her kids was fat when this story first appeared with a photo. I think the parents who objected were making sure their kids were on a suger high all day at school, so that they'd be too tired to make a nuisance of themselves when they got home. Selfish parents.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Would a ban on advertising junk foods make our children healthier?
Yes, it will make them less likely to eat unhealthy foods
No, ultimately it’s down to what their parents feed them
No, kids like the taste of junk food too much


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.