Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Endinburgh Council
 
 
Wednesday, 4th November 2009 Change Date Latest Issue

Caltongate set to be revived by failed firm's ex-bosses

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 25 May 2009
THE former owners of the Caltongate site are set to launch a dramatic bid to buy it back from administrators, in a move that could revive the controversial £300 million development.
Former Mountgrange Capital directors Manish Chande and Martin Myers have raised a fund of £300m from a range of investors, and are keen to snap up sites across the country where a developer has gone bust.

It is understood Caltongate, currently owned by Deloitte as Mountgrange Capital's administrator, is top of the fund's wish list and 'active enquiries' have already been launched by the fund about a bid for the site.

However, Mr Chande and Mr Myers are thought to be growing increasingly frustrated by the setbacks and delays they have faced in making their vision a reality.

Deloitte is not currently marketing the Old Town site because of concerns that it would not get the right value in the current market. The property tycoons may yet walk away unless Deloitte allows speedy progress on a potential deal.

If they regained control of the key Old Town site it is almost certain that the development would progress in line with the existing planning consent for a new five-star hotel and shops, offices and homes.

The Mountgrange Real Estate Opportunity Fund has raised the £300m from investors who include oil-rich sovereign wealth funds, endowment and pension funds and rich individuals. The fund, part of asset manager Mountgrange Investment Management (MIM), is entirely separate from Mountgrange Capital so is not affected by the latter being in administration.

It estimates that the money raised would enable it to borrow further funds and give it a net acquisition pot of about £850m.

One insider close to the development said: "Mountgrange are now with funds: formal funds of £850m for investment. They have made a statement of intent on Caltongate and they now have the funds to act on that."

Mountgrange Capital went into administration after Bank of Scotland withdrew funding. The bank is still owed £73.8m that it had invested in the company.

When Mountgrange's annual accounts were published earlier this year, the Caltongate land was valued at just over £20m, compared with £45m at its peak.

It is not known how much the administrator would demand for the site, which has the benefit of full planning consent. But it is understood it is looking to include the price of some of the assets the council still owns, including the Canongate Venture, in the deal.

Mr Chande, senior partner of MIM, said: "We believe there are opportunities in the UK which can provide substantial returns for our investors. Our task now is to bring these identified opportunities to fruition."

John Reid, joint administrator for Mountgrange at Deloitte, said: "We are not currently actively marketing the Caltongate site or soliciting offers at this time.

"At present, there remain certain matters to be concluded with regard to the land assembly and planning, which the administrators are progressing."

Ron Hewitt, Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce chief executive, said: "The fact that they (MIM] are able to raise more funding and want to invest it here shows the value in this."


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 May 2009 11:01 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Caltongate development
 
1

Logie Almond,

25/05/2009 12:21:25
What a bunch of crooks.
2

adogcatcherwearsauniformto,

musselburgh 25/05/2009 12:22:15
Opportunity how appropriate !
3

Jams,

Edinburgh 25/05/2009 12:25:24
If they can raise the funds to buy the site from the receiver why can they not take the development company out of receivership ?

Oh yes, I see! This way they get to write off a large chunk of debt and buy the site back for a fraction of what it is worth! Is it just me or does this stink to high heaven.

If you were really cynical you might think that they deliberately folded the development company with this idea in mind.
4

Bigwull,

edinburgh 25/05/2009 13:12:58
Jeeze these guys could teach MP's a thing or two about corruption.
5

Statsman,

Edinburgh 25/05/2009 13:28:08
Fold the company and start over debt free. Meanwhile other businesses are left out of pocket.

Anyone that does business with someone using this shady practice should be aware that they could do it all over again.
6

mad moo,

edinburgh 25/05/2009 14:07:35
Oh wait a minute
"But it is understood it is looking to include the price of some of the assets the council still owns, including the Canongate Venture, in the deal."

At what point did the Administrators take control over the Council....are things worse than they have told us ....CEC under administration?

What authority does Delotte have to be selling council and common good assets?

Surely if the council still wants to sell off land it must be agreed by a council committee, be subject to open competition and must achieve best value????
7

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 25/05/2009 14:34:35
This 'story' has all the credibility of a carefully-spun, kite-flying press release. Like a tale from 'Watchdog', but were're talking a lot more than a shoddy kitchen or double glazing. Why should the same 'interesting characters' who skipped off leaving the Bank of Scotland owed £73.8m be given another chance, especially as they don't have the benefit of their cronies at the City Chambers any more; Dear Leader Anderson and Dastardly Davies, with supporting cast of intellectual pygmies.
8

tomias,

Edinburgh 25/05/2009 16:06:20
This has been carefully fore planned;the hallmarks indicate a form of pre-emotive strike taught at legth at mba classes- not a lesson to follow but to avoid if even from a moral point of view.
The debts in forces free up money- the legalese used is also well scanned/scammed.
Whre are the ultimate share holders assets?
Carefull now
9

Rap,

25/05/2009 18:23:09
You should be flattered to hear Caltongate got a reference today in the Haymarket Inquiry. Mr Tiger was asked to list other world class hotel chains in Edinburgh and all he could name was Caltongate's Sofitel. Not that it actually exists in Edinburgh, or perhaps he knew today's news?

I do hope Deloitte and the Council see this as an opportunity to reconsider their previous bad decisions and see sense, and ignore Mountgrange MK II's new approach.
10

mad moo,

edinburgh 25/05/2009 19:09:57
Maybe its Mr Tiger who wants to build Caltongate as Mountgrange dont
yesterdays Herald made it clear that the abusive partner Mountgrange are seeking a divorce from the community of the Old Town

see
http://www.sundayherald.com/business/businessnews/display.var.2509980.0.breakdown_of_caltongate_marriage.php
11

Mallory,

Edinburgh 25/05/2009 19:27:21
Where do they get this stuff? AFAIK 'soverign wealth funds are not immune to the economioc slump. see http://tinyurl.com/p8vm59

so it would appear that Mountgrange never actually paid for some of the 'Council Owned' public assets which they claimed.

It should be remembered that the accounts that MG published this spring were for the previous year - ie before the worst of the 'crash' last summer. That will have further eaten into their capital base.

A glance at any of the serious daily press shows the parlous state of affairs at British Land and the rest. Even the poor old Duke of Westminster's property fund has shed half a billion pounds sterling in value.

The article looks like the PR puff from Property Week which presumably was to help convince investors that their loot is safe.

No doubt Edinburgh's common good assets remain in the safe hands of two un-elected city officials who will be ensuring the best return for Edinburgh residents and CT payers.

Just one further example of the democratic deficit which has grown under recent (local) governments.
12

Rap,

25/05/2009 21:30:19
So Mad Moo, not for the first time you think EEN is behind the times? Or mixed messages purposely being sent out to keep you on your toes?
13

Buttress,

25/05/2009 22:37:19
Jeez, do this lot at the EEN ever get anything right?

14

Buttress,

26/05/2009 00:14:53
"THE DEVELOPER behind the collapsed £300 million Caltongate project in Edinburgh has indicated for the first time that it will not attempt to revive the project.

Manish Chande, co-owner of Mountgrange Capital, which was forced into administration by its banker Lloyds in March, told the Sunday Herald he was "close to divorce" from the project, expressing impatience with the planning delays and heritage objections that have dogged the four-year project.

Chande's decision to draw a line under Mountgrange's involvement in Caltongate comes as administrator Deloitte said it had held talks with other potential developers and that a deal could be "months if not weeks" away. This runs contrary to reports that Lloyds was leaning on the administrator to mothball the site until the commercial property market picked up in value."

15

Pilrig,

Livingston 26/05/2009 05:40:12
Save Embra's hameless yuppies !
16

Salmond Rushdie,

26/05/2009 13:03:36
Easy solution - Deloitte's state they will not entertain any approach from Chande and his cohorts.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Should the Old Town’s Caltongate development be revived in its original form?
Yes, it was an innovative and stylish proposal
No, it was not in fitting with the Old Town
Yes, but it needs to be done more cheaply


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.